US 5,344,617 AGrant
Apparatus for Converting Noxious Pollutants From Flue Gas Into Merchantable by-Products
Issue Date:1994-09-06
•17 Claims
•4 Drawing Sheets
Abstract
A system and method of converting flue gas pollutants to marketable byproducts of ammonium bisulfite and ammonium bisulfate, which are collected, and to other harmless byproducts which may be safely discharged is provided. The system removes as much particulate material and reaction inhibiting coal tar components as possible via an electrostatic precipitator and then passes the flue gas through a heat exchanger, wherein it is cooled by boiler feedwater. A suds producing detergent is introduced to the flue gas in order to separate any remaining coal tar components from the condensing moisture. Due to the removal of the tar components, sulfur dioxide and nitrous oxide readily dissolve in the condensing moisture when sufficiently cooled.
Metadata
Inventor
- Arthur F. Johnson
Application Information
Application Number:US 0977837
Filing Date:1993-07-26
Priority Date:1992-05-26
Art Unit:181
Classifications
IPC:
F01N 302B01D 5334
Field of Search:
42242395165172-175;178235;243.06;230;2101547;133;905
Patent Drawings (4 sheets)
Description
Field of the Invention
This invention relates to a system for the removal of noxious pollutants, including compounds of sulfur and nitrogen, from boiler plant flue gases. It also relates to a system for the production of ammonium bisulfate and ammonium bisulfite.
Background of the Invention
Boiler plants, particularly those which generate heat through the combustion of coal, are well known sources of air and water pollution. The emissions of sulfur from these plants have been well-documented as a major contributor to the problem of "acid rain". Various toxic or otherwise undesirable compounds are also produced during the combustion of coal, these including uranium, beryllium, chromium, barium, arsenic, selenium, mercury and coal tar.
The worsening environmental impact of the above described pollutants has become increasingly apparent in the last decade. Thus, considerable resources have been expended to come up with reliable and environmentally acceptable ways of removing the pollutants from flue gas emissions.
The currently available techniques for removing these pollutants include cooling the flue gas down to condensation within a heat exchanger that heats boiler feedwater. The prior art, for example, recognizes that cooling flue gases that contain sulfur trioxide and water vapor will result in condensation of sulfuric acid. See U.S. Pat. No. 4,526,112 to Warner; U.S. Pat. No. 4,874,585 to Johnson et al; and U.S. Pat. No. 4,910,011 to Dorr et al.
Although the aforementioned systems are more or less effective in removing some degree of the pollutants from the flue gas, they merely shift the pollution category from atmospheric waste to solid waste. Attempts have therefore been made to convert pollutants into useful products as they are removed from the flue gases.
One such approach involves the introduction of ammonia to combine with sulfur oxides in flue gases and form ammonium bisulfite and/or ammonium bisulfate.
This approach fails to address the presence of other pollutants in the flue gas, such as nitrogen compounds, uranium, beryllium, chromium, barium, arsenic, selenium, mercury and coal tar. Further, optimum transfer of heat to the boiler feedwater requires the utilization of densely packed tubes through the heat exchanger. Thus, the approach as described above is inefficient and commercially impracticable because the dry products produced thereby have a tendency to buildup on the tubes and to severely impede the flow of flue gas.
It has been further recognized in the prior art that SO.sub.2 is not readily oxidized to SO.sub.3 despite the presence of sufficient atmospheric oxygen in the flue gas to react therewith. In response to this recognition, the prior art has introduced oxidizing agents such as hydrogen peroxide (H.sub.2 O.sub.2) dissolved in water in order to precipitate H.sub.2 SO.sub.4 from the sulfur dioxide within the heat exchanger. See, for example, U.S. Pat. No. 4,783,326 to Srednicki. However, the added cost of introducing the required amount of oxidizing agents make such systems economically unattractive as well as complex.
It is therefore an object of the present invention to provide a system for economically removing pollutants from flue gas by which substantially all oxides of sulfur and nitrogen, as well as other harmful contaminants are removed.
