Technical Field
This invention relates to the general subject of oil well and gas drilling and, in particular to apparatus and methods used to drill a curved wellbore in the surface of the earth.
Background of the Invention
There are many enhanced recovery methods used to maximize the total oil recovered from fields. Unfortunately, even after the latest techniques are used, vast oil resources are left unproduced.
Lateral wellbores offer the potential to drain more oil than would be recovered otherwise. Laterals can be used to tap fresh oil by intersecting fractures, penetrating pay discontinuities, and draining up-dip traps. Lateral re-completions can also be used to correct production problems, such as water coning, gas coning, and excessive water cuts from hydraulic fractures which extend below the oil-water interface. Synergistic benefits may result from coupling lateral re-completions with enhanced recovery techniques to solve conformance problems, to contact un-swept oil by re-completing injection wells, and to re-direct sweep by converting existing well patterns into line-drive configurations. Lateral re-completions strategies can take advantage of the current production infrastructure, capital resource of existing wellbores, known resources of oil in place, and secondary and tertiary recovery technology.
When drilling laterals the rate of inclination change is usually described by the radius of curvature of the borehole. This is different from conventional drilling where curved boreholes are often described by the build or drop rate in degrees per 100 feet. A "short radius" curve is generally considered to have a radius of curvature of less than 150 feet. A "medium radius" is about 150 to 300 feet and a "long radius" curve is anything beyond 300 feet. For comparison, a 5 degree per 100 feet build is approximately equal to a 1,000 foot radius curve. None of the various curve rates (short, medium, long) are inherently better than the others. Depending on the objectives for a given well and the constraints of the situation, one curve rate will often be more suitable than another. However, as a general rule, short radius curves are often more desirable in re-completions where there is minimal open hole between the casing seat and the target zone. The shorter the radius, the less likely a section will need to be removed from the casing. Short radius curves also allow submersible pumps to be located close to pay zones. And the shorter the curve, the less formation above the target zone will need to be penetrated. This may reduce the problems associated with having open hole exposed to unstable shales, gas caps, and other producing zones. As the radius of curve gets smaller, so does the length of the lateral which can be drilled. Small radius curves also restrict the types of completions which can be performed. For example, it would not be realistic to case a 30 foot radius curve conventionally.
When drilling a curved borehole having a short radius of curvature, a flexible or an articulating drill pipe section is added to the curve drilling assembly (e.g., see U.S. Pat. Nos. 5,210,533 and 5,194,859 assigned to Amoco Corporation). The articulating section typically comprises short sections of pipe having articulating joints, or the like, as would be known to one skilled in the art. The articulating section is provided so the drill string does not impair the ability of the curve drilling assembly to drill a short radius curved borehole (i.e., a conventional drill string often does not have enough flexibility to traverse the short radius curved borehole and therefore may not allow the assembly to drill a short radius curved borehole and, if it is placed in a short radius curve, it may fatigue and fail after only a few rotations). The articulating section preferably extends uphole from the curve drilling assembly through the curved portion of the borehole.
Articulated drill collars are commonly called "wiggly pipe". They are constructed by cutting a series of interlocking lobed patterns through the wall of steel drill collars (e.g., see U.S. Pat. Nos. 4,483,721 and 4,476,945). Each such collar is fitted with a high pressure hydraulic hose and seal assembly. Historically, these collars have been the only reasonable option for rotating through a short radius curve, but they are not ideal because they attempt to straighten under compressive loading, cause the drillstring to rotate rough, complicate the procedure for orienting the deflection sleeve and are difficult to handle.
A major impediment to the widespread use of lateral re-entries is that drilling and completion of the laterals must be done economically. Workover economics in mature fields requires substantial cost reductions over the methods most often used for drilling new horizontal wells. Thus, there is a continuing need for reliable reduced-cost lateral drilling systems and tools, particularly tools that are easy to use with commonly used components and parts of curved drilling systems.
