US 5,856,737 AGrant

Fast Battery Charging System and Method

Issue Date:1999-01-05

•45 Claims

•36 Drawing Sheets

Abstract

In an exemplary fast charging system, a hand-held computerized terminal with rechargeable batteries therein may be bodily inserted into a charger receptacle. The terminal may have volatile memory and other components requiring load current during charging. The system may automatically identify battery type and progressively increase charging current while monitoring for an increase in battery terminal voltage to ascertain the level of load current. The battery temperature may be brought into a relationship to surrounding temperature such that by applying a suitable overcharge current value and observing any resultant temperature increase, the level of remaining battery charge can be determined. For example, if the battery is found to be relatively fully discharged, a relatively high fast-charge rate may be safely applied while monitoring battery temperature. If the battery is initially relatively fully charged or reaches such a state during fast charge, the system may automatically dynamically select a maintenance charge rate according to battery type and temperature. A preferred system may automatically recharge the batteries of a portable device according to an optimum schedule of essentially maximum safe charging rates as a function of battery temperature, and thereafter safely maintain the batteries at essentially fully charged condition in readiness for maximum duration portable operation.

Metadata

Assignee

Norand Corporation

Inventors

Phillip Miller
Ronald D. Becker
Steven E. Koenck

Application Information

Application Number:US 315825&

Filing Date:1994-09-30

Priority Date:1982-06-07

Art Unit:211

Classifications

IPC:

H02J 700H01M 1044

Field of Search:

32021;22;35;31-32;15;39

Patent Drawings (36 sheets)

Description

INCORPORATION BY REFERENCE

The disclosures and drawings of the above-mentioned U.S. Pat. Nos. 4,455,523; 4,553,081; 4,737,702; and 4,885,523; published PCT Application No. PCT/US90/07049, filed Dec. 3, 1990; and of the pending applications U.S. Ser. No. 07/266,537 and U.S. Ser. 07/837,650, filed Feb. 18, 1992 are hereby incorporated herein by reference in their entirety.

BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

NiCad (nickel-cadmium) battery technology has been employed successfully in portable hand-held applications for many years. Photographic equipment, power tools, data terminals, personal radio transceivers and pagers commonly utilize NiCad batteries as a power source. The charging systems that have been provided with these products have-ranged from a simple transformer/rectifier type to rather complex systems to monitor and control the charging function. An increasing need is the ability to charge NiCad batteries quickly. To reliably and efficiently charge NiCad batteries at high rates requires careful control of the charging operation to avoid damage to the cells, particularly under extreme ambient temperature conditions.

The NiCad charge cycle consists of two basic parts: the coulombic portion and the overcharge portion. The coulombic portion of the charge cycle is characterized by the fact that most of the charge that is applied to the battery is stored in the form of electrochemical energy. This portion of the charge cycle is slightly endothermic, consequently high charge currents may be applied during this time without resulting in temperature increase. Most of the available battery capacity is stored during the coulombic portion of the charge cycle. The overcharge portion of the charge cycle is characterized by the fact that most of the applied charge current causes generation of oxygen gas at the positive electrode of the NiCad cell, with only a relatively small amount of charge actually being stored in the cell. The released oxygen chemically recombines with cadmium at the negative electrode of the cell which serves to equalize the internal pressure of the cell. If the overcharge rate is too high, the rate of oxygen recombination may be insufficient to prevent excessive internal pressure and cell venting, which drastically reduces the useful life of the cell.

The most critical factors in determining the maximum allowable charge current that may be safely applied to a NiCad battery are temperature and state of charge. At low temperatures the oxygen recombination rate is significantly reduced which limits the allowable overcharge current that may be applied without venting the cells if they are fully charged. At high temperatures the heat released by the oxygen recombination reaction may cause excessive cell temperature to be experienced leading to premature failure of the plate separator material and subsequent short-circuiting.

If the battery is fully discharged, minimal oxygen generation will occur until the battery nears the fully charged condition. If the battery is nearly fully charged, it will quickly enter the overcharge condition and begin oxygen generation. The difficulty lies in accurate determination of the previous state of charge to avoid damage to the battery.

As portable hand-held data and radio terminals continue to be used more widely in certain demanding applications, the need for fast charging of the terminal batteries becomes more significant. The increased use of high powered scanner attachments and peripherals as well as other connected devices often causes the terminal battery capacity to be taxed to the point where only a portion of the intended period of usage may be served with the stored charge available from a single battery pack. Consequently, it has become incereasingly necessary to provide multiple packs which may be exchanged in such a way that a depleted pack may be replaced by a fresh one with minimal downtime. When a depleted pack is removed, it should be fully recharged in, at most, the amount of time that a fresh pack is able to operate the terminal. With a recharging capability of this type, it is then possible for virtually perpetual operation to be provided with as few as two battery packs per terminal.

A similar but further complicated application involves the utilization of the described data terminals on a vehicle such as an industrial forklift truck. In this type of application, the terminal may receive power for operation from the vehicle the majority of the time. Often, however, it may be necessary for the terminal to be physically removed from the vehicle and operated in a fully portable mode for potentially extended periods of time. For this reason, it is highly advantageous to maintain the terminal batteries substantially at their fully charged or "topped off" state while they remain on board the vehicle.

SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

A basic objective of the present invention is to provide a monitoring and control system which provides for effective fast charging. In order to avoid damage to the battery, the system automatically tests to determine the initial state of charge and selects the charging rate accordingly.

In a preferred implementation, a microprocessor receives measures of battery temperature and battery terminal voltage and selects an optimum charging rate. A unique feature of the preferred system is its ability to provide a safe controlled charge to a NiCad battery without sensing the current flow through the battery directly. This allows the effective battery impedance to be held at a minimum, thereby delivering the maximum available battery energy to the load.

Further features of the preferred system relate to the automatic processing of batteries subject to temperature extremes beyond the range where rapid charging operation is permitted, while safe guarding optimum battery life.

Further objects relate to the provision of an improved battery conditioning system and method wherein batteries are safely maintained at optimum charge automatically, while accommodating repeated removal of the batteries from the charging system for varying periods of portable use, and providing automatic quick and efficient recharging after use at a wide range of temperatures.

In accordance with a feature of the improved battery conditioning system, the differential between ambient temperature and battery temperature is used to select between fast charge mode, and a battery conditioning mode wherein the battery temperature is adjusted relative to ambient temperature. Preferably during such adjustment a moderate current is applied not exceeding a safe overcharge value but generally sufficient to compensate for any battery load. Such value of maintenance current may be selected according to self-identification by the battery pack or may be dynamically adjusted according to battery load current and minimum safe overcharge current for the battery temperature.

According to another feature of the improved battery conditioning system, a measure of battery voltage is obtained, e.g. after use of the above feature to equalize battery temperature and ambient temperature. A moderate current is then applied not exceeding any minimum safe overcharge value and any needed load current, and the current value is then dynamically adjusted so that battery voltage is maintained generally equal to the measured value, e.a. until battery temperature is in a range suited to fast charge operation.

The invention will now be described, by way of example and not by way of limitation, with references to the accompanying sheets of drawings; and other objects, features and advantages of the invention will be apparent from this detailed disclosure and from the appended claims.

BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

FIGS. 1 through 17 and the brief description thereof are incorporated herein by reference to U.S. Ser. No. 876,194, now U.S. Pat. No. 4,709,202 issued Nov. 24, 1987.

FIG. 18 is an electric circuit diagram for illustrating a preferred embodiment of battery charging current control system in accordance with the present invention;

FIG. 19 shows an exemplary current pulse waveform which may correspond with a maximum battery charging rate in a substantially linear operating range for an exemplary control system in accordance with FIG. 18;

FIG. 20A shows selected control pulses which may be generated during control of battery charging current in the control system of FIG. 18, and FIG. 20B shows respective corresponding battery charging current pulses on the same time scale with vertically aligned portions of the waveforms of FIGS. 20A and 20B occurring at the same time;

FIG. 21 is a diagrammatic view of use in explaining the aliased sampling of actual current pulses in the battery charging circuit, and illustrating the case where thirty-two samples form a complete sampling cycle;

FIG. 22 is a block diagram for illustrating exemplary sampling circuitry for association with the V sense input of the processor means of FIG. 18;

FIG. 23 illustrates a battery conditioning system as described at col. 17, lines 51-68 of the incorporated U.S. Pat. No. 4,455,523, and wherein two-way communication may be established between memory means associated with a portable unit comprised of rechargeable battery means, and non-portable central computer controlled conditioning station;

FIG. 24 shows a battery conditioning system wherein a battery identifying circuit element directly controls the set point of a battery charging circuit to determine a battery charging parameter, e.g., battery charging current;

FIG. 25 shows a highly integrated semiconductor device, e.g. for implementing the system of FIGS. 18-22;

FIG. 26 is an electric circuit block diagram showing a battery conditioning system wherein a preferred hand-held terminal unit contains battery parameter sensing means and computer operating means for optimizing battery charging current as supplied by an external circuit (which may correspond with a standardized circuit such as shown in FIG. 24 applicable to a complete family of hand-held terminals);

FIG. 27 shows a new RF terminal unit including charge control and temperature transducer outputs as in FIG. 26, and also incorporating an interface for coupling with a local area network so as to enable batch transmission of data to and from the RF terminal;

FIG. 28 is a block diagram illustration of a preferred fast charging system in accordance with the present disclosure;

FIG. 29 (sheets one and two) shows a flow chart for illustrating a preferred fast charging algorithm for use with the microprocessor of FIG. 28;

FIG. 30 is a circuit diagram illustrating a preferred arrangement for the automatic identification of various types of batteries which may be associated with a fast charging system according to FIGS. 28 and 29;