It is a further object of the invention to provide such a system in which the oxides of sulfur and nitrogen are not merely removed from the flue gas to be disposed elsewhere, but are converted into useful and environmentally safe substances, particularly ammonium sulfate, ammonium bisulfate, and ammonium sulfite.
It is another object of the present invention to provide such a system in which the formation of the useful byproducts does not hamper the proper functioning of the apparatus.
Summary of the Invention
These and other objects of the present invention that would be apparent to one skilled in the art are provided by the present invention, which comprises a heat exchanger located along a duct containing flue gas to exhaust, means for introducing an ammoniacal substance to said flue gas, means for introducing a suds producing detergent to the flue gas, means for collecting ammonium bisulfate and ammonium bisulfite formed by the reaction of the ammoniacal substance with oxides of sulfur in the flue gas, and means for removing particulate material from the flue gas before it enters the heat exchanger.
Boiler feedwater is delivered to the heat exchanger after passing through a condenser. The boiler feedwater moves upwardly through the heat exchanger through either acid-proof copper alloy pipes or between closely spaced, acid-resistant roll-bonded sheets having serpentine circuits therebetween.
According to another aspect of the invention, a method of removing pollutants from the flue gases includes exchanging heat between flue gas and condensed boiler feedwater to cool the flue gas down to a first temperature whereat substantially all SO.sub.3 in the flue gas is combined with H.sub.2 O, condensing the SO.sub.3 and H.sub.2 O from the flue gas as a first condensate, adding a solution containing an ammoniacal substance and a suds producing detergent to the flue gas, collecting the soap suds produced after the adding step and the first condensate as a first solution, and separating ammonium bisulfate from the first solution.
The method further includes the steps of exchanging heat between said flue gas and cooling water at a precisely controlled temperature to cool the flue gas down to a second temperature, condensing H.sub.2 O from the flue gas as a second condensate, dissolving SO.sub.2 in the flue gas into the second condensate; and collecting the second condensate and part of the ammoniacal substance introduced during said addition step to form a second solution containing ammonium bisulfite.
Brief Description of the Drawings
FIG. 1 is a flow chart showing the arrangement of the components of the present invention along the flows of flue gas and boiler feedwater in a typical power plant application;
FIG. 2 is a humidity chart showing the LBS of water per LB of "bone dry" flue gas.
FIG. 3 is a cut-away view of the heat exchanger showing a arrangement of roll-bonded sheets which may be used to carry boiler feedwater through the heat exchanger.
FIG. 4 is a detail of the end of the tubes which may be used in the heat exchanger in lieu of roll-bonded sheets.
FIG. 5 is a cutaway view showing the connection between the tubes of the arrangement in FIG. 4.
FIG. 6 is a diagrammatic flowsheet showing the arrangement of the heat exchanger, recirculating air lift, and mineral flotation and filtering system.
Detailed Description of the Preferred Embodiment
The flow diagram of FIG. 1 shows the basic configuration of the invention within a conventional power plant system. Fossil fuel 2 is supplied to a boiler 4 which produces steam. The steam drives turbines 6, and a condenser 8 then cools the steam, returning it to the boiler feedwater state. The condensed feedwater 10 exits the condenser at about 40.degree. F. to 80.degree. F. Some remaining wet steam 12 is used in a preheater 14 for the boiler feedwater, which is returned to the boiler via pumps 16.
Flue exhaust gas 18 leaving the boiler is first cooled from about 700.degree. F. to about 600.degree. F. by passing it through an air preheater 20. Preheating the boiler combustion air increases the efficiency of boiler combustion.
The flue gas is next directed through an electrostatic precipitator or baghouse 24 to remove particulates 26, such as fly ash. This serves two purposes. First, by removing them prior to introduction of the flue gas into the heat exchanger, the particulates are prevented from accumulating on the heat exchanging surfaces and thus from interfering with heat transfer processes. Second, the adverse effects of particulate pollutants on the desired reactions taking place within the heat exchanger are minimized.