One situation that often occurs is the need to enlarge or widen a curved section of a well bore after the curve drilling is completed. For example, it is sometimes helpful to open a 33/4" or a 315/16" curve to 43/4". The larger opening facilitates running the lateral drilling assembly and reduces the torque required to rotate wiggly pipe in the curved section while lateral drilling. Opening the hole also makes the wiggly pipe more "fishable" in case it becomes lost in the hole. If a 43/4" drill bit or a conventional 43/4" PDC reaming tool (e.g., see U.S. Pat. Nos. 1,332,841; 4,431,065; and 3,851,719) was used to do this, drilling torque would be very erratic and the penetration rate would be slow. Moreover, existing reaming tools have not been proven to be very durable. Clearly, improvement is needed.
Summary of the Invention
A general object of the invention is to provide a tool for opening or enlarging the borehole formed by a short radius curved drilling assembly.
Another object of the invention is to provide a hole opener for a shot-radius drilling assembly.
One particular object of the invention is to provide a low friction hole opener.
Still another object of the invention is to provide an apparatus that makes wiggly pipe sections easier to fish, if they were to fail in a short radius curved borehole.
Yet another object of the invention is to provide a more durable hole opener.
In accordance with the present invention, disclosure is made of a hole opener for use with a flexible drill string. The hole opener comprises: a base disposed about a longitudinal bit axis for connecting to the downhole end of the flexible drill string; a gauge portion that is disposed about the longitudinal bit axis, that extends from the base, that has an uphole end and that has a downhole end; a nose disposed about the longitudinal bit axis and extending from the gauge portion; a plurality of cutting elements that are carried by and extend from the gauge portion and that produce a lateral force on the hole opener at its downhole end in response to the rotation of the hole opener in the borehole; lower reaction pad means, carried by and extending from the gauge portion to trail behind the cutting elements by a maximum of 180 degrees and located generally below the cutting elements, for continuously contacting the borehole wall during rotation of the hole opener and for receiving a reactive force that is from the borehole, that is in response to the lateral force and that is directed adjacent to the downhole end of the hole opener, the lower reaction pad means extending from the longitudinal bit axis by no more than the bore in which the hole opener is inserted; and upper reaction pad means, carried by and extending from the gauge portion to trail behind the cutting elements by a maximum of 180 degrees and located generally above the cutting elements, for continuously contacting the borehole wall during rotation of the hole opener and for receiving a reactive force that is from the borehole, that is in response to the lateral force and that is directed adjacent to the uphole end of the hole opener, the upper reaction pad means extending from the longitudinal bit axis by approximately the same amount as the cutting elements, the lower reaction pad means and the upper reaction pad means having the effect of directing the longitudinal axis of the base portion to be tangent to the centerline of the curved portion of the borehole in which it is inserted.
The new tool operated much better than any other tool used for opening a curved borehole. It has been used successfully in several wells and has resulted in no problems to date. Numerous other advantages and features of the present invention will become readily apparent from the following detailed description of the invention, the embodiments described therein, from the claims, and from the accompanying drawings.
Brief Description of the Drawings
FIG. 1 is a schematic diagram of the downhole end of a drill string having the hole opener that is the subject of the present invention;
FIG. 2 is an enlarged view of the lower end of the bore and the tool of FIG. 1;
FIG. 3 is a elevation view of the hole opener of FIG. 1; and
FIG. 4 is a cross-sectional view of the hole opener of FIG. 3, as viewed along line 4--4.
Detailed Description
While this invention is susceptible of embodiment in many different forms, there is shown in the drawings, and will herein be described in detail, one specific embodiment of the invention. It should be understood, however, that the present disclosure is to be considered an exemplification of the principles of the invention and is not intended to limit the invention to the specific embodiment illustrated.
Turning to FIG. 1, the downhole end of a short radius curved drill string 9 is shown in a curved borehole 12 of an oil or gas well. The borehole 12 is characterized by a radius of curvature R.sub.b. The drill string 9 is operated by a conventional rotational drive source (not shown in the drawings for purposes of simplicity and known to those skilled in the art) for drilling in subterranean earthen materials to create a borehole 12 having a borehole wall 11. The drilling tool 10 or "hole opener," that is the subject of the invention, is located at the end of the drill string 9. In particular, the hole opener 10 comprises a base 14, a gauge portion 16, a drilling pilot or "bullnose" 18, a plurality of cutting elements 20, a lower reaction pad 22; and an upper reaction pad 24. The hole opener 10 is used to enlarge the diameter of the borehole 12. The interior of the tool 10 has a central bore 15 for ducting drilling fluid through openings 17 in the nose 18.
