US 4,929,412 AGrant
Control Rod
Issue Date:1990-05-29
•5 Claims
•4 Drawing Sheets
Abstract
An apparatus and process for control rod assembly and construction for a nuclear reactor is disclosed wherein the control rod is of cruciform configuration having a plurality of and preferably four flat planar members. Each planar member is made up with an assembly of square cross sectioned tubular members. Each square cross sectioned tubular member includes a defined cylindrical center and a constant thickness surrounding tubular metallic shell to provide the contained neutron absorbing materials in a cylindrically shaped pressure vessel. The constant thickness surrounding tubular shell constituting the cylindrical shaped pressure vessel has four corner sections added to generate a modified square exterior profile. These added four corner sections comprise an addition to the tubular side wall thickness of the shell. Appropriate chamfers and rounding are provided to the square profile to impart both stress relief and convenient points for automated welding between side-by-side square sections. The square cross sectioned tubular members when welded together extend axially and longitudinally the length of the control rod in the direction of control rod movement and fluid flow. The square cross sectioned tubular members are filled with a neutron absorbing material, plugged at both ends, and fastened by welding in side-by-side relation to form the planar control rod members of the required cruciform shape. These square cross sectioned tubular members as welded in side-by-side relation are in integral portion of the longitudinal support structure of the control rod and fasten and interconnect the handle at the top of the control rod and a conventional velocity limiting device at the bottom of the control rod. The fastening of the handles and velocity limiting device at the respective top and bottom provides a secondary and supplemental seal to primary plugs containing the neutron absorbing material. If needed for enhanced life, provision is made for the incorporation of a hafnium plate in a rectangular sectioned tube adjacent the handle at upper end of the control rod, this tip being variable in length dependent upon individual control rod requirements. Thus square sectioned tubular members form an improved poison containing cylindrical volume for providing resultant improved control rod worth and increased in service life time in moderating and shutting down nuclear reactions. Consequently, the disclosed construction can be used both for conventional control rods as well as for control rod configured for control cell locations.
Metadata
Assignee
- General Electric Company
Inventors
- Robert C. Dixon
- James E. Cearley
- Paul Van Diemen
- Edwin D. Sayre
- Gerald M. Gordon
Application Information
Application Number:US 3369412
Filing Date:1989-04-11
Priority Date:1987-03-30
Art Unit:224
Classifications
IPC:
G21C 2118
Field of Search:
376228165122219260;463;333;327182;183;184;4.1;47168-1726 A121.63;121.64
Patent Drawings (4 sheets)
Description
Brief Description of the Drawings
Other objects, features, and advantages of this invention will be more apparent after referring to the specification and attached drawings in which:
FIG. 1 is a horizontal section taken from a control rod illustrating several square cross sectioned tubular members of this invention in side-by-side alignment:
FIG. 2A is a reduced section similar to FIG. 1 illustrating the partial composite construction of a cruciform shaped rod according to this invention and having a planar control rod member containing 15 side-by-side square sectioned tubes: and,
FIG. 2B is a section similar to FIG. 2A illustrating a control rod section incorporating 12 side-by-side square sectioned tubes:
FIG. 3 is a perspective view illustrating a control rod coming up from under four side-by-side fuel channels for absorbing neutrons in the control of a nuclear reaction:
FIG. 4 is a perspective view, partially broken away illustrating the control rod of FIG. 3 clear of the fuel channels of FIG. 3:
FIGS. 5, 6, and 7, are respective sections of the control rod of FIG. 4:
FIG. 8 is a detail of the tip of a control rod constructed in accordance with this invention illustrating the encapsulation of a hafnium tip in the rod to provide a control rod having long in service life: and,
FIG. 9 is a detail of plugs at one end of a the square sectioned tube illustrating plugging of the tube for the containment of the neutron absorbing materials within the cylindrical volume of the tube.
Referring to FIG. 1, an actual section of the composite control rod is illustrated. Applicants point out that while size is not normally construed to be indicative of invention, the construction of nuclear reactors renders size in this invention important.
The control rod herein can be fabricated to discrete sizes. By way of example, a square sectioned rod having 0.260 inch cross sectional dimension includes 0.190 inch inside diameter cylindrical volume. Alternately, a square sectioned rod having a 0.312 inch cross sectional dimension includes 0.240 inch inside diameter. Wall thickness of 0.030 inch is provided for both sizes. It will be seen with the aforementioned dimensions that the square section of the rod slightly exceeds the tube diameter. Other dimensions may as well be used.