As a matter of chemistry, it has long been known that the presence of certain substances can have a "negative catalytic effect" on reactions between other substances. Fly ash and other particulates in the flue gas contain coal tar components such as phenol, which can act as a negative catalyst to the reactions sought by the present invention. For example, one of the reactions sought by this invention and impeded by the presence of coal tar components is the reaction of SO.sub.2 in the flue gas with ammonium hydroxide.
For the above reasons, the baghouse 24 is placed ahead of the heat exchanger 26 to minimize the amount of the coal tar derivatives present in the flue gas. After the flue gas passes through baghouse 24, wherein it may cool to a temperature of approximately 700.degree. F., the flue gas is drawn downwardly at approximately 40 feet per second through a vertical heat exchanger 26 by a conventional induced draft fan, not shown. Heat is exchanged therein between the flue gas and boiler feedwater thereby reducing the amount of fuel needed to heat the feedwater.
As best shown in FIG. 3, the heat exchanger is preferably comprised of a acid proof housing, preferably formed of plastic, and a vertical column of consecutive, spaced layers of acid proof fluid conveying means carrying boiler feedwater therethrough.
Preferably, the fluid conveying means are parallel, horizontally spaced sheets 23 of stainless steel or other corrosion resistant metal having a serpentine circuit provided between adjacent sheets. The serpentine circuits are formed by a plurality of vertically spaced, horizontally extending raised portions or corrugations 21 on the surfaces of the sheets 23. These raised portions are preferably formed on the sheets by rollbonding, although any conventional method of producing spaced projections on a sheet of metal may be used.
The sheets are preferably arranged so that respective raised portions 21 of one sheet are positioned opposite to corresponding flat portions of the sheet facing it. The alternating "washboard" arrangement of raised portions and flat portions on each sheet results in a zig-zag flow pattern which greatly increases the heat transfer rate. Each serpentine circuit includes an inlet 23a, where cool water enters the heat exchanger, and an outlet 23b where hot water exits the heat exchanger.
Alternatively, and as illustrated in FIGS. 4 and 5, vertically spaced, horizontally extending tubes 72 may be used in lieu of the roll bonded sheets. Preferably, tubes 72 are constructed of a nylon coated copper nickel alloy. However, other metal or metal alloys having high thermal conductivity and suitable corrosion protection may also be used. The ends of tubes 72 are connected by a suitable bend as shown in FIG. 5.
As shown in FIG. 6, the layers of heat exchanging pipes or rollbonded sheets are arranged in three sections 30, 40, and 50. The sections are separated from each other by inverted pyramid shaped pans 31 and 41, each of the pans serving to collect and funnel corresponding condensate solutions which precipitate at various temperatures within the heat exchanger. The condensate solution flowing through conduit 32 collected by the first pan 31 contains both noxious impurities as well as marketable ammonium sulfate. The condensate solution flowing through conduit 45 collected by the second pan 41 contains ammonium sulfite, herewith converted to ammonium bisulfate. Lastly, a third pan 51 forms the base of the heat exchanger and collects purified condensate 42 from the flue gas for disposal in streams, lakes, or the ocean. Preferably, these pans are made of plastic and have deep, downwardly sloping grooves formed on their upper surfaces to carry off condensates from high velocity flue gas.
Even after it passes through the baghouse 24, I have found that the flue gas 18 still contains significant quantities of phenol and other compounds. Further, I have discovered that these trace quantities form a coating on each and every drop of condensing moisture and that this coating resists the dissolution of SO.sub.2 into the condensate.
The present invention ensures that the SO.sub.2 contained in the flue gas is dissolved in the moisture of condensation by means which will be explained below. According to the invention, solid ammonium bisulfate or ammonium sulfite, useful as fertilizer, is then formed by the introduction of a sufficient amount of either ammonia or ammonium hydroxide, and a suds-producing detergent or soap into the flue gas at certain specified locations.
The operation of the present invention may be best understood by reference to FIG. 6. As the flue gas is cooled in the heat exchanger 26, H.sub.2 SO.sub.4 is produced by the reaction of the SO.sub.3 with H.sub.2 O. These reactions begin at high temperatures with SO.sub.3 producing H.sub.2 SO.sub.4 with no molecules of H.sub.2 O at 626.degree. F., 1 molecule of water at 554.degree. F., 2 molecules of H.sub.2 O at 333.degree. F., and 4 molecules of H.sub.2 O at 250.degree. F.
