US 7,702,495 B2Grant

Three-dimensional finite-element code for electrosurgery and thermal ablation simulations

Issue Date:2010-04-20

•20 Claims

•13 Drawing Sheets

Abstract

A method for performing a simulation of an electrosurgical procedure is provided. The method includes the step of generating a three-dimensional model of a medium comprising one or more material regions representing a physical object or a region of the tissue. The method also includes the step of calculating one of an electrical energy solution and a thermal transport solution based on one of a mathematical model and finite element method. The method further includes the step of updating one or more property values of the material region in response to temperature changes based on an empirically derived value, wherein one of the electrical energy solution and the thermal transport solution is updated as a function of the updated property value.

Metadata

Assignee

Covidien AG

Inventors

Stanley Humphries
Kyle R. Rick
David A. Schechter
Nahum Goldberg

Application Information

Application Number:US 12/208,545

Filing Date:2008-09-11

Priority Date:2004-12-23

Art Unit:2123

Classifications

IPC:

G06F9/45

Patent Drawings (13 sheets)

Description

Cross-Reference to a Related Application

[0001] This application is a continuation of a U.S. application Ser. No. 11/314,332 filed on Dec. 21, 2005 now U.S. Pat. No. 7,467,075 which claims priority to U.S. Provisional Application Ser. No. 60/638,560 filed on Dec. 23, 2004, the entire contents of which are hereby incorporated by reference herein.

Background

[0002] 1. Field

[0003] The present disclosure relates generally to data processing and computer simulation systems, and more particularly, to a method and system for simulations electrosurgical RF thermal ablation processes.

[0004] 2. Description of the Related Art

[0005] Electrosurgery procedures involve the application of RF electric fields to produce local heating. The goal is to destroy or to alter selected tissues. Applications include blood-vessel cauterization, incision sealing and minimally-invasive procedures for tumor destruction. By their nature, electrosurgery procedures induce large changes in the thermal and electrical properties of tissue. In many procedures, the application of RF power follows a complex temporal sequence to ensure effective local treatment while minimizing damage to surrounding tissues. In the past, the design of equipment and the choice of operation sequence relied primarily on empirical experience. As a result, investigation of new applications is generally a long drawn out, difficult and costly process.

[0006] Computer simulations can play an important role in reducing the cost and time associated with certain experiments. In other words, simulations offer a relatively quick and inexpensive approach to fill in missing data points, to investigate novel methods or to optimize existing procedures.

[0007] Considering the complexity of electrosurgical procedures, generic finite-element software is generally not very useful. Conventional electrosurgical simulation software relies on two-dimensional simulations in cylindrical or planar geometries. Such software suites are incapable of determining end effects for many electrosurgical procedures. These software suites are also unable to provide solutions for simple electrosurgical probes which may be significantly altered by the presence of nearby asymmetric structures like blood vessels.

[0008] Therefore there exists a need for a system and method for simulation of electrosurgical procedures which provides solutions in a three-dimensional medium.

Summary

[0009] A method and system for simulating the effect of electrosurgical processes such as RF tumor ablation are provided. The method according to the present disclosure covers the complete calculation process from mesh generation to solution analysis. The method employs three-dimensional conformal meshes to handle cluster probes and other asymmetric assemblies. The conformal-mesh approach is advantageous for high-accuracy surface integrals of net electrode currents. The simulation algorithm performs coupled calculations of RF electric fields in conductive dielectrics and thermal transport via dynamic solutions of the bioheat equation. The boundary-value RF field solution is updated periodically to reflect changes in material properties.

[0010] The simulation algorithm also features advanced material models with the option for arbitrary temperature variations of thermal and electrical conductivity, perfusion rate, and other quantities. The algorithm handles irreversible changes by switching the material reference of individual elements at specified transition temperatures. The simulation algorithm is controlled through a versatile interpreter language to enable complex run sequences. The algorithm can also automatically maintain constant current or power, switch to different states in response to temperature or impedance information, and adjust parameters on the basis of user-supplied control functions.

[0011] According to one embodiment of the present disclosure a method for performing a simulation of an electrosurgical procedure is disclosed. The method includes the step of generating a three-dimensional model of a medium including one or more material regions representing a physical object or a region of the tissue. The method also includes the step of calculating one of an electrical energy solution and a thermal transport solution based on one of a mathematical model and finite element method. The method further includes the step of updating one or more property values of the material region in response to temperature changes based on an empirically derived value, wherein one of the electrical energy solution and the thermal transport solution is updated as a function of the updated property value.

[0012] According to another embodiment of the present disclosure, a system for performing a simulation of an electrosurgical procedure is disclosed. The system includes one or more processors coupled to a computer-readable media configured to store a set of instructions capable of being executed by the at least one processor. The instructions include the steps of generating a three-dimensional model of a medium including one or more material regions representing a physical object or a region of the tissue. The instructions also include the step of calculating one of an electrical energy solution and a thermal transport solution based on one of a mathematical model and finite element method. The instructions further include the step of updating one or more property values of the material region in response to temperature changes based on an empirically derived value, wherein one of the electrical energy solution and the thermal transport solution is updated as a function of the updated property value.

[0013] According to a further embodiment of the present disclosure, a computer-readable storage medium storing a set of computer-executable instructions for performing a simulation of an electrosurgical procedure is disclosed. The computer-executable instructions include the step of generating a three-dimensional model of a medium including one or more material regions representing a physical object or a region of the tissue. The instructions also include the step of calculating one of an electrical energy solution and a thermal transport solution based on one of a mathematical model and finite element method. The instructions further include the step of updating one or more property values of the material region in response to temperature changes based on an empirically derived value, wherein one of the electrical energy solution and the thermal transport solution is updated as a function of the updated property value.

Brief Description of the Drawings

[0014] The above and other aspects, features, and advantages of the present disclosure will become more apparent in light of the following detailed description when taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings in which:

[0015] FIG. 1 is a schematic diagram of an exemplary computer system;

[0016] FIG. 2A shows a non-conformal mesh including box elements;

[0017] FIG. 2B shows a conformal mesh including hexahedron elements;

[0018] FIG. 2C shows a three-dimensional hexahedron element;

[0019] FIG. 3 is an exemplary generated surface of a medium;

[0020] FIG. 4 is a graph defining a temperature-dependent electrical conductivity;

[0021] FIG. 5 is a screen shot of the software of the present disclosure for radio frequency electric fields illustrating analysis capabilities in a two-dimensional slice plot mode;

[0022] FIG. 6A illustrates an isothermal surface with gray scale coding determined by the magnitude of thermal flux;

[0023] FIG. 6B is a representation of region boundaries of the probe and sheath gray scale coded by temperature;

[0024] FIG. 7 shows voltage variation required to maintain constant current with decreasing conductivity for two values of a drive current;

[0025] FIG. 8 shows a two-dimensional slice plot of the electrical solution;

[0026] FIG. 9A is a plot of probe impedance over time in a solution volume;

[0027] FIG. 9B is a plot of maximum temperature over time in the solution volume; and

[0028] FIG. 10 shows spatial variation of electrical conductivity in a particular plane; and

[0029] FIG. 11 shows a flow chart illustrating a method according to the present disclosure.