FIG. 31 is a diagram useful in explaining certain steps of the flow chart of FIG. 29;

FIG. 32 is a circuit diagram for illustrating an exemplary implementation of the block diagram of FIG. 28;

FIG. 33 illustrates a plot showing a maximum permissible overcharge rate for fast charge cells as a function of cell temperature, and provides information which may be incorporated in the programming of the system of FIGS. 28-32 for establishing an optimum value of charging current (Ichg) during sustained overcharging;

FIG. 34 illustrates a plot of maximum charge rate for fast charge cells as a function of cell temperature to show exemplary data which may be used for the system programming in FIGS. 28-32 for establishing an optimum value of charging current for a battery which has not yet reached the overcharge state;

FIG. 35 shows a plot of measured battery pack temperature as a function of time for a previously fully charged enclosed battery pack where an overcharge current (Ichg) of three hundred milliamperes is applied and the ambient temperature T.sub.A is about fourteen degrees celsius (14.degree. C.) and also illustrates successive approximate slope values for selected successive time intervals; and

FIG. 36 is a plot of measured battery pack temperature as a function of time for the case of an enclosed battery pack which is initially at a much lower temperature than ambient temperature; specifically the battery pack was initially at a temperature of about minus fifteen degrees celsius (-15.degree. C.) while the ambient temperature was about twenty degrees celsius (20.degree.), the battery pack receiving only a small charging current of six milliamperes; FIG. 36 also shows successive approximate slope values by means of straight lines covering successive equal time intervals of 600 seconds;

FIG. 37 shows an improved procedure for carrying out fast charging and maintenance of a nickel-cadmium battery pack, for example in conjunction with a microprocessor system as shown in FIG. 28, the variable P temp, V batt and Atemp of FIG. 28 being represented by PT, PV and AT in FIG. 37;

FIG. 38 is a schematic diagram for illustrating a charge current regulator circuit such as indicated at 28-20 in FIG. 28; and

FIG. 39 shows the voltage to current transfer function for the circuit of FIG. 38.

DETAILED DESCRIPTION

The detailed description of FIGS. 1 through 27 is incorporated herein by reference to the specification at col. 4, line 25, through col. 66, line 4, of the incorporated U.S. Pat. No. 4,709,202, by reference to the specification at col. 4, line 15, through col. 11, line 37 of the incorporated U.S. Pat. No. 4,737,702, and by reference to the specification of incorporated U.S. Pat. No. 4,885,523.

DESCRIPTION OF FIGS. 28-32

A block diagram of the charging system is shown in FIG. 28. A microprocessor 28-10 is preferably of a type that has analog to digital inputs such as 28-11 to 28-13 and digital to analog outputs such as 28-14 for interface to sensor and control functions. Both the temperature of battery 28-15 and ambient temperature are sensed as indicated at 28-16 and 28-17 so that absolute and relative temperature measurements may be made. The terminal voltage of the battery pack is sensed as indicated at 28-12 so that charge trends may be determined. The charge regulator comprised of a voltage controlled current source 28-20 whose output current (Ichg) is controlled by the level of the charge control signal at 28-14 from the microprocessor. A load 28-21 may or may not be connected during charge.

In the microprocessor 28-10, analog to digital (A/D) means and digital to analog (D/A) means are indicated at 28-10A and 28-10B. Preferably these means are integrated with the other components of the microprocessor as part of a monolithic unit or "chip" formed from a unitary substrate of semiconductor material.

With a charging system as shown in FIG. 28, flow diagram has been developed for fast charging of NiCad batteries as shown in FIG. 29 (sheets one and two). The charging function is initiated as represented by "start" at 29-1 e.g. by placing the battery 28-15 in the charger. The temperature sensor 28-16 is preferably in a housing 28-22 which together with battery 28-15 forms the battery pack 28-25. The sensor 28-16 is preferably of the type whose output is proportional to absolute temperature e.g. at the rate of ten millivolts per degree Kelvin (10 mv/.degree.K). The microprocessor 28-10 tests for insertion of the battery in the charger by reading the temperature PT(Ptemp as indicated at 29-2), and checking to determine if Ptemp shows a temperature greater than -100.degree. C.; see decision block 29-3. The decision at block 29-3 will be affirmative only if a battery pack has been inserted to provide a non-zero voltage on the Ptemp signal line 28-11.

Following determination of the presence of a battery pack 28-25 in the charger, the pack type must be identified as represented at 29-4 and 29-5 to allow for cells with different charge characteristics. In the case of an invalid reading of battery pack identity, the program may branch to an error sub routine as indicated at 29-5A. The identification of the type of battery inserted into the charger is a significant step in the battery processing operation since battery cells of specialized types may offer significantly higher capacity than ordinary NiCad cells, but they may require charging at lower maximum rates. Other cells may allow high charging rates at extreme temperatures. Future technology developments may offer new cell types with unusual charging parameters that may be accommodated by applying an appropriate charging algorithm. Refering to FIG. 30, a proposed method for identification of the pack type is to connect a shunt voltage regulator 30-10 to the battery pack 30-27 represented in FIG. 30. The shunt regulator may be comprised of a simple zener diode or it may be implemented with an active regulator e.g. as indicated in FIG. 30, depending on the number of different pack types that must be identified. Upon determination of the pack type a suitable one of a set of parameter tables may be selected that contains the appropriate values for charging the specified cell type, as shown at 29-6.

As indicated in FIG. 28, there may be a load 28-21 placed on the battery that requires current. Consequently, current supplied by a charger is shared by the load and the battery as shown in FIG. 31. If the load current Iload-is larger than the charge current Ichg, the battery will provide the difference, resulting in further discharge of the battery rather than charging. To compensate for this effect, the control system senses the terminal voltage (Vb) of the battery (step 29-7, FIG. 29) corresponding to pack voltage PV, FIG. 1, and applies increasing charge current to the battery in small increments (step 29-8) until the terminal voltage trend is positive (steps 29-9 to 29-11) meaning the battery is accepting charge rather than providing current to a load (see block 29-12).

While the absolute terminal voltage of a NiCad battery is a poor indicator of its condition, its trend is a good indicator of charging versus discharging if it is measured over a short enough time that the pack temperature remains relatively constant. Once the battery voltage trend is determined to be positive, the level of current required by the load (Iterm of block 29-12 corresponding to Iload, FIG. 31) is known, and may be added to the desired net battery current level (Ibatt, FIG. 31) to select the actual charge current (Ichg, FIG. 31).

Typical NiCad cell specifications call for charging in a temperature range of 0.degree. to 40.degree. C. Many of the products that utilize NiCad batteries may operate in environments with temperatures that range from -30.degree. C. to 60.degree. C. Consequently, it is possible that a battery pack may be placed in a charger immediately after being removed from either of these temperature extremes. If the pack temperature is greater than 40.degree. C., (see decision step 29-13), the pack must be "cooled" to no more than 40.degree. C. before charging may proceed. This is accomplished (as shown by step 29-14) by applying a charge current Ichg that equals the terminal load Iterm so that no net charge current is received by the battery and it may be cooled by the ambient environment. If the battery pace is cold, it must be warmed to a temperature above 0.degree. C. This is carried out by steps 29-15 to 29-19. By applying a safe (low) charge current per the charge table of steps 29-17 and 29-19 (and FIG. 33), the pack my be warmed by the ambient environment of the charger.

Although charging may begin when the battery temperature exceeds 0.degree. C. according to the battery charging specifications, additional information is needed to determine the state of charge of the battery. The clearest method to determine whether a battery is fully charged is to detect the presence of the overcharge condition. In overcharge, the oxygen recombination reaction is highly exothermic which results in rapid heating of the battery. By applying twice the permissible substained overcharge rate as at steps 29-20 to 29-23 and monitoring cell temperature, it is possible to reliably determine that the overcharge condition has been reached. Unfortunately, when a cold pack is placed in a warm environment, there is a resultant temperature rise due to ambient warming that can actually occur at a rate faster than the heating due to the supply of a high value of overcharge current. Consequently, a reliable means of detecting heating due to overcharge current is first insure that the battery temperature is not substantially less than the ambient temperature (as determined by step 29-18). Once the battery is warmed to ambient temperature, the overcharge condition can be quickly detected by means of steps 29-20 to 29-23 since any further substantial increase in temperature can he attributed to internal heat being evolved by the battery. If the pack has been in a hot environment, the cooling (steps 29-13. and 29-14) will bring its temperature down to no more than 40.degree. C., which is above the ambient temperature of the charger. Overcharge induced heating will cause the pack temperature to begin to increase again as shown by FIG. 35. According to the described control method, the charge current applied to the battery for overcharge detection (step 29-20) is double the standard overcharge table value of steps 29-17, 29-19 and 29-28 (and of FIG. 33) to improve the ability to detect a temperature increase. Since the test time is relatively short, little gas pressure increase and potential for cell venting is involved.

Once it has been determined that the battery is not in the overcharge condition (at decision block 29-23), it is a relatively simple matter to apply the appropriate charge value from the fast charge parameter table (as at step 29-24, FIG. 29). The fast charge table value may correspond to that indicated in FIG. 34 and is a function of temperature so that a temperature regulation capability is implemented for reducing the current applied at elevated temperatures. During the fast charge operation, battery temperature increase is closely monitored (steps 29-25 to 29-27) to determine when overcharge has been reached, so that the fast charge cycle may be terminated (as represented by branch line 29-27a) and a controlled temperature overcharge cycle may be initiated as represented by step 29-28 and FIG. 33 to "top-off" the battery for maximum capacity. After the overcharge cycle is complete (after step 29-29), a trickle charge current is applied per step 29-30 to maintain the full battery capacity and offset the effects of self-discharge normally seen when a battery rests in an idle condition.