When the flue gas has been cooled to a temperature below 212.degree. F. but still above the point of condensation of moisture (which will vary depending upon the fuel used), fine sprays 17 of ammonium hydroxide and suds-producing detergent or soap are injected, via line 13, under pressure from pump 15 into the flue gas from locations around the acid proof plastic enclosure housing the heat exchanger. These sprays are added just before the first moisture condenses within the flue gas, preferably at a point within 2.degree. F. from the moisture condensation point.
It is important that ammonia not be added at a temperature too much above the moisture condensation point because crusts of ammonium sulfate may form on the walls of the chamber or between the closely spaced layers of acid-proof heat exchanger tubes or rollbonded sheets which contain the condenser feedwater. To achieve precise regulation of the flue gas temperature, cooling water 11 having a precisely controlled inlet temperature is preferably introduced into the heat exchanger. The cooling water may be drawn from a conventional tank or reservoir 19 and introduced by several layers of acid proof pipes or roll bonded sheets at a point just following the level where NH.sub.4 OH is injected,
The SO.sub.3 reports in the first condensate as H.sub.2 SO.sub.4, which in turn reacts with some of the injected ammonium hydroxide to form ammonium bisulfate. A solution 32 containing ammonium bisulfate, soap suds, and other trace pollutants collects in first pan 31 and drains into a conventional mineral flotation machine 34. The flotation machine 34 has a plurality of mineral flotation cells 35. The soot and other coal tar components collected with the first solution 32 is floated to the surface of the floatation cells 35 via tiny soap bubbles and moves from right to left by skimmers 36 which rotate clockwise. The "pulp" or liquid solution of soluble ammonium sulfates and insolubles which are suspended therein moves from right to left through the cells and into a V-shaped tank 37. Waste, soot, and insoluble pollutants are separated and removed from the liquid solution by a vacuum filter 43, whereafter a purified solution of soluble ammonium sulfates 44 may be removed, separated by differential crystallization, and then marketed as crop fertilizer or the like.
Referring now to FIG. 2, it is possible to determine how much H.sub.2 O will condense from the flue gas as it is cooled. Burning 1 lb of coal normally produces approximately 10 lbs of flue gas. Using the chart of FIG. 2, cooling 10 lbs of flue gas from 120.degree. F. to 116.degree. F. will condense 1.2 lbs of H.sub.2 O. At approximately 115.degree. F., the SO.sub.2 in the flue gas will dissolve into the soot-free condensing moisture, whereafter it reacts with ammonium hydroxide to produce ammonium sulfite in accordance with the following formula:
The resulting condensate containing the ammonium sulfite collects on the second pan 41 for removal and conversion into ammonium bisulfate as will be described below.
Although the present invention is capable of dissolving all of the SO.sub.2 into the H.sub.2 O and converting it to (NH.sub.4).sub.2 HSO.sub.3 (ammonium bisulfite), it may be necessary to supply more water than that provided by condensation. Accordingly, sufficient water may be included in the ammonium hydroxide and detergent sprays, if production of ammonium bisulfite, instead of ammonium sulfite, is desired at this stage.
The collected ammonium sulfite drains from the second pan 41 and is introduced into an inlet 61 of a conventional recirculating Pohl air lift 60. Preferably, the recirculating lift 60 comprises a cylindrical tank 62 having an approximate height of 30 feet and an approximate diameter of 6 feet axially aligned within a Pohl air lift pipe 63 having a diameter of approximately 10 feet. Ammonia (NH.sub.3) and atmospheric oxygen O.sub.2 are introduced through an inlet 64 in the bottom of the tank 62. The lift evolves moist air, which exits through an outlet 65 proximate the top of the lift pipe 63, thus concentrating the solution contained therein. The NH.sub.3, O.sub.2, and NH.sub.2 HSO.sub.4 react in the recirculating lift in accordance with the following equation:
The ammonium bisulfate produced is collected and removed from the lift at arrow 66, whereupon it may be marketed as a crop fertilizer as previously described.