Detailed Description

[0030] Preferred embodiments of the present disclosure are described herein with reference to the accompanying drawings. In the following description, well-known functions or constructions are not described in detail to avoid obscuring the present disclosure in unnecessary detail.

[0031] 1. Introduction

[0032] It is to be understood that the present disclosure may be implemented in various forms of hardware, software, firmware, special purpose processors, or a combination thereof. In one embodiment, the present disclosure may be implemented in software as an application program tangibly embodied on a program storage device. The application program may be uploaded to, and executed by, a computer system 100 including any suitable architecture such as a personal computer, a workstation or server. The system 100 is implemented on a computer platform having hardware such as one or more central processing units (CPU) (e.g., processor 102), a random access memory (RAM) 104, a read only memory (ROM) 106 and input/output (I/O) interface(s) such as a keyboard 108, cursor control device (e.g., a mouse or joystick) 110 and display device 112. A system bus 115 couples the various components and may be any of several types of bus structures including a memory bus or memory controller, a peripheral bus, and a local bus using any of a variety of bus architectures. The computer platform also includes an operating system and micro instruction code, which may be stored in a data storage device 114. The various processes and functions described herein may either be part of the micro instruction code or part of the application program (or a combination thereof) which is executed via the operating system. In addition, various other peripheral devices may be connected to the computer platform by various interfaces and bus structures, such as a parallel port, serial port or universal serial bus (USB), for example, additional storage devices and a printer.

[0033] It is to be further understood that because some of the constituent system components and method steps depicted in the accompanying figures may be implemented in software, the actual connections between the system components (or the process steps) may differ depending upon the manner in which the present disclosure is programmed. Given the teachings of the present disclosure provided herein, one of ordinary skill in the related art will be able to contemplate these and similar implementations or configurations of the present disclosure.

[0034] The simulation algorithm according to present disclosure may be run on personal computers under Microsoft Windows™ or Linux™ operating systems and/or software. The algorithm includes an interactive mesh generator, solution programs for RF fields and thermal transport and dedicated post-processors for plots and data analysis. The method according to present disclosure utilizes conformal hexahedron meshes for high-accuracy surface integrals, calculates electrical and thermal solutions with temperature-dependent effects, incorporates advanced material models, and further includes a built-in script interpreter with a flexible control language for autonomous operation.

[0035] The following section, Section 2, describes the nature of conformal hexahedron meshes and the tools used for their creation. Section 3 covers solution methods for coupled RF electric fields and thermal transport. Section 4 reviews techniques for modeling temperature-dependent properties of materials (including phase changes) while Section 5 describes methods to operate probes at fixed current or as part of a temperature-control loop. Features of the interpreter language for sequence control are described in Section 6. Features of the postprocessors are covered in Section 7. Section 8 presents examples that illustrate some advanced features of the algorithm.

[0036] 2. Mesh Generation

[0037] The foundation of the finite-element method for field solutions is to divide the solution space (e.g., a segment and/or medium 8 of a simulated surgical site) into small volumes (e.g., elements). The division is performed in such a way that each element is uniquely part of one material region. In particular, the material regions may also represent electrodes, insulators or different types of tissue (e.g., blood vessels, muscles, etc.). This process simplifies the calculations as well as the organization of the code—only one material model is applied to each element. The division facilitates the conversion of the governing partial differential equations for RF fields and temperature to large sets of coupled linear equations. Such equation systems are easily solved on a digital computer, an example of which is discussed above.

[0038] The simplest way to divide space, e.g., medium 8, is the non-conformal mesh 10 of FIG. 2A which employs box elements. However, this approach leads to a poor representation of surfaces between material regions since curved surfaces are approximated and are not accurately represented. As a result, field calculations near the surface of material regions are inaccurate. For example, surface integrals of current over the sphere represented by non-conformal mesh may be inaccurate.

[0039] FIG. 2B shows a conformal mesh 12 representing the medium 8, which gives highly-accurate results in surface field calculations. In a conformal mesh, elements are flexed near region boundaries so that facets lie close to the desired shape. The box elements are transformed to generalized hexahedrons. An exemplary hexahedron element 14 is shown in FIG. 2C.

[0040] Mesh generation is accomplished by ordering elements 14 according to cubic logic. However, elements 14 may have arbitrary shapes. The element 14 includes a plurality of facets 16 and nodes 18 (e.g., indices). The facets 16 may meet at a variety of angles allowing for flexible shapes which more closely approximate the medium. In other words, each element has a unique set of indices along the coordinate axes such that element (I+1, J, K) is adjacent to element (I, J, K). Mesh structure allows faster field solutions, where the boundary-value solution for RF electric field may be updated hundreds of times during execution with temperature-dependent materials.

[0041] FIG. 3 illustrates an exemplary generated surface of the medium 8, which includes mathematically-generated surfaces from a Table 1 containing elevation values. The mesh in the FIG. 3 combines a mathematical surface representative of tissue 20 with an extrusion (e.g., electrosurgical probe 32).

[0042] Table 1 shows the script to generate the shapes. In the present disclosure, the program was adapted to use constructive solid geometry techniques to fabricate complex assemblies from simple parts (i.e., cylinders, spheres and cones, extrusions, turnings, etc.).