FIG. 32 shows an exemplary embodiment of the described fast charging system utilizing a microprocessor system with a programmed control system for fast charging of battery packs. Other embodiments involving control circuits contained within a data terminal or other utilization device may employ identical control methods without departing from the concepts described.

FIG. 32 represents an implementation of FIG. 28, and corresponding reference numerals have been applied in FIG. 32 so as to facilitate correlation therewith. The major components of FIG. 32 may comprise commercially available parts which are identified as follows:

microprocessor chip 32-10 of microprocessor system 28-10, type SC83C552

voltage regulator 32-11, type LP2951AC

amplifiers 28-12 and 28-13 of charge regulator 28-20, type LT1013 transistor 32, type 1RF9Z30

temperature sensor 28-17,type LM335.

The programming for microprocessor element 32-10 of FIG. 32 may correspond with that represented in FIGS. 29, 33 and 34, as described with reference to these figures and the circuits of FIGS. 28, 30 and 31. By way of example, terminals 32-21, 32-22, 32-23 and 32-24, FIG. 32, may be connected with terminals 30-21, 30-22, 30-23 and 30-24 respectively in FIG. 30. Temperature sensor 30-26, FIG. 30, which is connected between terminals 30-22 and 30-23, may correspond with sensor 28-16 and may be mounted in intimate heat transfer relation with battery 28-15 and within the housing of the battery pack 28-25 as represented in FIG. 28. Resistor R1, FIG. 30, has a respective one of a set of values so as to provide a voltage level between terminals 30-22 and 30-24 selected so as to identify the particular type of battery pack 30-27 with which it is associated.

Terminals 30-21A, 30-22A, 30-23A and 30-24A may be connected with a utilization circuit to supply energy thereto during portable operation. It will be noted that the battery pack 30-27 can be associated with the circuitry of the 16 FIG. (16A and 16B) of incorporated U.S. Pat. No. 4,709,202, terminals 30-21A and 30-22A having a quick-release connection with terminals JP-1, JP-2, FIG. 16B, and terminals 30-23A having a quick-release coupling with terminal J7-3, FIG. 16B. Terminal 30-24A can be used by the portable device to identify the battery pack, where the portable device provides a circuit such as associated with terminal 32-24, FIG. 32, leading to an analog to digital input such as 32-25, FIG. 32.

FIG. 35 illustrates by a plot 35-10 the increase in temperature as a function of time of an enclosed battery pack such as 27-1OB, FIG. 27, 28-25, FIG. 28 or 30-27, FIG. 30, due to an overcharge current of 300 milliamperes, where the battery means 27-27, 28-15 is initially fully charged and is at a battery temperature of about minus eight degrees celsius the ambient temperature being about fourteen degrees celsius. The slopes between successive points 35-1, 35-2, 35-3 and 35-4, are represented by straight line segments 35-11, 35-12 and 35-13, with respective slope values of 0.54 degrees celsius per minute, 0.36 degrees celsius per minute and 0.21 degrees celsius per minute.

FIG. 36 for the sake of comparison shows by a curve 36-10 the rate of warming of such a battery pack due to an ambient temperature which is substantially higher than battery temperature. Specifically FIG. 36 shows the case where initial battery temperature is about minus fifteen degrees celsius and ambient temperature is about twenty degrees celsius. Straight line segments 36-11, 36-12, 36-13, 36-14 show approximate slope values of 0.98 degrees celsius per minute, 0.5 degrees celsius per minute, 0.33 degrees celsius per minute and 0.24 degrees celsius per minute. The relatively high slope values indicate that the differential between a high ambient temperature and a low battery temperature must be taken into account when using steps 29-20 to 29-23 to determine whether a battery is in the overcharge range.

DISCUSSION OF FIGS. 33 THROUGH 36 AND TABLES I AND II

FIGS. 33 and 34 represent in effect a series of tables of charge rate versus temperature since the ordinate values are in units of charge rate (e.g. current Ibatt in milliamperes divided by capacity C in milliampere-hours). The following TABLES I and II give values of overcharge and fast charge correponding to FIGS. 33 and 34 for successive temperatures in increments of two degrees celsius, and give corresponding current values in milliamperes for two different values of battery capacity C, namely C equals 800 milliampere-hours and C equals 1200 milliampere hours.

TABLES I and II may be stored in machine readable form in the memory of microprocessor system 28-10 or 32-10, e.g. in first and second read only memory segments. Thus if step 29-4 identified an 800 milliampere-hour capacity fast charge nickel-cadmium battery means, the microprocessor would access the first memory segment corresponding to TABLE I for steps such as 29-17, 29-19, 29-20, 29-24 and 29-28, while if step 29-4 showed a 1200 milliampere-hour capacity fast charge nickel-cadmium battery means the second memory segment corresponding to TABLE II would be addressed.

If for example, the battery temperature (Ptemp) in step 29-16 were greater than nineteen degrees celsius but less than or equal to twenty-one degrees celsius, the overcharge value read from memory segment I would be 240 milliamperes (0.300 units in FIG. 33 times 800 milliampere-hours, the battery capacity C, equals 240 milliamperes). Thus according to step 29-17 and step 29-19, an overcharge current of 240 milliamperes (plus any needed load current) would be supplied by regulator 28-20 until temperature sensor 28-16 showed that battery temperature exceeded ambient temperature (Atemp, 28-13, FIG. 28).

If ambient temperature were thirty degrees celsius and the battery temperature were in the range from thirty-one to thirty-three degrees celsius, current of 480 amperes would be applied according to step 29-20, but for a limited duration (e.g. about ten minutes per step 29-21) such as to avoid substantial detriment to the useful life of the battery means.

FIG. 36 illustrates warming of the battery pack as a function of time with the battery pack initially at a temperature of about minus fifteen degrees celsius. From FIG. 33, it can be seen that maximum permissible overcharge current corresponds to about 0.08 units. For a battery capacity of 800 milliampere hours, this would correspond to an overcharge current value of greater than sixty milliamperes, while FIG. 36 shows the warming rate with an ambient temperature of about twenty degrees celsius and a relatively negligible value of charging current (i.e. Ichg equals six milliamperes). It will be noted that the warming rate in FIG. 36 in the first 600 seconds is 0.98 degrees celsius per minute which considerably exceeds the warming rate produced by a current of 300 milliamperes in FIG. 35.

SUPPLEMENTARY DISCUSSION OF FIGS. 28-36

For representing an embodiment such as that of FIG. 30, a microprocessor system such as indicated at 28-10 in FIG. 28 would be shown with a fourth input to A/D means 28-10A corresponding with input 32-25, FIG. 32. For such an embodiment each type of battery means such as the one with 800 milliampere-hour capacity and temperature characteristics as shown in Table I, and the one with 1200 ampere-hour capacity and characteristics according to Table II would have a respective distinct value of R1, FIG. 30 and a respective different shunt voltage level so as to enable the microprocessor system 28-10 to reliably identify each of numerous types of battery means pursuant to step 29-4. The microprocessor system 28-10 or 32-10 may store a set of parameter tables such as Tables I and II in machine readable form with each table of such set having an address associated with the corresponding shunt voltage level. In this way the appropriate stored table can be interrogated by the microprocessor in accordance with a given battery temperature reading so as to obtain appropriate current values for steps 29-8, 29-17, 29-19, 29-20, 29-24 and 29-28.

The battery identification means 26-36 or 30-10 would distinguish the presence or absence of an internal current regulator 26-28 as well as identifying the various battery types requiring different charging and overcharge treatment.

Other stored machine readable tables of computer system 28-10 or 32-10 may include acceptable maximum overcharge rates as represented in FIG. 6 and have charge rates, e.g., as described at Col. 9, line 26 to Col. 10, line 32 of the incorporated U.S. Pat. No. 4,455,523. Such stored tables would insure that the charging system of FIG. 28 or FIG. 32 would be compatible with a battery means such as shown in FIG. 5 or in FIGS. 9A and 9B. For example, the stored table for the battery means of FIGS. 9A and 9B could take account of internal heating within the internal regulator 173 of the battery pack and insure that the current to the battery (20, FIG. 5) and to the battery load did not exceed the power dissipation capacity of the internal regulator network (173, FIG. 9A).

The current regulator 28-20 may be controlled to provide a voltage VCHG at the line CHG in FIG. 9A of approximately seven volts which would result in minimum power dissipation in the interior regulator network (173, FIG. 9A). The presence of an internal current regulator within a hand-held terminal unit is indicated at 26-28, FIG. 26, and charging current control circuit 26-22 could conform with the embodiments of FIGS. 28-36 in the selection of charging and overcharge current values while tending toward minimum power dissipation in the internal regulator network (173, FIG. 9A). The presence of an internal current regulator within a hand-held terminal unit is indicated at 26-28, FIG. 26, and charging current control circuit 26-22 could conform with the embodiments of FIGS. 28-36 in the selection of charging and overcharge current values while tending toward minimum power dissipation in the internal regulator 26-28.

In a different embodiment, each battery pack could have an internal digitally stored identification code digitally stored in the battery pack and accessible to an external microprocessor system such as 28-10 or 32-10 as in the embodiment of e.g. FIG. 23 (via contacts 23-51A), FIG. 25 (via data output 25-51), FIG. 26 (via components 26-36, 26-37, 26-20 and 26-23), or FIG. 27 (via D to A component 27-37 or LAN interface 27-39).