In some cases, it is recognized that a power plant may be unable to obtain boiler feed water cold enough to cool the flue gas below 120.degree. F. Here again the present invention advantageously utilizes the injection of fine sprays of water into the heat exchanger in order to cool the flue gas by the heat of evaporation. For example, 0.01 lbs of added H.sub.2 O cools the flue gas by the heat of evaporation, which in this case equals 10 BTU/0.29 (specific heat of flue gas) or 34.degree. F. Flue gas at a temperature of 130.degree. F., for example, may thus be cooled to 96.degree. F. by injecting additional water. The injected cooling water must be at 86.degree. F. or less in order to cool the flue gas to 96.degree. F. in the manner described above.
Preferably the action of the heat exchanger, supplemented if needed by additional water injection, cools the flue gas to approximately 50.degree. F.
Because the cooled flue gas has already been cleaned of soot and coal tar derivatives, the NO present therein will now readily dissolve in the H.sub.2 O. Once dissolved, the NO reacts with introduced atmospheric oxygen and the remaining ammonium hydroxide according to the following equation:
The NH.sub.4 NO.sub.2 then decomposes into N.sub.2 and H.sub.2 O.
The final purified condensate 42 collected in the base pan 51 is substantially detoxified and can be safely discharged through an outlet 52 as waste water from the facility. A set of demisting screens 53 is provided to catch droplets of moisture before the flue gas exits through the exhaust duct 54.
After the pollutants have been removed therefrom in the manner described above, the cleaned and cooled flue gas 28 is blown by an induced draft fan through an exit duct 54 by which it is led to a smoke stack 40.
Ordinarily, flue gas would contain more pollutants and would have to be discharged out of a high stack. However, a high flue gas temperature is necessary to successfully discharge gas through such stacks, which are often hundreds of feet high. The purity of the flue gas treated by the present invention allows a shorter stack to be used in discharging the gas. This, in turn, obviates the need to maintain the gas at an elevated temperature so that additional cooling and heat recovery may be obtained.
Claims
What is claimed is:
1. A heat exchanger and pollutant removal system for fossil fuel boiler plants, comprising: a fossil fuel boiler; an exhaust stack; heat exchanger means forming a portion of a duct which directs a flue gas stream from said fossil fuel boiler to said exhaust stack and having a flue gas inlet, a flue gas exit, and first fluid delivery means for carrying a first fluid and removing heat from the flue gas; a source of ammoniacal substance; means on said heat exchanger means, and in fluid connection with said source of ammoniacal substance, for introducing said ammoniacal substance into said flue gas; and first means, located below said first fluid delivery means, for collecting and removing a first solution of soot, part of said ammoniacal substance, and SO.sub.3 dissolved in water, wherein the ammoniacal substance introducing means is located upstream of the collection and recovery means.
2. The system of claim 1 wherein said first fluid delivery means comprises a plurality of acid resistant metal tubes.
3. The system of claim 2 wherein the tubes are made of a copper-nickel alloy having a nylon coating on the exterior.
4. The system of claim 1 wherein said first fluid delivery means comprises a plurality of acid resistant, spaced, sheets having spaced projections thereon, adjacent sheets forming a serpentine circuit therebetween.
5. The system of claim 4 wherein the sheets are made of stainless steel.
6. A heat exchanger and pollutant removal system for fossil fuel boiler plants, comprising: a fossil fuel boiler; an exhaust stack; heat exchanger means forming a portion of a duct which directs a flue gas stream from said fossil fuel boiler to said exhaust stack and having a flue gas inlet, a flue gas exit, and first fluid delivery means for carrying a first fluid and removing heat from the flue gas; a source of ammoniacal substance and a source of suds-producing detergent; means on said heat exchanger in fluid connection with said source of ammoniacal substance for introducing said ammoniacal substance and means for introducing a suds-producing detergent into said flue gas; first means, located below said first fluid delivery means, for collecting a first solution of suds, soot, part of said ammoniacal substance, and SO.sub.3 dissolved in water; and mineral flotation means connected to said first means for receiving the first solution.