[0043]

TABLE 1

MetaMesh script to generate FIG. 3


PART	Type	Surf 3D FIG.D02.DATE
	Name	TestSurface
	Region	TestSurface
	Fab	−1.00
	Surface	Region	SVolume 1.00
END
PART
	Type	Extrusion
	L	−1.0	−1.0	1.0	−1.0 S
	L	1.0	−1.0	1.0	0.0 S
	A	1.0	0.0	0.0	1.0	0.0	0.0 S
	A	0.0	1.0	−1.0	0.0	0.0	0.0 S
	L	−1.0	0.0	−1.0	−1.0 S
	End
	Region	Electrode
	Fab	9.00
	Surface	Region		SVolume
	Rotate	0.0	0.0	180.0
END

[0044] 3. Field Solution Techniques

[0045] Electrosurgery simulations involve two finite-element solutions: radiofrequency (“RF”) electric fields and thermal transport Structures generated in the medium are common to both solutions. Consequently, the method of the present disclosure uses the same mesh for the RF and thermal solutions, assigning different physical properties to the regions. Because there is little change in thermal properties over a period of the RF field, the electric field solution is handled as a boundary value problem with periodic updating. The following equation governs the RF electric field solution:

[0046]

\begin{matrix} \nabla \cdot [(ɛ_{r} - \frac{jσ}{ɛ_{0} ω}) \nabla ϕ] = 0 & (1) \end{matrix}

[0047] In Equation 1, ∈_ris the relative dielectric constant of the element 14 and σ is the electrical conductivity. The quantity φ (the quasi-static potential) is a complex number. The amplitude and phase of the electric field is given by:
E=−∇φ (2)

[0048] The electric field provides one of the source terms for the thermal transport equation.
q_e=σE·E*/2 (3)

[0049] Equations 1 and 2 include effects of both real and displacement currents and hold in the non-radiative limit. The validity condition is that the radiated electromagnetic energy leaving the patient is small compared to the deposited energy. The condition holds when the RF wavelength is large compared to the treatment area.

[0050] Conversion of Equation 1 to finite-element form uses the standard minimum-residual method with quasi-linear shape functions for the hexahedron elements 14. The resulting linear equation set determines φ at the element 14 node locations. Each equation involves coupling to 27 neighboring nodes. The coupling coefficients are computed by taking numerical integrals over elements using the normal coordinate method. The equations are solved with an interactive matrix-inversion technique. An initial electric field solution with 400,000 nodes requires about 2 minutes on a 3.0 GHz computer. The solution time is shorter for updates with temperature-dependent ∈_ror σ if changes are relatively small.

[0051] The method of the present disclosure solves the following relationship (often known as the bioheat equation) for thermal transport;

[0052]

\begin{matrix} {pC}_{p} \frac{\partial T}{\partial t} = \nabla \cdot (k \nabla T) + q_{e} + q_{m} + W_{b} (T_{b} - T) & (4) \end{matrix}

[0053] In Equation 4, ρ is the density of the medium, C_pis the specific heat, k is the thermal conductivity, q_eis the resistive source from Equation 3 and q_mis any other source such as metabolism. The term W_b(T_b−T) is a thermal source or sink resulting from the volume-averaged perfusion of blood through capillaries. Here, W_bis the blood flow rate and T_bis the incoming blood temperature.

[0054] The system and method of the present disclosure recast the minimum-residual formulation for the conformal mesh to reduce coupling to the six nearest nodes. The resulting solutions are fast and stable for all mesh geometries and choices of time step at the expense of some reduction in accuracy.

[0055] Execution of the algorithm consists of an initial RF solution followed by a thermal solution over a specified time span. Temperature-dependent thermal quantities are updated each time step. The electric field must be updated periodically if materials have temperature-dependent values of ∈_ror σ. Electrical field updates may consume considerable time, so it is essential to minimize operations in three-dimensional solutions with large meshes. Accordingly, the code implementing the method has been carefully analyzed to eliminate unnecessary or redundant operations. Several techniques have been implemented to reduce run time, such as variable time steps with automatic adjustment are used in the thermal solution. Further, whenever possible, the RF solution is scaled rather than recomputed. The program utilizes precomputed baseline RF solutions during pulsed RF simulations. In addition, element properties and coupling coefficients for the RF and thermal solutions are updated only for temperature-dependent materials.

[0056] 4. Material Models and Temporal Variations

[0057] Electrosurgery simulations usually involve materials with significant variations of properties with temperature. Therefore, the system and method of the present disclosure, uses a flexible method of tabular functions to represent arbitrary temperature and time variations. A table is simply a text file where each line contains one value of an independent and dependent variable (e.g., temperature T and thermal conductivity k(T)).

[0058] FIG. 4 shows a typical data set to represent a temperature-dependent electrical conductivity which is shown as a graph of electrical conductivity over temperature. Electrical conductivity of materials (e.g., tissue) varies with temperature, therefore the method and system according to the present disclosure account for these variations by updating RF field calculations.

[0059] The system and method incorporates a software unit to perform cubic spline or linear interpolations. The unit is designed so that tables appear as a continuous function to the calling program. The routines handle non-uniform intervals of the dependent variable. Flexibility is achieved through a free-form parser with automatic sorting and error checking. Tabular input has several advantages for the user, including data transparency, the option to maintain standard material libraries, efficient input of digitized or published data and easy electronic exchange of models.

[0060] Fixed values or tables may be applied to the following quantities in Equations 1 and 4: ∈_r, σ, C_p, k and W_b. Physical quantities are assigned to materials. The program accepts up to 127 different material types. The elements of the mesh are divided into regions that represent physical objects like tissue types, dielectrics or electrodes. In turn, an element with a given region number is assigned an initial material and may be associated with different materials, depending on its thermal history. Flexible material assignment is the key to the implementation of phase changes. The properties of a region represented by a single table are non-linear but reversible. If the tissue cools, it returns to its original state.

[0061] The algorithm according to present disclosure represents permanent state changes by reassigning the material reference when the element reaches a setpoint temperature. The algorithm also maintains values of the Arrhenius damage integral that represent the extent of chemical changes. Damage integral values can also be used as setpoints. With the reassignment method, properties can be permanently changed, even if the element cools. For example, a particular element 14 is originally associated with a material with electrical conductivity that drops sharply at 100° C. At this temperature, the reference is shifted to a material with the properties of desiccated tissue. The conductivity will not rise even if the electrical power and temperature drops. All elements of a region have the same region number but may have different material associations. A region may have up to five alternate materials with ascending temperature or damage-integral setpoints.

[0062] 5. Fixed-Current Operation and Temperature Control

[0063] As mentioned in Section 3, the RF solution yields the quasi-static potential at all points in solution volume for specified electrode potentials. In many applications, the equipment operates at fixed current or power rather than voltage. These global quantities are not natural boundary conditions of Equation 1, the method of the present disclosure uses an indirect approach. The current or power is calculated using the present voltages and material states. An adjustment factor to achieve the desired state is calculated and used to scale potential values.