Instead of bringing battery temperature up to ambient temperature as in steps 29-15 to 29-19, it would be conceivable to establish ambient temperature to match battery temperature, and then proceed with a test for overcharge condition as in steps 29-20 to 29-23. Similarly before steps 29-24 to 29-27, where the battery is initially at a low temperature, it would be conceivable to control ambient temperature so as to bring battery temperature up to zero degrees celsius or six degrees celsius by control of ambient temperature alone, or in combination with a suitable charging current. In this way, a relatively high charge rate according to FIG. 34 would be suitable, e.g., at least 0.6C, and a maximum overcharge rate according to FIG. 33 would quickly be appropriate for the overcharge cycle of steps 29-28 and 29-29.

The stored charge rate information can take -the form of end points such as 33-1, 33-2; 33-2, 33-3; 33-3, 33-4, FIG. 33, for successive substantial straight segments such as 33-11, 33-12 and 33-13, so that the microprocessor could interpolate a precise charge rate multiplier for any measured battery temperature. Thus, if segment 33-12 had end points at -20.degree. C., 0.060 units and at -10.degree., 0.100, a battery temperature of -19.degree. might be computed to correspond to 0.064 by linear interpolation. Of course of course the points given in Tables I and II could be similarly interpolated to obtain intervening more precise overcharge and fast charge values.

With respect to steps 29-7 to 29-12, an internal microprocessor such as in FIG., 5 or FIGS. 9A, 9B may determine battery load current and communicate the same to an external microprocessor such as 28-10 as shown in FIGS. 23, 25, 26 or 27, for example, FIG. 28 may represent the association of a non-portable battery conditioning station including components 28-10, 28-17 and 28-20 with a hand-held terminal unit containing a quickly removable battery pack 28-25 comprised of a nickel-cadmium rechargeable battery 28-15 and a battery temperature sensor 28-16 within housing 28-22. The hand-held terminal unit may provide load means 28-21, which may comprise a dynamic random access memory and other circuitry which is to be continuously energized during a charging operation.

As in the embodiment of FIG. 30, the hand-held terminal units which are to be associated with components 28-10, 28-17 and 28-20 may include coupling means such as 30-21, 30-21A, 30-22, 30-23 and 30-24 which are automatically engaged with cooperating coupling means of the charging station when the hand-held unit is bodily inserted into a receptacle of the charging station. The coupling means 30-21 and 30-21A in FIG. 30 would be represented in FIG. 28 by a line (+BATT) from component 28-20 corresponding to line 28-26, and a further line (+CHG) leading to a network (representing components 30-28 and 30-29) in turn connected with battery 28-15 and line 28-11.

An exemplary charging station adaptable for a hand-held unit including battery pack 30-27 of FIG. 30 is shown in greater detail in FIG. 27.

Where FIGS. 28-36 are applied to a system as represented in FIG. 27, components 28-10, 28-17 and 28-20 would be part of charger station 27-22. Line 28-26 would lead to a charging station contact engageable with external battery pack contact 27-11. Input line 28-12 would be connected via a further set of mating contacts with internal battery pack contact 27-61. Input line 28-11 would connect with contact 27-17. Alternatively, charger station 27-22 would have a LAN interface corresponding to 27-39 and would receive digital information as to battery terminal voltage for example via amplifier 27-35A, an A to D converter of terminal 27-1OA, LAN interface 27-39 and LAN data coupling means 27-19, 27-21. The charging station would then charge the battery packs such as 27-10B of terminals such as 27-10A in accordance with the embodiments of FIGS. 28-36. In place of amplifier 27-37, (representing components 26-36, 26-37), an identifying shunt voltage regulator 30-10 would be part of each battery pack 27-10B.

As a further embodiment, the charger station 27-22 could comprise the components of FIG. 32, the line 28-12 being-coupled with a battery such as 27-27 via mating terminals 32-21 and 27-11 and through forward biased diode 27-Dl, for example. In this embodiment terminal 27-13 would mate with terminal 32-24, and battery pack 27-10B would conform with battery pack 30-27 for example by including a respective identifying shunt regulator 30-10, and e.g., nickel-cadmium batteries with respective characteristics as shown by FIGS. 33 to 36 and Tables I and II.

SUMMARY OF OPERATION OF FIGS. 28-36

Operation of the specific exemplary embodiment as presented in FIG. 29 may be summarized as follows.

As represented by steps 29-2 and 29-3, the presence of a battery pack 28-25, FIG. 28, or 30-27, FIG. 30, may be sensed by means of the input 28-11, FIG. 28 or FIG. 32, from battery pack temperature sensor 28-16, FIG. 28, or 30-26, FIG. 30. A non-zero voltage input level on line 28-11 may signal the presence of a battery pack 28-25 coupled with components 28-10 and 28-20. The physical connections may be analogous to those of FIG. 26, for example, an exemplary arrangement of terminals for a battery pack 30-27 being shown in FIG. 30.

Referring to FIG. 31, the load current may be automatically sensed by means of steps 29-7 to 29-11 since battery voltage as measured at 28-12, FIG. 28 or FIG. 32, will not increase until a current Ichg, FIG. 30, in excess of battery load current Iload is applied to line 28-26, FIG. 28.

Where the battery pack has a given upper temperature limit which must be observed to avoid detriment to battery life, the battery may be automatically allowed to cool to a suitable temperature (e.g. 40.degree.) if it is introduced into the charger at an unacceptably high temperature. This is represented by steps 29-13 and 29-14 which may be automatically performed by microprocessor 28-10 or 32-10 according to battery temperature (Ptemp) as sensed at input 28-11, FIG. 28 or FIG. 32.

As explained in reference to FIG. 36, in order to detect the battery overcharge condition, the microprocessor 28-10 or 32-10 automatically performs steps 29-15 to 29-19 to assure that battery temperature as measured at input 28-11 is not substantially lower than ambient temperature as sensed at input 28-13. Once battery temperature is at least essentially equal to ambient temperature, steps 29-20 to 29-23 are effective to automatically determine whether the battery is to receive a fast charge according to steps 29-24 to 29-27, and e.g. FIG. 34, or whether the microprocessor 28-10 or 32-10 is to govern the supply of charging current at 28-26 according to steps 29-28 and 29-29 and e.g. FIG. 33.

DISCUSSION OF TERMINOLOGY

From the foregoing, it will be understood that steps 29-20 to 29-23 are effective where the battery system can be made to exhibit a temperature characteristic which rises as a function of overcharge current over a given time interval generally as illustrated in FIG. 32. Another example may be a nickel hydride type battery. To accomplish this the chargins system may operate automatically as in steps 29-15 to 29-19 to insure that the battery means has a state such that its temperature will not increase at a substantial rate due to a higher ambient temperature (e.g. as in FIG. 36). In particular, the state of the battery means may be automatically assured to be such that it will exhibit a substantially greater increase in battery temperature in response to a given selected charge rate when the battery is in overcharge condition that when it is not in such a overcharge condition.

As represented by step 29-20, the current automatically applied to the battery means exceeds battery load current by a substantial overcharge magnitude, e.g. twice the overcharge value obtained from FIG. 33, but the application is of limited duration (e.g. ten minutes per step 29-20) such as to void substantial detriment to the useful life of the battery.

According to steps 29-22 and 29-23, the microprocessor system automatically determines whether any increase in battery temperature due to step.29-20 is of a magnitude (e.g. two degrees celsius or greater) which is distinctive of the overcharge condition of the battery means.

From the foregoing TABLE I, it will be understood if battery temperature at step 29-22 has reached thirty degrees celsius, step 29-24 would result in an initial relatively high battery charging current (Ibatt, FIG. 31) of about 1280 milliamperes if the temperature increases at step 29-23 was not greater than two degrees celsius, while if the increase at step 29-23 were found to be greater than two degrees celsius, step 29-28 would result in supply of a relatively lower battery charging current of about 240 milliamperes.

Where the relatively high battery charging current is applied, battery temperature is measured at regular intervals (e.g. at about one minute intervals per step 29-25) to assure that such high charge rate is terminated sufficiently quickly after overcharge condition is detected so as to avoid any substantial detriment to the useful life of the battery means.

The overcharge relatively lower charge rate is terminated after an overcharge interval so as to insure optimum charging of the battery means without detriment to its useful life.

Of course the charge rate or overcharge rate may be readjusted higher or lower according to FIGS. 33 and 34 at any desired time intervals, e.g. at each step 29-24 in charging mode, and by inserting steps such as 29-25 and 29-26 between steps 29-28 and 29-29 so that overcharge current would be re-selected at suitable intervals such as one-minute intervals.

Referring to the plots of maximum acceptable overcharge rate in FIGS. 6 and 33, it will be observed that there is a minimum temperature for each battery type below which overcharge current is not applied by the microprocessor system 28-10 or 32-10. In FIG. 6, the lower temperature extreme is shown as about zero degrees Fahrenheit (about minus eighteen degrees celsius). At about zero degrees Fahrenheit, the low overcharge rate is less than about capacity divided by fifty. In FIG. 33, the low temperature extreme is about minus thirty degrees celsius where the overcharge current of about 0.04 units corresponds to an overcharge rate of about capacity divided by twenty-five.