7. The system of claim 1 wherein said collecting means includes means for separating soot from the first solution.
8. The system of claim 7 wherein the separating means comprise a vacuum filter.
9. The system of claim 1, wherein said heat exchanger further comprises second fluid delivery means for carrying a second fluid and removing heat from the flue gas, and wherein said system further comprises means for maintaining said second fluid at a predetermined temperature prior to delivery into said heat exchanger means.
10. A heat exchanger and pollutant removal system for fossil fuel boiler plants, comprising: a fossil fuel boiler; an exhaust stack; heat exchanger means forming a portion of a duct which directs a flue gas stream from said fossil fuel boiler to said exhaust stack and having a flue gas inlet, a flue gas exit, and first fluid delivery means for carrying a first fluid and removing heat from the flue gas; a source of ammoniacal substance and a source of suds-producing detergent; means on said heat exchanger means in fluid connection with source of ammoniacal substance for introducing said ammoniacal substance and means in fluid connection with said source of suds-producing detergent for introducing said suds-producing detergent into said flue gas; first means, located below said first fluid delivery means, for collecting a first solution of suds, soot, part of said ammoniacal substance, and SO.sub.3 dissolved in water; second fluid delivery means for carrying a second fluid to said heat exchanger means and removing heat from the flue gas; means for cooling said second fluid prior to delivery into said heat exchanger means; and second means for collecting a second solution containing SO.sub.2 dissolved in condensed water and part of said ammoniacal substance.
11. The apparatus of claim 10 further comprising means for removing said second solution.
12. The apparatus of claim 11 further comprising recirculating means for receiving said second solution from said removing means and having means for recirculating said second solution with an ammoniacal substance and air to produce ammonium bisulfate.
13. A heat exchanger and pollutant removal system for fossil fuel boiler plants, comprising: a fossil fuel boiler; an exhaust stack; heat exchanger means forming a portion of a duct which directs a flue gas stream from said fossil fuel boiler to said exhaust stack and having a flue gas inlet, a flue gas exit, and first fluid delivery means for carrying a first fluid and removing heat from the flue gas; a source of ammoniacal substance and a source of suds-producing detergent; means on said heat exchanger means in fluid connection with said source of ammoniacal substance and said source of suds-producing detergent for introducing said ammoniacal substance and suds-producing detergent into said flue gas; and first means, located below said first fluid delivery means, for collecting a first solution of suds, soot, part of said ammoniacal substance, and SO.sub.3 dissolved in water.
14. The system of claim 13 further comprising means for separating said suds and soot from said first solution.
15. The system of claim 14 wherein the separating means comprises a vacuum filter.
16. The system of claim 1 further comprising means for separating said soot from said first solution.
17. A heat exchanger and pollutant removal system for fossil fuel boiler plants, comprising: a fossil fuel boiler; an exhaust stack; heat exchanger means forming a portion of a duct which directs a flue gas stream from said fossil fuel boiler to said exhaust stack and having a flue gas inlet, a flue gas exit, and first fluid delivery means for carrying a first fluid and removing heat from the flue gas and second fluid delivery means for carrying a second fluid and further removing heat from the flue gas; a source of ammoniacal substance; means on said heat exchanger in fluid connection with said source of ammoniacal substance for introducing an ammoniacal substance into said flue gas; first means, located below said first fluid delivery means, for collecting a first solution of part of said ammoniacal substance and SO.sub.3 dissolved in water; second means located below said second fluid delivery means and said first solution collection means for collecting a second solution containing SO.sub.2 dissolved in condensed water and part of said ammoniacal substance.