[0064] The global power P₀is calculated by taking a volume integral of time-averaged resistive power density (σEE*/2) over all material elements of the solution volume. In multi-electrode systems, the method assigns a general amplitude change to all electrodes. If P is the desired power level, then potential values are scaled by √{square root over (P/P₀)}. The calculation of current from an electrode requires a surface integral of current density over the fixed-potential region. Initially, the method gathers a list of facets of fixed-potential region elements that are common to conductive/dielectric elements. The program determines the current passing through each facet using a 4×4 normal coordinate integral of normal electric field, and sums the real and displacement currents to find the amplitude I₀. If I is the desired current amplitude, potential values at all nodes are scaled by I/I₀.

[0065] The tabular functions described in Section 4 are also employed in the method of the present disclosure to represent arbitrary temporal variations such as a time-dependent thermal source q_mor boundary temperature. The program also stores several generalized functions that are used for feedback control. In this case, the method uses a region-averaged temperature as the independent variable and use the tabular function output as a multiplying factor for probe voltages. The method generates a programmed voltage to maintain average temperature in a region near 60.0° C. The control function capability makes the method of the present disclosure a useful tool to test the dynamics and stability of control loops in electrosurgery equipment.

[0066] 6. Sequence Control

[0067] Because of wide variety of operating modes encountered in electrosurgery and RF ablation procedures, the system and method of the present disclosure include a versatile control capability based on a custom interpreter language. The program makes decisions and change operating modes depending on the temperature history of the medium. The organization of the control script follows the logic of an actual treatment. Initially there are given conditions that are not controlled by the operator: the geometry of the patient and probe and the intrinsic properties of materials (including temperature dependencies). During the procedure, the operator modifies applied voltages and the pulse sequence in response to changes of electrical and thermal properties. Accordingly, the control script contains one SETUP section for the definition of general control parameters and material properties. This section is followed by an unlimited set of STATE sections. Each STATE section represents a particular activity that the operator may choose, such as, for example, “apply 2000 mA current until the probe impedance rises 10% from its initial value,” or “lower the voltage to half its present value until the maximum temperature of the region drops to less than 60° C.”

[0068] STATE commands perform the following exemplary types of activities: 1) setting STATE properties such as the maximum duration and frequency of command updates; 2) setting parameters of the RF solution such as voltage amplitude and phase, frequency or global power; 3) returning values of state variables such as average temperature in a region, elapsed time in a STATE, and electrode current; 4) storing numbers in program variables with the operation to perform a broad range of mathematical operations; 6) testing conditions to exit a STATE; and 7) implement control loops to repeat a group of STATES.

[0069] Table 2 below shows an example of the control language.

[0070]

	TABLE 2

	X(4) = 28.0
	Relax
	X(10) = Impedance(3)
	X(2) = X(10) 1.15 *
	ENDSTATE
	#STARTLOOP
	STATE 200.0 2.5
	Voltage(3) = X(4)
	Relax
	Show Impedance(3)
	Show MaxTemp
	X(3) = StateTime
	X(1) = Impedance(3)
	Test X(1) > X(2)
	ENDSTATE
	STATE 0.0 0.0
	Test X(3) > 10.0
	X(5) = X(4) 1.0 -
	X(4) = X(5)
	ENDSTATE
	STATE 15.0 15.0
	Voltage(3) = 2.0
	Relax
	ENDSTATE
	#GOTO STARTLOOP 402.0

[0071] The algorithm according to the present disclosure records a variety of diagnostic data during the thermal solution. The program creates data files (snapshots of the RF or thermal solutions) at up to 500 specified times. The program also allows the user to place up to 20 diagnostic probes at different positions in the solution volume. The probes generate output files containing complete records of temporal variations of electric and thermal quantities.

[0072] 7. Analysis Tools

[0073] The method of the present disclosure includes dedicated post-processors to generate plots and to analyze RF and thermal solutions. The method features interactive graphical capabilities that allow the user to move easily through the solution volume. Two dimensional plots show quantities in a plane normal to the x, y or z axes. There are two styles. First, is a plane plot which is a projection of field quantities to a rectangular grid. The simple grid makes it possible to construct advanced displays such as 2D and 3D filled-contour plots. Second, is a slice plot which is a projection that preserves the structure of the conformal mesh. This mode accurately shows regions boundaries and allows point-and-click display of point or scan quantities in a particular plane of the medium 8.

[0074] An exemplary slice plot 30 of the medium 8 is shown FIG. 5. The slice plot 30 displays an electrosurgical probe 32 generating an electric field 33 represented by contour lines 34. RF solution quantities that are displayed include the quasi-static potential, electric field components, real and displacement currents and power density. The program shows either the amplitude of field quantities or a snapshot of the field at a given reference phase.

[0075] The method according to the present disclosure also plots spatial variations of ∈_r(T) and σ(T) for solutions with temperature-dependent materials. Thermal quantities plotted include the temperature and thermal flux. Spatial variations in k(T), C_p(T), and W_b(T) are displayed for solutions with temperature-dependent materials.

[0076] Solutions are also represented using advanced 3D plots with surfaces constructed directly from the conformal mesh. FIGS. 6A-B show two examples. FIG. 6A shows an isothermal surface with identifying regions thermal flux of the medium 8. In particular, FIG. 6A shows the probe 32 having an exposed electrically conductive shaft 31 and an insulated sheath 35 within a tissue 36. It is envisioned that color coding (shown in gray scale) may be used to illustrate gradual shifting of the thermal solution. On the right side of the plot, a gray scale coded index 40 is shown. It is envisioned that the index 40 may also be color-coded to better represent the gradations in thermal flux of the plot. This type of plot is useful for displaying the shape of the treatment volume.

[0077] FIG. 6B shows boundary facets on selected regions. FIG. 6B also shows the probe 32 having with the shaft 31 and the sheath 35. This plot type is useful to display surface temperatures on electrodes and organs. By splitting objects into two or more regions, it is possible to display temperature variations on arbitrary three-dimensional surfaces. On the right side of the plot, a gray scale coded index 42 is shown. It is envisioned that the index 42 may also be color-coded to better represent the gradations in temperature of the plot.