Above the lower limit temperature, there is a range of temperatures where the upper overcharge rate exceeds the lower overcharge rate by a factor of at least about four. For example, in FIG. 6, the acceptable overcharge rate at a relatively high temperature of about one hundred and ten degrees Fahrenheit is close to capacity divided by five (0.2C), while the acceptable overcharge rate at the low temperature extreme of about zero degrees Fahrenheit is about capacity divided by fifty (0.02C) a ratio of overcharge rates of ten to one. According to FIG. 33, the microprocessor system 28-10 or 32-10 may supply values of overcharge at about five degrees celsius of about 0.30 units (C/3.3) while at a low temperature extreme of about minus thirty degrees celsius, the acceptable overcharge rate to be supplied by the microprocessor system is about 0.04 units (C/25), a ratio of about seven to one. Between the temperature values of the temperature range of FIG. 6, the permissible overcharge rate progressively increases with successively higher temperature values such as zero degrees, fifteen deqrees, thirty-five degrees, fifty-five degrees, seventy-five degrees and ninety five degrees (Fahrenheit). Similarly in FIG. 33, between temperatures of minus thirty degrees celsius and about five degrees celsius, the permissible overcharge rate progressively increases for successively increasing temperature values (such as -20.degree. C., -10.degree. C., and 0.degree. C.).

Referring to FIGS. 28, 30 and 31, it will be understood that the embodiments of FIGS. 28 to 36 avoid series resistance means of substantial ohmic value such as shown at 131, FIG. 9A, 18-26, FIG. 18, 24-30, FIG. 24, 25-26, FIG. 25, for sensing battery current. Instead charging current source 28-20, FIG. 28, may be automatically operated to supply desired current values in an open loop manner. An automatic sequence such as steps 29-7 to 29-11 may be used to measure load current if this would be a fluctuating and possibly significant amount for a given hand-held terminal unit and would not be reported to the charging station by the hand-held unit. As shown by FIGS. 28, 30 and 31, the battery 28-15 has external terminals e.g. as at 30-21A, 30-22A, FIG. 30, with external circuit means connecting such terminals with the battery, such external circuit means having essentially negligible ohmic resistance such that the battery means supplies load current to a load via the external terminals with minimized ohmic loss at the battery side of said external terminals.

DESCRIPTION OF FIGS. 37, 38 and 39

As portable hand-held data and radio terminals continue to be used more widely in certain demanding applications, the need for fast charging of the terminal batteries becomes more significant. The increased use of high powered scanner attachments and peripherals as well as other connected devices often causes the terminal battery capacity to be taxed to the point where only a portion of the intended period of usage may be served with the stored charge available from a single battery pack. Consequently, it has become increasingly necessary to provide multiple packs which may be exchanged in such a way that a depleted pack may be replaced by a fresh one with minimal downtime. When a depleted pack is removed, it should be fully recharged in a least the amount of time that a fresh pack is able to operate the terminal. With a recharging capability of this type, it is then possible for virtually perpetual operation to be provided with as few as two battery packs per terminal.

A similar but further complicated application involves the utilization of the described data terminals on a vehicle such as an industrial fork lift truck. In this type of application, the terminal may receive power for operation from the vehicle the majority of the time. Often, however, it may be necessary for the terminal to be physically removed from the vehicle and operated in a fully portable mode for potentially extended periods of time. For this reason, it is highly advantageous to automatically quickly recharge the terminal batteries, and then to automatically maintain the terminal batteries substantially at their fully charged or `topped off` state while safeguarding the batteries against detriment to their optimum useful life.

The above stated objectives for a battery charginq system have traditionally been extremely difficult to achieve FIGS. 37, 38 and 39 show an embodiment that addresses both aspects of fast charging and maintenance in a novel and unique way.

As described with reference to FIGS. 28 through 36, the characteristics of the popular NiCad battery technology are such that the rates at which charging may be accomplished are a strong function of temperature and state of charge. If the cell is in a discharged condition, the rate at which charge may be applied is relatively high, regardless of the cell temperature. If the cell is in a charged condition, the rate at which charge may be applied to the cell is determined by the temperature of the cell. At the limits of cell temperature, excessive charge current may cause permanent damage resulting in premature failure of the cell. Consequently, for fast charging to be accomplished safely, the temperature and state of charge of a battery must be determined.

Battery temperature (herein designated PT) may be measured directly by the use of a pack temperature sensor 28-16 thermally coupled to the battery pack 28-25. State of charge of a NiCad battery type is more difficult to determine. In general, the most reliable indication that a NiCad battery is fully charged is the release of heat while under charge. This only occurs when the battery is in the overcharge condition in which most or all of the current supplied to the battery causes evolution of oxygen gas at the positive electrode. When oxygen chemically recombines with cadmium at the negative electrode, heat is released. No other condition of operation of a NiCad battery causes appreciable heat to be generated.

In general, the process of converting charge current to stored charge in a NiCad battery is a slightly endothermic chemical reaction, that is, heat is removed from the environment of the battery and it gets slightly cooler. Consequently, it is possible to apply quite high rates of charge to the battery if it is not in the overcharge condition. Once the overcharge condition is reached, the slightly endothermic charge reaction is overwhelmed by the highly exothermic overcharge/oxygen recombination reaction. The rate of applied charge must then be quickly reduced to prevent excessive heating and battery damage.

As described in reference to FIGS. 28-36, a microcomputer 28-10 with the ability to measure the temperature of a battery and control the applied charge to that battery may be employed to effect charging at the maximum safe (non-damaging) rate and may also terminate the charge function to prevent damage to the battery when it is fully charged. The present embodiment also employs a microcomputer to measure battery temperature and control applied charge as indicated in FIG. 28, however, the process that is used to determine the appropriate charge current is quite substantially different, and significantly modifies and improves the performance of the charging system.

A flow diagram of the procedure that accomplishes the described charging characteristics is shown in FIG. 37. It should be noted that the charging method described may be applied to either a terminal or utilization device with the circuits as shown in FIG. 28 or to a standalone pack charger with one of more sets of the same circuit. In the case of the pack charged configuration, the block 28-21 labeled "load" would not be present. In the terminal configuration the operating power required by the terminal itself would represent a load that requires current to be delivered by the charge circuit or battery.

In FIG. 37, the initial decision block 37-1, .vertline.AT-PT.vertline.>10.degree. C., provides two pieces of information based on the ambient temperature value, AT, from sensor 28-17, and battery pack temperature PT. The first information (when the temperature difference is not greater than ten degrees celsius) is that the temperature sensors 28-16 and 28-17 are in at least approximately agreement (which provides confidence that they are functioning property). If the temperature difference is relatively great, it is possible that the battery pack and the charger are at significantly different temperatures, in which case they need to stabilize to an acceptable level before further procedure steps may be taken. If this condition is detected, a constant current of sixty milliamperes (60 ma.) is selected as indicated at 37-2 to provide a safe low maintenance current that may minimize further discharge of the battery if it is already in a relatively depleted state.

If the initial temperature difference is not excessive, the absolute temperature of the battery pack is examined at steps 37-3 and 37-4. The temperature range allowed for charging is between 10.degree. C. and 36.degree. C. If the battery temperature is not within this range, the battery must be allowed to cool or warm as the case may be for the charging process to continue. It may be assumed (or specified) that the ambient temperature environment of the charger itself is between these limits, so that the battery temperature will stabilize after some time to an acceptable level. During this temperature stabilization time, it is preferable that no charqe current be supplied to the battery, though it may be necessary for current to be supplied to a load, as in the case of a terminal which receives itsoperating power from the battery or charge while charging is in progress. Since the load current is generally not known, a mechanism must be provided to adjust the current provided by the charger to accurately match the load current of the terminal. The means by which this is accomplished is as follows:

1. Examine the battery pack terminal voltage designated PV as indicated at block 37-5.

2. Select an initial charge current of sixty milliamperes (60 ma.) as indicated at 37-6.

3. Examine the pack temperature PT at 37-7 and 37-8 to determine if it has stabilized within the desired limits. If so, return to the main charging process.

4. Examine the present terminal voltage PV at 37-9 and 37-10.

5. If the battery terminal voltage has increased, decrease the charge current by twenty milliamperes (20 ma.) as indicated at 37-11.

6. If the battery terminal voltage has decreased, increase the charge current by twenty milliamperes (20 ma.) as indicated at 37-12.

7. If no terminal voltage change is detected, leave the charge current unchanged and return to step 3 above (referring to entry into the flow diagram of FIG. 37 at 187 and 188).

This method serves to provide an adaptive current that will prevent the battery from being further depleted while its temperature stabilizes to an allowable level.

After the battery temperature has stabilized to an allowable level, it is then possible to begin charging at high rates of charge. As described with reference to FIGS. 28-36, a stored table containing values of currents that may be safely applied to a battery of a known capacity at a given temperature is used to determine the charge current, this being indicated at 37-13. While the table values for fast charge current will not cause stress or damage to a battery when it is discharged and efficiently receiving charge, in general, these charge currents are high enough to cause permanent damage to the battery if not terminated properly. The indication that the battery is nearing full charge is based on detection of the overcharge condition, which is the only condition of a NiCad cell that releases significant heat. In the flow diagram block of FIG. 37, the condition for decision block 37-14, PT<AT+10.degree. C., provides the test for overcharge detection. In essence, the test for overcharge is to detect that the battery is becoming warmer than the ambient environment, in this case by an amount of ten degrees celsius (10.degree. C.). When this amount of heating is detected indicating that the battery has reached the overcharge condition in an appreciable amount, the fast charge function is terminated

Upon completion of fast charge, a maintenance charge function is initiated which continues to monitor the battery temperature rise above the ambient environment (step 37-15) and maintains an applied overcharge current at a level that regulates that battery temperature rise. The overcharge temperature rise is held to eight degrees celsius (8.degree. C.) as shown by steps 37-16, 37-17, and 37-18; this being a safe sustainable level that may be maintained indefinitely without appreciable cumulative damage to the battery. The temperature regulation process is implemented by selecting between a low charge current of sixty milliamperes (60 ma.) and the higher overcharge current table value depending on the measured temperature rise. By maintaining the batteryin a state of continuous safe overcharge, it is possible to hold the battery in its maximum state of charge when it has been returned to the charge, thereby ensuring that the user has the full battery capacity available whenever needed. If the battery temperature falls below the ambient temperature as determined at step 37-15, the fast charge state will be re-entered which will apply the maximum safe charge current for the measured temperature. It should be noted that this situation might occur if a very warm battery pack is placed in a pack charger at nominal temperature. Initially if the temperature difference is greater than 10.degree. C. the pack will be charged at a fixed current of 60 ma until the temperature difference is reduced. If the pack temperature is less than 36 degrees C. at this time, its temperature difference may still be very close to 10 degrees C. which might allow the process to advance to the final maintenance state of the charge system. As the pack cools further due to ambient cooling and the endothermic charging reaction, its temperature may go below the ambient temperature (step 37-15), at which point the fast charge state would be re-entered.