Patent Citations (57)
| Patent | Date | Inventor | Cited By |
|---|---|---|---|
| US1685388 | 1928-09-01 | White | |
| US1709865 | 1929-04-01 | Muffly | |
| US1712085 | 1929-05-01 | Litle | |
| US2109780 | 1938-03-01 | Mott | |
| US2159043 | 1939-05-01 | Orr | |
| US2174792 | 1939-10-01 | Lampton | |
| US2212481 | 1940-08-01 | Sendzimir | |
| US2234839 | 1941-03-01 | Edwards | |
| US2244475 | 1941-06-01 | Raskin | |
| US2294137 | 1942-08-01 | Spofford | |
| US2399650 | 1946-05-01 | Moyer | |
| US2438851 | 1948-03-01 | Gates | |
| US2582358 | 1952-01-01 | Schoellerman | |
| US3442232 | 1969-05-01 | White | |
| US3456928 | 1969-07-01 | Selway | |
| US3607034 | 1971-09-01 | Henry et al. | |
| US3676059 | 1972-07-01 | Welty | |
| US3770385 | 1973-11-01 | Grey et al. | |
| US3839849 | 1974-10-01 | Maniya | |
| US3880618 | 1975-04-01 | McCrea et al. | |
| US3957951 | 1976-05-01 | Hokanson et al. | |
| US3962112 | 1976-06-01 | Shaheen | |
| US4051225 | 1977-09-01 | Shiga et al. | |
| US4089088 | 1978-05-01 | Konczalski | |
| US4101635 | 1978-07-01 | Nambu et al. | |
| US4140175 | 1979-02-01 | Darm | |
| US4160810 | 1979-07-01 | Benson et al. | |
| US4339883 | 1982-07-01 | Waldmann | |
| US4409191 | 1983-10-01 | Osman | |
| US4444128 | 1984-04-01 | Monro | |
| US4444128 | 1984-04-01 | Monro | |
| US4454100 | 1984-06-01 | Faatz | |
| US4466815 | 1984-08-01 | Southam | |
| US4526112 | 1985-07-01 | Warner | |
| US4557202 | 1985-12-01 | Warner | |
| US4582122 | 1986-04-01 | Fan | |
| US4597433 | 1986-07-01 | Johnson | |
| US4600561 | 1986-07-01 | Frei | |
| US4619671 | 1986-10-01 | Ruff et al. | |
| US4744967 | 1988-05-01 | Brand et al. | |
| US4776391 | 1988-10-01 | Warner | |
| US4781797 | 1988-11-01 | Johnson | |
| US4783326 | 1988-11-01 | Srednicki | |
| US4793981 | 1988-12-01 | Doyle et al. | |
| US4802897 | 1989-02-01 | Johnson | |
| US4829911 | 1989-05-01 | Nielson | |
| US4860821 | 1989-08-01 | Hagewood | |
| US4871522 | 1989-10-01 | Doyle | |
| US4874585 | 1989-10-01 | Johnson et al. | |
| US4876986 | 1989-10-01 | Johnson | |
| US4900403 | 1990-02-01 | Johnson | |
| US4910011 | 1990-03-01 | Dorr et al. | |
| US4932334 | 1990-06-01 | Patte et al. | |
| US4994245 | 1991-02-01 | Murray et al. | |
| US5051245 | 1991-09-01 | Wilson et al. | |
| US5122352 | 1992-06-01 | Johnson | |
| US5220887 | 1993-06-01 | Hiddleston et al. |
Non-Patent Literature (4)
- Charles Hodgerman, Robert Weast, Samuel Selby; Handbook of Chemistry and Physics; 43rd Edition; pp. 1704-1709, 1712-1713.
- P. G. L. Thorne & E. R. Roberts; Fritz Ephraim Inorganic Chemistry; 1943; pp. ix-xii, 178 and 694.
- Ralph F. Bovier; Proceedings of the American Power Conference; Apr. 14, 15 & 16 1964; article entitled "Sulfur-Smoke Removal System"; pp. 138-143.
- Raisaku Kiyoura, Haruo Kuronuma and Gisuke Uwanishi; Bulletin of the Tokyo Institute of Technology; No. 81, 1967; article entitled "Studies on the Recovery of Sulphur Dioxide from Hot Gases, to Control Air Pollution," pp. 1-5.