The base 14 is located at the up-hole end of the tool 10 and is disposed about a longitudinal axis 26 The base provides a means for connecting the tool 10 to the downhole end of a section of wiggly pipe 28. The gauge portion 16 is generally cylindrical in shape and also disposed about the longitudinal axis 26. The gauge portion 16 extends downwardly from the base 14. The gauge portion 16 has an uphole end and an opposite downhole end. The bullnose 18 is also disposed about the longitudinal axis 26 and extends downwardly from the gauge portion 16. The bullnose 18 has a length that is sufficiently short, relative to the length of the gauge portion 16 and the base 14, that the end of the nose does not contact the outside wall 13 (see FIG. 1) of the curved borehole 12.
The cutting elements 20 extend from the gauge portion 16. The cutting elements 20 produce a lateral force on the hole opener 10 in response to the rotation of the hole opener in the borehole 12. Preferably, the cutting elements 20 are close enough to the first flexible interlocking lobe of wiggly pipe 28 that the lobe does not engage the curved borehole wall 11 and cause the tool 10 to be inclined with respect to the borehole centerline (at radius R.sub.c) at the blade. In other words, if the gauge portion 16 is located at a distance R.sub.g from the longitudinal axis 26, the cutting elements 20 are located at a distance R.sub.c from the longitudinal axis, and the borehole has a radius of curvature R.sub.b, the cutting elements are preferably located at a distance L from the downhole end of the flexible section of drill pipe 28 that is connected to the hole opener 10, where L has a magnitude on the order of the square root of the product of R.sub.b and (R.sub.c -R.sub.g).
The lower reaction pad 22 is carried by and extends from the gauge portion 16. It is positioned to "trail" (i.e., relative to the normal direction of rotation of the drill pipe 28) behind the cutting elements 20 by a minimum of 90 degrees and a maximum of 180 degrees (See FIG. 4). The lower reaction pad 22 is located generally below the axial position of the cutting elements 20 and substantially continuously contacts the borehole wall 12 during rotation of the hole opener 10. The lower reaction pad 22 receives a reactive force F.sub.RL that is from the borehole wall 12, that is in response to the lateral force from the cutting elements 20, and that is directed adjacent to the downhole end of the gauge portion 16 of the hole opener 10. The lower reaction pad 22 extends from the longitudinal axis 26 by no more than the bore (i.e., 2R.sub.g in which the hole opener 10 is inserted).
The upper reaction pad 24 is carried by and extends from the gauge portion 16. It is positioned generally above the cutting elements 20 and to "trail" behind the cutting elements by a minimum of 90 degrees and a maximum of 180 degrees. The upper reaction pad 24 substantially continuously contacts the borehole wall 12 during rotation of the hole opener 10. The upper reaction pad 24 receives a reactive force F.sub.RU that is from the borehole 12, that is in response to the lateral force from the cutting elements 20, and that is directed next to the uphole end of the gauge portion 16 of the hole opener 10. The upper reaction pad 24 extends from the longitudinal axis by about the same amount R.sub.c as the cutting elements 20 (see FIG. 3).
The lower reaction pad 22 and the upper reaction pad 24 have the effect of positioning the longitudinal axis 26 of the hole opener 26 to be tangent (see FIG. 1) to the centerline of the curved portion R.sub.b of the borehole 12 in which it is inserted. Preferably, the upper reaction pad 24 and the lower reaction pad 22 are located about 120 degrees behind the cutting elements 20 with the upper reaction pad directly above the lower reaction pad. The exact radial position of the pads is determined by considering the magnitude and direction of the two reactive forces F.sub.RL and F.sub.RU. Radial separations as much as 90 degrees may be possible. The upper reaction pad 24 and the lower reaction pad 22 are not continuous when viewed from either end of the tool (see FIG. 4). Each pad is broken by a series of longitudinal grooves or channels 30 formed on the exterior surface of the tool. These channels 30 allow drilling fluid released from the nose part 17 to return upwardly to the well head while lubricating the cutters 20 and flushing earthen materials removed by the cutters.