[0078] Both post-processors have extensive capabilities for quantitative analysis. These include point calculations and line scans using a second-order, least-squares-fit procedure. Information is displayed within the program or is ported to an analysis history file in text format. Line scans generate screen plots with digital oscilloscope features. Complex or repetitive operations are controlled by scripts. The program performs automatic volume integrals over regions of the solution space. Calculated quantities include RF field energy, total resistive power dissipation, and average temperature. Surface integrals employ the same routines for current calculations. Output quantities include net current or thermal flux. The post-processors include the option to create matrix files where electrical or thermal quantities are projected from the conformal mesh to regular box mesh.

[0079] 8. Application Examples

[0080] This section reviews two examples that illustrate some of the features of the system and method of the present disclosure. The first example addresses solution accuracy, operation at constant current and the ability to handle temperature-dependent materials. The simple test geometry consists of concentric cooled spherical electrodes of radii r_i=1.0 cm and r_o=5.0 cm separated by a uniform medium with ∈_r=1.0. The electrical conductivity is defined by a table with values that start at σ=1.0 S/m at T=0.0° C. and drop smoothly to 0.2 S/m in the range T=20.0° C. to T=120.0° C. Both electrodes are maintained at a reference temperature of 0.0° C. The outer electrode is grounded and the inner electrode has a time-dependent voltage to maintain constant current. The medium has the thermal properties k=100.0 W/m-° C., C_p=4800.0 J/kg-° C. and ρ=1000.0 kg/m³. The approximate side length of the elements near the inner sphere is 0.1 cm.

[0081] The total current flowing through the medium is determined by a surface integral of normal electric field over the inner sphere. Initially all elements are near 0.0° C. and the conductivity is σ≅1.0 S/m. This allows for comparison of the impedance calculated by the algorithm to the analytic formula:

[0082]

\begin{matrix} R = \frac{(\frac{1}{r_{1}} - \frac{1}{r_{0}})}{4 π σ} & (5) \end{matrix}

Inserting values in Equation 5 gives 6.366 Ω, while the calculation using the method according to the present disclosure yields 6.371 Ω. The small difference results from the fact that the shape used by the method of the present disclosure is a multi-faceted polyhedron rather than a sphere, therefore it is a close approximation of the actual shape of the medium 8.

[0083] The thermal solution advances for 50 seconds with a variable time step. The control script contains three STATES. The first sets up a baseline RF solution at f=60.0 Hz with 250 V applied to inner sphere. The second STATE advances the thermal solution for 10 seconds and updates commands at 1 second intervals to include effects of changing electrical conductivity. The STATE includes the command Current(3)=5.7.

[0084] The command maintains approximately constant current from the inner sphere by correcting the voltage. In response to the command, the algorithm recalculates the field every 1.0 second, takes the surface integral to determine the current, and scales potential values in the solution space to bring the current to 5.7 Amps. Additional commands instruct the program to record values of voltage and maximum temperature in the solution volume at each update. The third state (which runs from 10 to 50 seconds) has the same commands with an update interval of 2.5 seconds.

[0085] FIG. 7 shows the voltage variation required to maintain constant current with decreasing conductivity for two values of the drive current. The 5.8 Amp curve 50 exhibits thermal run-away, while a curve 52 does not have a similar defect, A constant-current solution may become unstable when the electrical conductivity drops with increasing temperature. Thermal run-away is a real effect rather than a numerical artifact; similar phenomena are observed in experiments with electrosurgery equipment. FIG. 7 demonstrates that non-linear solutions must be approached with caution—a small change in input may make a dramatic difference in output.

[0086] FIG. 8 shows a two dimensional slice plot of the electrical solution. Here, the probe 32 with length 3.0 cm is inserted in a 2.0 cm diameter tumor 54 within a liver 56. The calculation was performed in single octant with symmetry boundaries at x=0.0, y=0.0 and z=0.0 using a mesh of 74,000 elements. In the calculation, both the liver 56 and tumor 54 have the conductivity variation shown in FIG. 4. Electrical conductivity rises 2% per degree up to around 100° C. where a sharp drop represents tissue vaporization.

[0087] Table 2 above shows the main portions of the STATE sections of the control script. The included commands from the initial STATE store a value of applied voltage in program variable X(4) as a parameter, calculate a baseline normalized solution to determine the zero-temperature impedance and set a trigger level 15% higher. The next three STATES are contained in a loop that runs for a maximum time of 402 seconds. The commands of the first STATE sets the voltage to X(4) and advance the thermal solution until either: 1) the state time reaches 200 seconds or 2) the impedance exceeds the trigger level. The RF solution is updated and checks are performed at 2.5 second intervals.

[0088] The second STATE has zero duration so the commands are executed only once per loop cycle. No action is taken if the duration of the previous state exceeds 10 seconds. Otherwise, the baseline voltage is reduced by 1.0 V. The commands of the third STATE reduce the voltage to 2.0 V and advance the thermal solution for 15 seconds to allow cooling of the region near the probe.

[0089] The algorithm according to the present disclosure also outputs data in a variety of graph, such as impedance over time and temperature over time plots shown in FIGS. 9A and 9B respectively. In the first pulse cycle, the impedance initially drops as the medium heats and then follows a rapid rise as the medium around the probe tip approaches 100° C. In the impedance plot, triggering does not occur exactly at the setpoint level of 300 Ω because checks are performed only at 2.5 second intervals. The temperature plot of FIG. 9B shows the maximum temperature recorded in the solution space at a point near the tip of the probe 32 in the region of enhanced electric field. Records of temperature at other positions confirm that the pulse cycle restricts temperature in the bulk of medium surrounding the probe to values less than 100° C.

[0090] In addition, the algorithm also displays electrical conductivity plots. FIG. 10 shows the spatial distribution of electrical conductivity in the plane y=0.0 late in the pulse (t=65.1 seconds). Although some areas have enhanced conductivity, σ is sharply reduced near a region 60 representing the tip of the probe 32. On the right side of the plot, a gray scale coded index 62 is shown. It is envisioned that the index 62 may also be color-coded to better represent the gradations in electrical conductivity of the plot.

[0091] The simulation involves 120 recalculations of the electrical field with a total run time of 22 minutes on a 3 GHz computer. The example illustrates that complex three-dimensional simulations are feasible on standard personal computers with careful pre-analysis to eliminate unnecessary details.