In the maintenance mode, the current required for operation of a terminal is provided by the fact that the charge current (step 37-17 or 37-18) will exceed the terminal operating current by an amount necessary to maintain the temperature rise of the battery. Consequently, this charging system provides broad flexibility for fast charging of NiCad batteries in utilization devices with widely varying current demands.

A useful feature of this charging method is that it is not critical that the charging voltage source be able to provide the maximum current specified by the controlling microcomputer for reliable charging to be accomplished. For example, if the selected value of charge current for a certain battery pack is 1500 ma., but the voltage source has a current capacity of only 600 ma., the fast charge state of the procedure would be maintained in exactly the same way except it would take correspondingly longer for the overcharge state to be reached. This feature of the charging method is particularly useful in configurations where multiple battery packs may be charged in a single unit and it is necessary to place constraints on the unit power supply for economic or size reasons. It is a relatively simple matter to externally limit the maximum delivered current so that the actual charge current is less than the value selected by the controlling microcomputer.

FIG. 38 shows a schematic diagram of a charge current regulator circuit which has the capability of delivering a constant current output to a battery in proportion to an input control voltage. In addition, this circuit has a maximum delivered current limit that may be set by a resistor selection in power supply constrained applications.

The CHARGE CONTROL input 38-10 is intended to be driven by a digital to analog (D/A) converter out put of a microcomputer based utilization device such as a data terminal. The CHARGE CONTROL input develops a control voltage at pin 3 of differential amplifier 38-U1. The output pin 1 of 38-U1 drives 38-Q3 which establishes a current through 38-R8 that develops a voltage at 38-UI, pin 4 equal to the voltage at 38-U1, pin 3. Since the current gain h.sub.fe of 38-Q3 is relatively high (about 200) the collector current of 38-Q3 is nearly equal to the emitter current, resulting in an equal current through both 38-R5 and 38-R8. Since these resistors are of equal magnitude, the input voltage at CHARGE CONTROL 38-10 appears across 38-R5 referenced to the +12 volt supply voltage. The amplifier at 38-U1A pins 8, 9 and 10 is a differential configuration operating in a negative feedback mode. With a voltage developed across 38-R5, the voltage at pin 9 of 38-U1A will be decreased, which increases the voltage at the output pin 8. This increased voltage drives current into 38-Q2 which increases the drive current to 38-Q1 establishing a current through current sense resistor 38-R6. When the voltage drop across 38-R6 equals the voltage across 38-R5, the amplifier output will stabilize, holding the output current constant. With a sense resistor value of one ohm at 38-R6, the voltage to current conversion factor is one ampere per volt (1 amp./volt). If the CHARGE CONTROL input is left unconnected, the 1.25 volt voltage reference 38-CR1 and resistors 38-R2 and 38-R4 establish an open circuit voltage of 0.120 volts which establishes a "default" output current of 120 ma. This condition may be useful in cases where a utilization device is either unintelligent or its battery is completely depleted in which case its processor is unable to operate and the battery must be brought up to at least minimal capacity for the processor to function.

The circuit block consisting of the amplifier at 38-U1B pins 5, 6 and 7 is a clamp circuit that limits the maximum voltage that may be applied to 38-U1, pin 3. By limiting the input voltage, the maximum available charge current may then be limited to some selected value dependent on the selection of 38-Rl5 and 38-R16. With values of twenty-one kilohms for 38-Rl5 and ten kilohms for 38-R16, a voltage of 0.40 volts is applied to the clamp circuit input. If the input voltage driven on CHARGE CONTROL is less than 0.40 volts the output pin 7 of 38-U1B remains low which biases 38-Q4 off. If the CHARGE CONTROL input voltage reaches or exceeds 0.40 volts, 38-Q4 is turned on sufficiently to maintain a voltage of exactly 0.40 volts at 38-U1B pin 5 which prevents the input voltage to the control amplifier from exceeding this voltage. The voltage to current transfer function of the system is shown in FIG. 39. It should be noted that the clamp voltage and maximum available current may be modified by selecting different.values for 38-R15 and 38-R16 or the voltage reference 38-CR1. A maximum available current of 1.25 amps may be implemented by deleting 38-R16 in which case the full reference voltage appears at the clamp circuit input.

The microprocessor system means 28-10 or 32-10 operates automatically to apply substantially maximum charging current to the battery means consistent with avoiding substantial detriment to the useful life of the battery means e.g. as represented in FIG. 34.

DISCUSSION OF COMMON FEATURES IN THE EMBODIMENTS OF FIGS. 29 AND 37

A basic step of each embodiment is to compare battery temperature and ambient temperature as represented at 29-18 and 37-1. As indicated by FIG. 36, where ambient temperature is 20.degree. C. (68.degree. F.), the increase in battery temperature because of higher ambient temperature is relatively moderate for an initial battery temperature approaching 10.degree. C. (50.degree. F.). Thus, if battery temperature is at least 10.degree. C. (step 37-3), and if ambient temperature is within 10.degree. C. of battery temperature (step 370-), a substantial charging current may be supplied (37-13) even if the battery has not previously been checked for the overcharge condition (as in steps 29-20 to 29-23).

In each embodiment, charging current may be applied according to a fast charge characteristic such as shown in FIG. 34.

For step 37-13, it has already been ascertained that battery temperature is between 10.degree. C. and 36.degree. C., a region of the overcharge characteristic of FIG. 33 which is least sensitive to charging current. Further, in each embodiment current is applied for only a limited time interval, e.g. one minute or less (see step 29-25), before battery temperature is read again for the purpose of detecting a change of battery temperature indicative of the overcharge condition.

For step 29-27 an increase in battery temperature of two degrees Celsius or greater is taken as an indication of the overcharge condition.

For steps 37-14 to 37-16, the battery temperature is initially less than 10.degree. C. greater than ambient temperature (step 37-1), so that if battery temperature increases so as to be equal or greater than the sum of ambient temperature and 10.degree. C., this can be taken as indicating the overcharge condition. The comparison to ambient temperature plus 10.degree. C. at step 37-14 can take place frequently, e.g. at one minute intervals where steps 37-13 and 37-14 are repeated cyclically.

Step 37-17 can be taken as setting a current value corresponding to 0.2C. (C equals 1200 milliampere-hours) which according to Table II would be suitable for temperatures between about -25.degree. C. and 60.degree. C. Since ambient temperature is assumed to be maintained between 10.degree. C. and 36.degree. C., a low value of sixty milliamperes would be suitable for Table I also, even assuming no current being taken by load 28-21.

In each embodiment, measurement of battery terminal voltage is utilized to obtain a measure of load current. In FIG. 29, this is accomplished by increasing current in steps of say ten milliamperes (at 29-8) and sensing when battery voltage increases (step 29-11).

In FIG. 37, an initial current value of sixty milliamperes (step 37-6) is increased or decreased as measured battery voltage fluctuates in comparison to a reference value (XV, step 37-5). Thus, the current supplied is roughly equal to the required load current until such time as battery temperature increases above 10.degree. C.

DISCUSSION OF THE EMBODIMENT OF FIG. 37

Steps 29-1 to 29-12 are not inconsistent with the processing steps of FIG. 37, and could be used therein to identify a given battery pack, and/or to determine terminal load current during charging.

Steps 29-7 to 29-14 could be substituted for step 37-4 if desired.

Also, step 29-14 could be used in place of step 37-6, whereupon, steps 37-9 to 37-12 could be omitted. Steps 29-14 could also be substituted for step 37-2 or step 37-17.

It may be helpful to give the operation of FIG. 37 for the case of a specific example. If ambient temperature of the charge system which is to receive a terminal or battery pack is 20.degree. C. (68.degree. F.) and the pack is initially at 0.degree. C. (32.degree. F.), step 37-2 will apply until the battery pack reaches a temperature of 10.degree. C. (50.degree. F.). At this time, the temperature differential will be 10.degree. C., and step 37-13 will be executed. For a battery according to Table II, the value of fast charging current would be 1.314C. This value would also be selected based on characteristic of FIG. 34.

Step 37-14 could be performed at suitable time intervals, e.g. one minute intervals. While battery temperature remained below 30.degree. C., the fast charge rate would be successively adjusted (step 37-13) at e.g. one minute intervals according to Table II if necessary. Between 14.degree. C. and 30.degree. C., the fast charge rate might be at 1.600C, as also indicated in FIG. 37, where such a charge rate was available from the regulator circuit.

When the battery temperature exceeds 30.degree. C., initially the temperature would exceed room temperature by more than 10.degree. C., and a current of nominal value, e.g. comparable to load current would be selected. As the battery then cooled toward ambient temperature, e.g. below 28.degree. C., current would be set according to step 37-18, e.g. at 0.300C or 360 milliamperes.

Generally, by means of steps 37-1 to 37-4, it is insured that the battery has a state such that its temperature will not increase at a substantial rate due to a higher ambient temperature, and that the overcharge condition can be detected by the subsequent step 37-14.