Each of the cutting elements 20 preferably comprises a poly-crystalline diamond (PCD) compact material mounted on a support, such as a carbide or steel support. The cutting elements 20 may, of course, include other materials such as natural diamond and thermally stable polycrystalline diamond material. Each of the cutting elements 20 has a base disposed in the gauge portion 16 and a cutting edge for contacting the subterranean earthen materials of the bore. The cutting elements 20 are oriented with a flat side in the penetrating direction so they cut a flat ledge, rather than a tapered ledge. This orientation was selected because it is believed that, with a tapered edge, the tool 10 might take too big a bite which would cause the tool to run rough. As shown in FIG. 2, there are two distinct cutting elements or cutters 20a and 20b. One cutter 20a is located closer to the uphole and of the tool 10. As such, the lower cutter 20b engages the walls 11 of the borehole in advance of the upper cutter 20a. More than two distinct cutters may be employed. Only two cutters 20a and 20b are shown for simplicity.
The cutting elements 20 create a net imbalance force F.sub.i along a net imbalance force vector that is substantially perpendicular to the longitudinal bit axis 26 when the tool 10 is rotated. Before proceeding, it is appropriate to state the preferred features and properties of the imbalance force F.sub.i, the various forces acting on the tool 10 during rotation, and how these forces are managed.
The imbalance force F.sub.i may be provided by a mass imbalance in the tool 10. Preferably, the imbalance force is produced by the cutting elements 20. When produced by the cutting elements 20, the magnitude and direction (See FIG. 3) of net imbalance force vector F.sub.i will depend on the position and orientation of the cutting elements (e.g., the specific arrangement of cutting elements 20a and 20b on the tool 10 and the shape of the gauge portion 16 on which they are located. Orientation includes the backrake and the siderake of the cutting elements. The magnitude and direction of the net force vector F.sub.i is also influenced by the specific design (e.g., shape, size, etc.) of the individual cutting elements 20a and 20b, the load applied to the tool 10, the speed of rotation, and the physical properties of the subterranean earthen material being drilled. By "load" is meant the longitudinal or axial force applied by the rotational drive source downhole on the drill string 9.
In any case, the cutting elements 20 are located and positioned to cause net imbalance force vector F.sub.i to maintain substantially the reaction pads 20 and 24 in contact with the borehole wall when the tool is used. Preferably, the cutting elements 20 are located and positioned to cause net imbalance force vector F.sub.i to have an equilibrium direction, and to cause net radial imbalance force vector to return substantially to the equilibrium direction in response to a disturbing displacement. These aspects of the invention and the related forces on the drill bit are discussed in U.S. Pat. Nos. 5,213,168; 5,131,478; 5,042,596 and 5,111,892--all assigned to Amoco Corporation. The position and arrangement of the cutting elements 20 shown in the drawings is by way of illustration, however, and not by way of limitation. For example, cutting elements 20 may be positioned in a non-linear pattern, a curved pattern, or they may be positioned in a non-uniform, random pattern on the blade. All of the cutting elements 20 serve to produce a net imbalance force vector F.sub.i that is located substantially perpendicular to the longitudinal bit axis 26 when the tool is used.
The reaction pads 22 and 24 have preferably sliding, borehole engaging surfaces 32a and 32b for intersecting a force plane that is defined by the net imbalance force vector F.sub.i and the longitudinal axis 26. Preferably, these bearing or sliding surfaces 32a and 32b form substantially continuous regions that are devoid of cutting elements and borehole abrasive surfaces. The cutting element devoid regions intersect a force plane defined by the longitudinal tool axis 26 and net imbalance force vector F.sub.i. This force plane is conceptual and is useful for reference purposes and in explaining the effect of the net imbalance force vector F.sub.i on the tool 10. When the drilling tool 10 is viewed longitudinally as shown in FIG. 3, this force plane emerges in the plane of the drawing sheet.