[0092] FIG. 11 shows a flow chart illustrating the method according to the present disclosure. In step 300, the processor 102 generates the medium 8. The medium 8 may include the tissue 20 with the probe 32 therein as shown in FIG. 3. In step 302, the processor 102 divides the medium into hexahedron elements 14 to generate the three-dimensional conformal mesh 12 as shown in FIG. 2C. In step 304, the processor 102 assigns each element 14 to a specific material region. For example, elements 14 within the protrusion of the probe 32 as shown in FIG. 3 are assigned to a material region of the probe, while elements 14 within the tissue 20 are assigned into the corresponding material region. In step 306, the processor 102 calculates the electrical energy solution and the thermal transport solution. In step 308, the display device 112 outputs graphical representations of the solutions, such as various plots illustrated in FIGS. 5-10.

[0093] While the disclosure has been shown and described with reference to certain preferred embodiments thereof it will be understood by those skilled in the art that various changes in form and detail may be made therein without departing from the spirit and scope of the disclosure.

Claims

What is claimed is:

1. A processor implemented method for simulating an electrosurgical procedure, the method comprising the steps of:

generating, using a processor, a three-dimensional model of a medium including at least one material region representing at least one of a physical object and a region of the tissue;

calculating, using the processor, at least one of an electrical energy solution and a thermal transport solution based on at least one mathematical model and finite element method; and

updating, using the processor, at least one property value of the at least one material region at least once in response to temperature changes based on an empirically derived value, wherein at least one of the electrical energy solution and the thermal transport solution is updated as a function of the at least one property value.

2. The method according to claim 1, further comprising the steps of:

dividing, using the processor, the model of the medium into a plurality of hexahedron elements to generate a three-dimensional conformal mesh;

assigning, using the processor, each element to a corresponding at least one material region; and

calculating, using the processor, at least one of an electrical energy solution and a thermal transport solution based on at least one mathematical model, the plurality of hexahedron elements and finite element method.

3. The method according to claim 2, further comprising the step of:

generating and displaying at least one graphical representation representing at least one form of the electrical energy solution and one form of the thermal transport solution on an output device.

4. The method according to claim 2, wherein the plurality of elements are ordered in the three-dimensional mesh according to cubic logic.

5. The method according to claim 2, wherein the graphical representation is a three-dimensional plot and the at least one form of the thermal solution is an isothermal surface of the medium.

6. The method according to claim 2, wherein the graphical representation is a two dimensional slice plot and the at least one form of the electrical solution is electrical conductivity of the medium.

7. The method according to claim 1, wherein the step of calculating the electrical energy solution further comprises a step of solving equations 1 and 2

\begin{matrix} \nabla \cdot [(ɛ_{r} - \frac{jσ}{ɛ_{0} ω}) \nabla ϕ] = 0 & (1) \\ E = - \nabla ϕ & (2) \end{matrix}

wherein ∈_ris a relative dielectric constant, and σ is electrical conductivity of each of the elements, j is an imaginary number, ∈₀is vacuum permittivity, ω is angular frequency, φ is a quasi-static potential, which is a complex number, and E is amplitude and phase of electric field.

8. The method as in claim 7, wherein the step of calculating the thermal transport solution further comprising a step of solving equations 3 and 4:

q_e=σE·E*/2 (3)

ρC_pδT/δt=∇·(k∇T)+q_c+q_m+W_b(T_b−T) (4)

wherein ρ is density of the medium, C_ρis specific heat, k is thermal conductivity, q_mis heat generated by metabolism, q_eis resistive source, and W_b(T_b−T) represents thermal variations caused by blood flow.

9. The method according to claim 1, wherein the at least one property value is representative of at least one physical property selected from the group consisting of relative dielectric constant, electrical conductivity, specific heat, thermal conductivity and blood flow.

10. The method according to claim 9, wherein the at least one physical property is temperature-dependent.

11. The method according to claim 9, wherein a tabular function stores a plurality of temperature-dependent values for the at least one physical property.

12. A system for performing a simulation of an electrosurgical procedure on tissue, the system comprising:

at least one processor coupled to a computer-readable medium configured to store a set of instructions to be executed by the at least one processor, the medium including instructions for:

generating a three-dimensional model of a medium including at least one material region representing at least one of a physical object and a region of the tissue;

calculating at least one of an electrical energy solution and a thermal transport solution based on at least one mathematical model and finite element method; and

updating at least one property value of the at least one material region at least once in response to temperature changes based on an empirically derived value, wherein at least one of the electrical energy solution and the thermal transport solution is updated as a function of the at least one property value.

13. The system according to claim 12, wherein the medium further includes instructions for:

dividing the model of the medium into a plurality of hexahedron elements to generate a three-dimensional conformal mesh;

assigning each element to a corresponding at least one material region; and

calculating at least one of an electrical energy solution and a thermal transport solution based on at least one mathematical model, the plurality of hexahedron elements and finite element method.

14. The system according to claim 12, further comprising:

an output device configured to output at least one graphical representation representing at least one form of the electrical energy solution and one form of the thermal transport solution.

15. The system according to claim 12, wherein the at least one property value is representative of at least one physical property selected from the group consisting of relative dielectric constant, electrical conductivity, specific heat, thermal conductivity and blood flow.

16. The system according to claim 15, wherein the at least one physical property is temperature-dependent.

17. The system according to claim 15 wherein a tabular function stores a plurality of temperature-dependent values for the at least one physical property.

18. A computer-readable storage medium storing a set of computer-executable instructions for performing a simulation of an electrosurgical procedure, the medium comprising instructions for:

generating a three-dimensional model of a medium including at least one material region representing at least one of a physical object and a region of the tissue;

calculating at least one of an electrical energy solution and a thermal transport solution based on at least one mathematical model and finite element method; and

19. The computer-readable storage medium according to claim 18, wherein the medium further includes instructions for:

dividing the model of the medium into a plurality of hexahedron elements to generate a three-dimensional conformal mesh;

assigning each element to a corresponding at least one material region; and

calculating at least one of an electrical energy solution and a thermal transport solution based on at least one mathematical model, the plurality of hexahedron elements and finite element method.

20. The computer-readable storage medium according to claim 18, wherein the medium further includes instructions for:

generating and displaying at least one graphical representation representing at least one form of the electrical energy solution and one form of the thermal transport solution on an output device.