Step 37-14 follows step 37-13 at a suitable limited time interval, e.g. a one-minute interval so as to insure against any substantial detriment to the useful life of the battery, should the battery be in the overcharging condition.

It will be apparent that features of the various embodiments described or incorporated herein may be combined, and that various of the features may be utilized independently of others, and that many further modifications and variations may be effected without departing from the scope of the teachings and concepts of the present disclosure.

Claims

We claim as our invention:

1. In a battery conditioning system, (a) rechargeable battery means for supplying operating current during a number of hours of portable operation so as to become progressively discharged as a result, (b) battery conditioning system means for coupling with said rechargeable battery means for supplying current to said rechargeable battery means during a battery conditioning cycle, after a period of portable operation, (c) said battery conditioning system means comprising computer means having input means for receiving measures of battery temperature at successive times during such battery conditioning cycle, (d) current control means for coupling with said rechargeable battery means for controlling the rate of current flow to the rechargeable battery means during a battery conditioning cycle, and (e) said computer means having output means coupled with said current control means for dynamically varying the rate of current flow to said rechargeable battery means during a battery conditioning cycle as a function of battery temperature as monitored by said computer means without relying on measured battery voltage.

2. In a battery conditioning system according to claim 1, said computer means adjusting said current control means during a battery conditioning operation so as to reduce the rate of current flow when the battery temperature shows a substantial increase unrelated to a higher ambient temperature.

3. In a battery conditioning system according to claim 2, said rechargeable battery means comprising nickel-cadmium rechargeable battery means.

4. In a battery conditioning system according to claim 1, said rechargeable battery means comprising nickel-cadmium rechargeable battery means.

5. In a battery conditioning system according to claim 4, said computer means automatically controlling said current control means so as to avoid extended overcharging of the rechargeable battery means at a rate exceeding rated capacity divided by twenty for lower limit battery temperatures.

6. In a battery conditioning system according to claim 1, said computer means automatically operating so as to avoid substantial extended overcharging of the battery means while the battery temperature is outside a temperature range while providing respective progressively increased values of overcharge current for respective progressively increased values of battery temperature when substantially within said temperature range.

7. In a battery conditioning system according to claim 6, said battery means comprising nickel-cadmium battery means, and said computer means being automatically operative to supply overcharge current values as a function of battery temperature between capacity divided by about twenty and capacity divided by about three.

8. In a battery conditioning system according to claim 1, said computer means automatically operating to provide respective successively increased values of current over a given temperature range such that overcharge current is increased by a factor of at least four for the high end of the given temperature range in comparison to the low end of the given temperature range.

9. In a battery conditioning system according to claim 8, said battery means comprising a nickel-cadmium battery means wherein current supplied to the battery means becomes overcharge current when most of the supplied charge causes generation of oxygen gas.

10. The method of charging a battery means having a temperature characteristic when subject to overcharge current which exhibits a rising temperature as a function of overcharge current duration, said method comprising (a) insuring that the battery means has a state such that its temperature will not increase at a substantial rate due to a higher ambient temperature, and that the battery means will exhibit a substantially greater increase in battery temperature when subjected to overcharge current than when subjected to charging current when it is not over charged, (b) automatically applying current to the battery means of a substantial magnitude, but measuring battery temperature within a time interval after applying the current such as to avoid substantial detriment to the useful life of the battery means prior to such measurement, (c) automatically sensing any change of battery temperature which is distinctive of the overcharge condition of the battery means so as to automatically determine whether or not the battery means is in overcharge condition without relying on measured battery voltage, and (d) automatically according to the result of step (c), applying a relatively high charge rate as a function of battery temperature to said battery means while the battery means is sensed not to be in the overcharge condition, and applying a relatively lower charge rate to said battery means when the battery means is in the overcharge condition, and in each case selecting the charge rate so as to avoid substantial detriment to the useful life of the battery means, wherein said relatively high charge rate varies dynamically as a function of battery temperature.

11. The method of charging according to claim 10 with step (a) comprising (a1) automatically comparing battery temperature of said battery means with ambient temperature to determine if the temperature of the battery means will increase at a substantial rate due to a higher ambient temperature.

12. The method of charging according to claim 11, with step (a) further comprising (a2) if step (a1) shows such a higher ambient temperature, automatically applying a relatively low current to the battery means consistent with an overcharge condition of the battery means.

13. The method of charging according to claim 12, with step (a) additionally comprising (a3) intermittently repeating step (a1) until battery temperature is sufficiently high to enable the sensing of an overcharge condition by means of steps (b) and (c).

14. The method of charging a battery means which may have a load requiring current during charging operation, said method comprising (a) assuring that battery temperature is not substantially outside a given temperature range before applying substantial charge to the battery means, (b) reading battery voltage and applying current to the battery means, (c) sensing load current by determining whether the applied current has increased battery voltage, and (d) so long as the battery temperature is substantially outside the given temperature range, increasing the value of the applied current to the battery means until the applied current increases battery voltage to take into account the load on the battery means.

15. In a battery conditioning system according to claim 1, said computer means, including programming, and including connection means for obtaining a measure of the voltage of the battery means from a battery voltage measuring means and automatically operating to provide respective successively increased values of current flow rate to compensate for battery load, until such time as battery voltage has stabilized, and maintaining a current flow rate which compensates for battery load until the battery temperature has increased to a selected temperature value suited to fast charging operation.

16. In a battery conditioning system according to claim 15, said battery means comprising a nickel-cadmium battery means wherein current supplied to the battery means becomes overcharge current when most of the supplied charge causes generation of oxygen gas.

17. The method of charging a battery means having a temperature characteristic when subject to overcharge current which exhibits a rising temperature as a function of overcharge current duration, said method comprising: (a) insuring that the battery means has a sate such that its temperature will not increase at a substantial rate due to a higher ambient temperature, and that the battery means will exhibit a substantially greater increase in battery temperature when subjected to overcharge current that when subjected to charging current when it is not overcharged, by monitoring both absolute temperature of the battery means and relative temperature between the battery means and ambient temperature, and automatically maintaining temperature of the battery means within absolute and relative limits, (b) automatically applying dynamic charging current to the battery means of a substantial magnitude, the substantial magnitude varying dynamically as a function of battery temperature but measuring battery temperature within a time interval after applying the current such as to avoid substantial detriment to the useful life of the battery means prior to such measurement, (c) automatically sensing any change of battery temperature which is distinctive of the overcharge condition of the battery means so as to automatically determine whether or not the battery means is in overcharge condition without relying on measured battery voltage, and (d) automatically according to the result of step (c), applying a relatively high charge rate varying dynamically as a function of battery temperature to said battery means while the battery means is sensed not to be in the overcharge condition, and applying a relatively lower charge rate varying dynamically at least for a period of time as a function of battery temperature to said battery means when the battery means is in the overcharge condition, and in each case selecting the charge rate so as to avoid substantial detriment to the useful life of the battery means, (e) measuring ambient temperature and, after the battery means has reached the overcharge condition, current flow rate is automatically and dynamically adjusted according to the differential between battery temperature and ambient temperature, so as to maintain the battery means substantially in a fully charged condition.

18. The method of charging according to claim 17, (e1) step (e) comprises applying current according to a safe overcharge value as a function of battery temperature, where the battery temperature does not substantially exceed ambient temperature.

19. The method of charging according to claim 18, (e2) step (e) further comprises applying a current value not substantially exceeding battery load current where battery temperature substantially exceeds ambient temperature.

20. The method of charging according to claim 19 with step (e) comprising selecting between steps (e1) and (e2) in dependence upon whether battery temperature exceeds ambient temperature by a value of about eight degrees Celsius.

21. The method of charging a battery means which may have a load requiring current during charging operation, said method comprising (a) measuring battery voltage and applying moderate current to the battery means, (b) measuring battery temperature at successive times and determining whether battery temperature is substantially outside a given temperature range before applying substantial charge to the battery means, and if it is outside such temperature range, (c) sensing whether the applied current has increased battery voltage, (d) compensating for current drawn by the load by increasing the value of the current to the battery means by a small increment where battery voltage has not substantially increased within a given time interval, and (e) repeating step (d) until the applied current to the battery means increases the battery voltage.

22. In a method according to claim 21, repeating steps (b), (c), and (d) until such time as battery voltage corresponds to the measured value, or battery temperature is within said given temperature range.

23. In a method according to claim 21, repeating steps (b) and (c), and where battery voltage has increased above the measured value, decreasing current to the battery means by a small increment, so that battery voltage is maintained in the vicinity of the measured value until such time as battery temperature is within the given temperature range, whereupon a fast charge may be applied.

24. The method of charging a battery means wherein a utilization device containing the battery means may present a varying load requiring load current during charging operation, said method comprising: (a) measuring battery voltage and applying moderate current to the battery means; (b) measuring battery temperature at successive times and determining whether battery temperature is substantially outside a given temperature range before applying substantial charge to the battery means, and if it is outside such temperature range; (c) applying a current value to the utilization device according to the varying current demands thereof, wherein the current value is determined by measuring battery voltage and determining whether the applied moderate current to the battery means has substantially increased the measured battery voltage; and (d) supplying low current to the battery means where useful to increase the temperature thereof.

25. The method of charging a battery means wherein a utilization device containing the battery means may present a varying load requiring load current during charging operation, said method comprising: (a) measuring battery voltage before applying fast charge current to the battery means; (b) measuring battery temperature at successive times and determining whether battery temperature is substantially outside a given temperature range before applying substantial charge to the battery means, and if it is outside such temperature range; (c) applying current values to the utilization device according to the varying current demands thereof, wherein the current value is determined by measuring battery voltage and determining whether the applied moderate current to the battery means has substantially increased the measured battery voltage; and (d) supplying essentially zero current to the battery means where useful to allow the temperature thereof to decrease.