Preferably, the bearing surfaces 32a and 32b substantially and continuously contact the borehole wall 12 when the tool 10 is used. Preferably, the bearing surfaces 32a and 32b are substantially smooth and wear-resistant (e.g. a 1/16 inch hard-coat for 2Rg=45/8 inches) and slidably contact the borehole wall when the tool 10 is used. In particular, the lower reaction pad 32b preferably should not have cutters on its lower end. If cutters are placed there, the tool 10 will have a tendency tilt in the borehole which will cause poor performance and excessive tool wear. Non-cutting pad/surfaces 32a and 32b should be located above and below the cutters 20 to make the tool 10 stay centered in the hole.
The specific size and configuration of bearing surfaces 32a and 32b will depend on the specific tool 10 design and application. Preferably, the bearing means or sliding surfaces 32a and 32b extend along substantially the entire length of the gauge portion of the tool 10. Preferably, the sliding surfaces 32a and 32b are sufficiently large in surface area so, as the sliding surfaces are forced against the borehole wall, the applied forces will be much less than the compressive strength of the subterranean earthen materials of the borehole wall. This keeps the sliding surfaces 32a and 32b from digging into and crushing the borehole wall, which could result in the creation of an undesired whirling motion and over-gauging of the borehole 26. Preferably, the sliding surfaces 32a and 32b have a size sufficiently large to encompass net imbalance force vector F.sub.i as that vector moves in response to changes in hardness of the subterranean earthen materials and to other disturbing forces within the borehole. Preferably, the size of the sliding surfaces 32a and 32b is also selected so that the net imbalance force vector F.sub.i remains encompassed by the sliding surface as the cutting elements 20 wear.
The operation of the tool 10 will now be described. Once a short radius curve 12 is drilled and the curve drilling tool is withdrawn from the wellbore, the hole opening tool 10 is attached to a sufficient length of wiggly collars to traverse the curved borehole. The hole opening tool 10 is then tripped into the wellbore and positioned at the top (i.e., beginning) of the curve. Next, the mud pumps are engaged and drilling fluid is circulated through the drillstring and the tool 10. Rotation of the assembly is initiated and the drillstring is slowly advanced. The advancement rate is controlled so the force applied to the hole opening tool 10 is not excessive. As the tool 10 advances through the curve, it enlarges it from diameter of 2R a diameter of 2Rc.
From the foregoing description, it will be observed that numerous variations, alternatives and modifications will be apparent to those skilled in the art. Accordingly, this description is to be construed as illustrative only and is for the purpose of teaching those skilled in the art the manner of carrying out the invention. Various changes may be made, materials substituted and features of the invention may be utilized. For example, the bearing surfaces 32a and 32b may comprise one or more rollers, ball bearings, or other low friction load bearing surfaces. The sliding or bearing surfaces 32a and 32b may comprise the same material as other portions of tool 10, or a relatively harder material such as a carbide material. In addition, the bearing surfaces 32a and 32b may include wear-resistant coatings or diamond impregnation, a plurality of diamond stud inserts, a plurality of thin diamond pads, or similar inserts or impregnation that strengthen the bearing surfaces and improve their durability. The elevation of the upper reaction pad 24 may also be selected to act as a penetration rate limiter to help keep the operating torque smoother. Similarly, a penetration rate limiter can be installed on the up-hole side of the tool to limit the depth of cut of the cutters 20 (for example, a penetration rate of 20 ft/hr at 60 RPM). Moreover, a sizing cutter can be added down-hole of the cutters 20 to insure the tool would work even if the original bore were slightly undersize (i.e., a 315/16 inch cutter for a 315/16 inch bore being enlarged to 43/4 inches). This sizing cutter may lead to degraded performance since it can cut out the low side of the curved borehole and cause the tool to tilt. Thus, it will be appreciated that various modifications, alternatives, variations, etc., may be made without departing from the spirit and scope of the invention as defined in the appended claims. It is, of course, intended to cover by the appended claims all such modifications involved within the scope of the claims.