Patent Citations (132)

Patent	Date	Inventor	Cited By
US4074718(A)	1978-02-01	Morrison, Jr. et al.	Applicant
US4411266(A)	1983-10-01	Cosman	Applicant
US4565200(A)	1986-01-01	Cosman	Applicant
US4576177(A)	1986-03-01	Webster, Jr.	Applicant
US4608977(A)	1986-09-01	Brown	Applicant
US4662383(A)	1987-05-01	Sogawa et al.	Applicant
US4739759(A)	1988-04-01	Rexroth et al.	Applicant
US4832024(A)	1989-05-01	Boussignac et al.	Applicant
US4880719(A)	1989-11-01	Murofushi et al.	Applicant
US4961435(A)	1990-10-01	Kitagawa et al.	Applicant
US4966597(A)	1990-10-01	Cosman	Applicant
US4993430(A)	1991-02-01	Shimoyama et al.	Applicant
US5029588(A)	1991-07-01	Yock et al.	Applicant
US5103804(A)	1992-04-01	Abele et al.	Applicant
US5225741(A)	1993-07-01	Auld et al.	Applicant
US5230623(A)	1993-07-01	Guthrie et al.	Applicant
US5267994(A)	1993-12-01	Gentelia et al.	Applicant
US5281213(A)	1994-01-01	Milder et al.	Applicant
US5323778(A)	1994-06-01	Kandarpa et al.	Applicant
US5330518(A)	1994-07-01	Neilson et al.	Applicant
US5334193(A)	1994-08-01	Nardella	Applicant
US5342357(A)	1994-08-01	Nardella	Applicant
US5348554(A)	1994-09-01	Imran et al.	Applicant
US5370675(A)	1994-12-01	Edwards et al.	Applicant
US5383876(A)	1995-01-01	Nardella	Applicant
US5383917(A)	1995-01-01	Desai et al.	Applicant
US5385148(A)	1995-01-01	Lesh et al.	Applicant
US5403311(A)	1995-04-01	Abele et al.	Applicant
US5409000(A)	1995-04-01	Imran	Applicant
US5409006(A)	1995-04-01	Buchholtz et al.	Applicant
US5433739(A)	1995-07-01	Sluijter et al.	Applicant
US5458597(A)	1995-10-01	Edwards et al.	Applicant
US5462521(A)	1995-10-01	Brucker et al.	Applicant
US5472441(A)	1995-12-01	Edwards et al.	Applicant
US5490850(A)	1996-02-01	Ellman et al.	Applicant
US5500012(A)	1996-03-01	Brucker et al.	Applicant
US5520684(A)	1996-05-01	Imran	Applicant
US5536267(A)	1996-07-01	Edwards et al.	Applicant
US5571147(A)	1996-11-01	Sluijter et al.	Applicant
US5588432(A)	1996-12-01	Crowley	Applicant
US5599345(A)	1997-02-01	Edwards et al.	Applicant
US5647871(A)	1997-07-01	Levine et al.	Applicant
US5662111(A)	1997-09-01	Cosman	Applicant
US5688267(A)	1997-11-01	Panescu et al.	Applicant
US5735847(A)	1998-04-01	Gough et al.	Applicant
US5775338(A)	1998-07-01	Hastings	Applicant
US5792146(A)	1998-08-01	Cosman	Applicant
US5830133(A)	1998-11-01	Osten et al.	Applicant
US5848967(A)	1998-12-01	Cosman	Applicant
US5849011(A)	1998-12-01	Jones et al.	Applicant
US5868740(A)	1999-02-01	LeVeen et al.	Applicant
US5921982(A)	1999-07-01	Lesh et al.	Applicant
US5951546(A)	1999-09-01	Lorentzen	Applicant
US6001093(A)	1999-12-01	Swanson et al.	Applicant
US6006126(A)	1999-12-01	Cosman	Applicant
US6053912(A)	2000-04-01	Panescu et al.	Applicant
US6059780(A)	2000-05-01	Gough et al.	Applicant
US6061551(A)	2000-05-01	Sorrells et al.	Applicant
US6074389(A)	2000-06-01	Levine et al.	Applicant
US6080149(A)	2000-06-01	Huang et al.	Applicant
US6106524(A)	2000-08-01	Eggers et al.	Applicant
US6134476(A)	2000-10-01	Arndt et al.	Applicant
US6146380(A)	2000-11-01	Racz et al.	Applicant
US6162216(A)	2000-12-01	Guziak et al.	Applicant
US6203541(B1)	2001-03-01	Keppel	Applicant
US6241725(B1)	2001-06-01	Cosman	Applicant
US6287305(B1)	2001-09-01	Heim et al.	Applicant
US6306132(B1)	2001-10-01	Moorman et al.	Applicant
US6337998(B1)	2002-01-01	Behl et al.	Applicant
US6398782(B1)	2002-06-01	Pecor et al.	Applicant
US6470217(B1)	2002-10-01	Fenn et al.	Applicant
US6478793(B1)	2002-11-01	Cosman et al.	Applicant
US6500172(B1)	2002-12-01	Panescu et al.	Applicant
US6506189(B1)	2003-01-01	Rittman, III et al.	Applicant
US6530922(B2)	2003-03-01	Cosman et al.	Applicant
US6546270(B1)	2003-04-01	Goldin et al.	Applicant
US6575969(B1)	2003-06-01	Rittman, III et al.	Applicant
US6605085(B1)	2003-08-01	Edwards	Applicant
US6614422(B1)	2003-09-01	Rafii et al.	Applicant
US6673070(B2)	2004-01-01	Edwards et al.	Applicant
US6675050(B2)	2004-01-01	Arndt et al.	Applicant
US6918907(B2)	2005-07-01	Kelly et al.	Applicant
US7004174(B2)	2006-02-01	Eggers et al.	Applicant
US7008421(B2)	2006-03-01	Steven et al.	Applicant
US7041101(B2)	2006-05-01	Eggers	Applicant
US7083615(B2)	2006-08-01	Peterson et al.	Applicant
US7131970(B2)	2006-11-01	Moses	Applicant
US7150749(B2)	2006-12-01	Dycus	Applicant
US7156846(B2)	2007-01-01	Dycus	Applicant
US7166075(B2)	2007-01-01	Varghese et al.	Applicant
US7166102(B2)	2007-01-01	Fleenor et al.	Applicant
US7189231(B2)	2007-03-01	Clague et al.	Applicant
US7189578(B1)	2007-03-01	Feng et al.	Examiner
US7217269(B2)	2007-05-01	El-Galley et al.	Applicant
US7220260(B2)	2007-05-01	Fleming et al.	Applicant
US7252667(B2)	2007-08-01	Moses	Applicant
US7278991(B2)	2007-10-01	David et al.	Applicant
US7282049(B2)	2007-10-01	Orszulak	Applicant
US7480533(B2)	2009-01-01	Cosman et al.	Applicant
US7553309(B2)	2009-06-01	Buysse	Applicant
US2002/0156472(A1)	2002-10-01	Lee et al.	Applicant
US2003/0040741(A1)	2003-02-01	Fleenor et al.	Examiner
US2003/0171672(A1)	2003-09-01	Varghese et al.	Examiner
US2004/0024396(A1)	2004-02-01	Eggers	Examiner
US2004/0056654(A1)	2004-03-01	Goldfine et al.	Examiner
US2005/0033277(A1)	2005-02-01	Clague et al.	Examiner
US2005/0055014(A1)	2005-03-01	Coppeta et al.	Examiner
US2005/0143656(A1)	2005-06-01	Burbank et al.	Applicant
US2005/0143724(A1)	2005-06-01	El-Galley et al.	Examiner
US2005/0154387(A1)	2005-07-01	Moses	Applicant
US2006/0079885(A1)	2006-04-01	Rick	Applicant
DE2407559	1974-02-01		Applicant
EP171967(A)	1986-02-01		Applicant
EP246350	1987-11-01		Applicant
EP310431	1989-04-01		Applicant
EP608609	1994-08-01		Applicant
EP1465037(A)	2004-10-01		Applicant
WO93/24066	1993-12-01		Applicant
WO94/28809	1994-12-01		Applicant
WO96/04860	1996-02-01		Applicant
WO96/18349	1996-06-01		Applicant
WO96/29946	1996-10-01		Applicant
WO96/34571	1996-11-01		Applicant
WO96/39914	1996-12-01		Applicant
WO97/06739	1997-02-01		Applicant
WO97/06740	1997-02-01		Applicant
WO97/06855	1997-02-01		Applicant
WO97/17029	1997-05-01		Applicant
WO99/01074	1999-01-01		Applicant
WO99/04710	1999-02-01		Applicant
WO1/00114(A1)	2001-01-01		Applicant
WO2005/009528	2005-02-01		Applicant