26. In a battery conditioning system, (a) rechargeable battery means for supplying operating current during a number of hours of portable operation so as to become progressively discharged as a result, (b) battery conditioning system means for coupling with said rechargeable battery means for supplying current to said rechargeable battery means during a battery conditioning cycle, after a period of portable operation, (c) said battery conditioning system means comprising computer means having input means for receiving measures of battery temperature at successive times during such battery conditioning cycle, (d) current control means for coupling with said rechargeable battery means for controlling the rate of current flow to the rechargeable battery means during a battery conditioning cycle, (e) said computer means having output means coupled with said current control means for dynamically varying the rate of current flow to said rechargeable battery means during a battery conditioning cycle as a function of battery temperature as monitored by said computer means without relying on measured battery voltage; and (f) wherein a utilization device receives operating current from the current control means according to widely varying current demands of the utilization device, concurrently with the dynamic variation of the rate of current flow to the rechargeable battery means.

27. The method of charging a battery means wherein a utilization device of portable construction may present a varying load requiring current during charging operation, said method comprising: (a) assuring that battery temperature is not substantially outside a given temperature range before applying substantial charge to the battery means; (b) reading battery voltage and applying current to the battery means; (c) supplying load current according to widely varying current demands of the utilization device while accommodating fast charging of the battery means consistent with maximum safe power availability; and (d) so long as the battery temperature is substantially outside the given temperature range, applying a current value to the utilization device according to the widely varying current demands thereof while supplying current to the battery means where useful to adjust the temperature thereof, wherein the applied current value is determined by reading battery voltage and determining whether the applied current to the battery means has substantially increased the voltage of the battery means.

28. A method of charging a battery means which may have a load requiring current during charging operation, said method comprising: (a) measuring battery voltage and applying moderate current to the battery means; (b) sensing at the battery whether there is a load on the battery means by sensing whether the applied current has increased battery voltage; and (c) increasing current to the battery means where a load is sensed to be present to accommodate load current in addition to a selected charging current.

29. A method of charging a battery pack while supplying operating current to a load, said method comprising: applying charging current to the battery pack; sensing at the battery the current required by the load by sensing whether the applied current has increased battery voltage; and adjusting the applied charging current based on the sensed current required by the load such that the applied current is sufficient for supplying operating current to the load and is sufficient for supplying charging current to the battery pack.

30. A method of charging a battery pack for a portable terminal requiring operating current during charging operation, said method comprising: applying a current to the battery pack; determining the operating current requirements of the portable terminal; determining an appropriate amount of current to be supplied to the battery pack so that operating current may be supplied to the portable terminal while the battery pack charges by sensing whether the applied current has increased battery voltage; and adjusting the current applied to the battery pack to correspond to the determined appropriate amount of current.

31. The method of charging a battery means wherein a utilization device containing the battery means may present a varying load requiring load current during charging operation, said method comprising: (a) measuring battery voltage and applying moderate current to the battery means; (b) measuring battery temperature at successive times and determining whether battery temperature is substantially outside a given temperature range before applying substantial charge to the battery means, and if it is outside such temperature range; (c) applying a current value to the utilization device according to the varying current demands thereof; and (d) supplying low current to the battery means where useful to increase the temperature thereof.

32. The method of charging a battery means wherein a utilization device containing the battery means may present a varying load requiring load current during charging operation, said method comprising: (a) measuring battery voltage before applying fast charge current to the battery means; (b) measuring battery temperature at successive times and determining whether battery temperature is substantially outside a given temperature range before applying substantial charge to the battery means, and if it is outside such temperature range; (c) applying current values to the utilization device according to the varying current demands thereof; and (d) supplying essentially zero current to the battery means where useful to allow the temperature thereof to decrease.

33. In a battery conditioning system, (a) rechargeable battery means for supplying operating current during a number of hours of portable operation so as to become progressively discharged as a result, (b) battery conditioning system means for coupling with said rechargeable battery means for supplying current to said rechargeable battery means during a battery conditioning cycle, after a period of portable operation, (c) said battery conditioning system means comprising computer means having input means for receiving measures of battery temperature at successive times during such battery conditioning cycle, (d) current control means for coupling with said rechargeable battery means for controlling the rate of current flow to the rechargeable battery means during a battery conditioning cycle, (e) said computer means having output means coupled with said current control means for dynamically varying the rate of current flow to said rechargeable battery means during a battery conditioning cycle as a function of battery temperature as monitored by said computer means; and (f) wherein a utilization device receives operating current from the current control means according to widely varying current demands of the utilization device, concurrently with the dynamic variation of the rate of current flow to the rechargeable battery means.

34. The method of charging a battery means wherein a utilization device of portable construction may present a varying load requiring current during charging operation, said method comprising: (a) assuring that battery temperature is not substantially outside a given temperature range before applying substantial charge to the battery means; (b) reading battery voltage and applying current to the battery means; (c) supplying load current according to widely varying current demands of the utilization device while accommodating fast charging of the battery means consistent with maximum safe power availability; and (d) so long as the battery temperature is substantially outside the given temperature range, applying a current value to the utilization device according to the widely varying current demands thereof while supplying current to the battery means where useful to adjust the temperature thereof.

35. A method of charging a battery means which may have a load requiring current during charging operation, said method comprising: (a) measuring battery voltage and applying moderate current to the battery means; (b) sensing whether there is a load on the battery means; and (c) increasing current to the battery means where a load is sensed to be present to accommodate load current in addition to a selected charging current.

36. A method of charging a battery pack while supplying operating current to a load, said method comprising: applying charging current to the battery pack; sensing the current required by the load; and adjusting the applied charging current based on the sensed current required by the load such that the applied current is sufficient for supplying operating current to the load and is sufficient for supplying charging current to the battery pack.

37. A method of charging a battery pack for a portable terminal requiring operating current during charging operation, said method comprising: applying a current to the battery pack; determining the operating current requirements of the portable terminal; determining an appropriate amount of current to be supplied to the battery pack so that operating current may be supplied to the portable terminal while the battery pack charges; and adjusting the current applied to the battery pack to correspond to the determined appropriate amount of current.

38. A method of charging a battery which may have a load requiring current during charging operation, said method comprising: (a) providing a current source for supplying charging current to the battery; (b) sensing whether there is a load on the battery and when the battery has a load, determining the amount of current required by the load; and (c) adjusting the current source to supply a current sufficient both to charge the battery and, where a load is present, to supply the required load current.

39. The method of claim 38, wherein step (b) further comprises sensing whether battery voltage has decreased, and wherein step (c) comprises increasing the charging current by a small increment.

40. The method of claim 39, further comprising the steps of repeating steps (b) and (c) until such time as battery voltage increases.

41. An apparatus for charging a battery in an electronic device comprising: (a) a current source for applying a controlled charging current to the battery; and (b) means for detecting battery charging conditions including means for detecting the presence of a load in addition to the battery and for controlling the current source such that an appropriate charging current is applied to the battery according to the detected charging conditions.

42. A method of charging a battery means having a load requiring current during charging operation, said method comprising: (a) providing a source of adjustable current for supplying current to the battery means and the load; (b) determining the amount of current required by the battery means and the load; and (c) adjusting the source of current to supply a current sufficient both to charge the battery means and to supply the required load current.

43. The method of claim 42, wherein a portable terminal has a communication link with the source of adjustable current, the step (b) of determining comprising receiving a signal from the portable terminal representing at least in part the load presented by the terminal.

44. The method of claim 42, wherein a portable terminal has a communication link with the source of adjustable current, the step (b) of determining comprising receiving a signal from the portable terminal representing at least in part an optimum or near optimum charging current for the battery means.

45. The method of charging a battery pack comprising the steps of: (a) applying a charge increment to a rechargeable battery means; (b) measuring a parameter sensitive to accumulation of charge by the battery means; (c) repeating steps (a) and (b) as necessary to effect a determination of any load current being supplied by the battery means; and (d) carrying out a battery charging operation by supplying to the battery means a charging current taking account of any load current as determined by step (c).

Patent Citations (32)

Patent	Date	Inventor
US3599071	1971-08-01	Lapuyade et al.
US3911350	1975-10-01	Swope
US3917990	1975-11-01	Sherman, Jr.
US4125802	1978-11-01	Godard
US4237411	1980-12-01	Kothe
US4308493	1981-12-01	Kothe
US4346336	1982-08-01	Crawford
US4370606	1983-01-01	Kakumoto et al.
US4424476	1984-01-01	Mullersman
US4455523	1984-06-01	Koenck
US4553081	1985-11-01	Koenck
US4607208	1986-08-01	Vreeland
US4649333	1987-03-01	Moore
US4667143	1987-05-01	Cooper et al.
US4670703	1987-06-01	Williams
US4692682	1987-09-01	Lane et al.
US4709202	1987-11-01	Koenck
US4716354	1987-12-01	Hacker
US4829226	1989-05-01	Nakamura
US4829259	1989-05-01	Konopka
US4833390	1989-05-01	Kumada et al.
US4862013	1989-08-01	Konopka
US4885522	1989-12-01	Konopka
US4885523	1989-12-01	Koenck
US5013993	1991-05-01	Bhagwat et al.
US5136231	1992-08-01	Faulk
US5150031	1992-09-01	James et al
US5204611	1993-04-01	Nor et al.
US5363031	1994-11-01	Miller et al.
US5463305	1995-10-01	Koenck
DEXA-2520599	1976-11-01
WOXWO-A-8902182	1989-03-01

Abstract

Description