Non-Patent Literature (29)

Panescu et al., “Three dimensional Finite element analysis of current density and temperature distributions during radio frequenct abalation”, IEEE, 1995.Examiner
Li et al., “Conformal microwave imaging for breast cancer detection”, IEEE, 2003.Examiner
Kim et al., “Origins of the impedance change in Impedance cardiography by a three-dimensional finite element model”, IEEE 1988.Examiner
Cosman ER, Cosman BJ: “Methods of Making Nervous System Lesions”, in William RH, Rengachary SS (eds): Neurosurgery. New York: McGraw-Hill, vol. 111, pp. 2490-2498, 1984.Applicant
Anderson, Gary et al., “A numerical study of rapid heating for high temperature radio frequency hyperthermia”, International Journal of Bio-Medical Computing, 35 (1994) 297-307.Applicant
Goldberg, et al., “Tissue Ablation with Radiofrequency: Effective Probe Size, Gauge, Duration and Temperature and Lesion Volume”, Acad Radio, 1995, vol. 2, No. 5, pp. 399-404.Applicant
Melvin A. Astrahan, “A Localized Current Field Hyperthermia System for Use with 192-Iridium Interstitial Implants”, Medical Physics, 9(3), May/Jun. 1982.Applicant
Cosman et al. “Theoretical Aspects of Radiofrequency Lesions in the Dorsal Root Entry Zone”. Neurosurgery 15:945-950, 1984.Applicant
Stuart W. Young, Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Imaging--Basic Principles, Raven Press, New York, 1984.Applicant
E.R. Cosman, et al., “Radiofrequency Lesion Generation and its Effect on Tissue Impedence”, Applied Neurophysiology, 51:230-242, 1988.Applicant
K. Ogata, Modern Control Engineering, Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, N.J., 1970.Applicant
E. Alexander et al., “Magnetic resonance image-directed stereotactic neurosurgery: use of image fusion with computerized tomography to enhance spatial accuracy”, J. Neurosurg., 83:271, 276, 1995.Applicant
Reidenbach (1995) “First Experimental Results with Special Applicators for High-Frequency Interstitial Thermotherapy”, Society Minimally Ivasive Therapy, 4(Suppl 1) :40 (Abstr).Applicant
Organ LW. (1976) “Electrophysiologic Principles of Radiofrequency Lesion Making” Appl. Neurophysiol, vol. 39: pp. 69-76.Applicant
Livraghi et al. (1995) “Saline-enhanced RF Tissue Ablation in the Treatment of Liver Metastases”, Radiology, 205-210.Applicant
Solbiati et al. (1995) “Percutaneous US-guided RF Tissue Ablation of Liver Metastases: Long-term Follow-up”, Radiology, 197(P): 199.Applicant
Solbiati, et al. (2001) “Percutaneous Radio-frequency Ablation of Hepatic Metastases from Colorectal Cancer: Long-term Results in 117 Patients”, Radiology, vol. 221, pp. 159-166.Applicant
Goldberg, et al., “Image-guided Radiofrequency Tumor Ablation: Challenges and Opportunities —Part 1”, (2001)J Vasc. Interv. Radiol, vol. 12, pp. 1021-1032.Applicant
McGahan et al. (1995) “Percutaneous Ultrasound-guided Radiofrequency Electrocautery Ablationof Prostate Tissue in Dogs”, Acad Radiol, vol. 2, No. 1:pp. 61-65.Applicant
Goldberg et al. (1995) “Tissue Ablation with Radiofrequency Using Multiprobe Arrays”, Acad Radiol, vol. 2: pp. 399-404.Applicant
Goldberg et al, (1995) “Saline-enhanced RF Ablation: Demonstration of Efficacy and Optimization of Parameter”, Radiology, 197(P): 140 (Abstr).Applicant
Humphries et al., (1997) “Finite-Element Codes to Model Electrical Heating and Non-Linear Thermal Transport in Biological Media”, Proc. ASME HTD-355, 131.Applicant
Panescu et al., “Three dimensional finite element analysis of current density and temperature distributions during radio frequency ablation”, IEEE, 1995.Applicant
Li et al., “Conformal microwave imaging for breast cancer detection”, IEEE 2003.Applicant
Kim et al., “origin of impedence change in impedence cardigraphy by a three-dimensional finite element model”, IEEE 1988.Applicant
European Search Report from Application EP 05021935 dated Jan. 27, 2006.Applicant
European Search Report from Application EP 05021939 dated Jan. 27, 2006.Applicant
European Search Report from Application EP 05021025 dated Mar. 13, 2006.Applicant
European Search Report from Application EP 05021936.9 dated Feb. 6, 2006.Applicant

Abstract