A word about BWR nuclear reactors with quick reference to FIG. 3 is worthwhile. Specifically, the nuclear reactors have fuel channels 14 containing tubes 16. Interior of the tubes 16 are placed the nuclear fuel pellets which generates the chain nuclear reaction. BWR type reactors introduce the control rods from the bottom towards the top. Such a control rod R is shown in FIG. 3 coming up between the respective fuel channels 14.
Some further dimensions can be instructive. Typically, the control rods are 174 inches long. The length of fuel loading in a nuclear reactor can be in the range of 144 to 150 inches. Typically, the interstitial space between adjacent fuel channels is in the order of a half inch.
Mechanisms for moving the control rods are conventional and expensive to replace. Consequently, it is important that new control rods be of such size and such weight that no substantial alteration is required to the control rod drives, fuel, and core support hardware.
Typically, control rod drives precisely move the control rods R to positions of partial insertion for shaping the reactor "burn." Additionally, and for purposes of SCRAM, the control rods must move rapidly from any current position to full insertion within the reactor. In some types of reactors, the entire 12 foot length of the control rod must be capable of insertion into the interstices between fuel channels 14 in the range of 1.6 seconds. Consequently, acceleration and deceleration forces are to be reckoned with in the construction of the control rod. Moreover, the control rods must have sufficient rigidity to withstand anticipated seismic loadings.
Regarding seismic events, two conditions must be simultaneously considered in a design "worse case" scenario. First, and since the most significant component of seismic loading on a reactor is horizontal and dynamic, it can be anticipated that during a seismic event the individual fuel channels will have a bowed configuration. Secondly, and because of the seismic event, scraming of the reactor will be desired. Consequently, the control rods will have to be sufficiently flexible to penetrate the interstices of the fuel channels while having sufficient columnar strength to avoid buckling.
Having introduced the environment to which the invention resides, the rod construction itself may be rather simply understood.
Referring to FIG. 1, square sectioned tubular member 20A, 20B, 20C, and 20D are shown in side-by-side configuration. Taking the case of configuration 20C, the elemental construction of the square sectioned tubular member can be easily seen and understood.
Typically, each section includes a constant sectioned cylinder 30. Further, each tubular section includes four added corners. The added corners are corners 31, 32, 33, and 34.
A broken line has been drawn between each of the respective corner sections 31, 32, 33, and 34 and the constant sectioned cylinder 30. This broken line demonstrates that cylinder 30 has a constant side wall of thickness 36 that extends entirely around the defined cylindrical volume 40 of the control rod. This constant side wall thickness 36 provides the requisite containment and pressure resistant vessel required by the control rod construction.
Corner sections 31, 32, 33 and 34 serve at least two additional purposes.
First, the corner sections impart to the disclosed tube the required square cross section. The tubes can thus be welded in side-by-side relation.
Secondly, the corner sections constitute wear points. Where contact occurs between the fuel channels and the sides of the control rods, the respective corner sections 31, 32, 33, and 34 will effect such contact first. The tubular member will not at all be affected or worn.
Further, and as will be hereinafter discussed, the thickness of the corner sections prevents the weld from interfering with the structural integrity of the tube.
It is known that in metallic pressure vessels that sharp surfaces are to be avoided. Accordingly, each of the corner sections is provided with fillets 51, 52. These respective fillets define a transition between the respective corner sections and the tubular sides. Likewise, the corners are chamfered and rounded at area 53. Thus, the corners are not sharp and are specified to conform to tube fabrication technology, including for example drawing.
Referring to FIG. 1 and specifically at the corner 60 between rod 20B and 20C, the placement of welding metal is illustrated. It can be seen that the adjacent chamfered and rounded corners 53 between control rods 20B and 20C have defined a convenient interstitial area for the introduction of weld metal. The weld metal has penetrated in the shaded wedge shaped area illustrated at 60.
Regarding this shaded wedge shaped weld metal area, it will be seen that it penetrates the corner section only. It does not penetrate or interfere with the required tubular side wall 36 required around the cylindrical volume 40.
Further, it will be understood that there is produced a generally "V"-shaped groove between the respective tubular members 20B, 20C. This V-shaped groove is ideal for tracking by automated welding equipment. Thus the composite rod here set forth can be directly fabricated from automated welding techniques, preferably laser welding.
Having set forth construction and cooperation of the individual control rod sections, a composite control rod constructed in accordance with this invention a cruciform shape can be understood. Specifically and referring to FIG. 2A, 15 tubes T are shown welded in side-by-side relationship. The tubes T extend from a central intermittent and cruciformed solid member 70. The square cross sectioned tubular members together produce a planar side S of a control rod. As is apparent, four sides S can be attached to central intermittent member 70 to impart to the rod the required cruciform cross section.
The disclosed design includes flexibility in the number and location of individual cylindrical volumes used to contain neutron absorbing material. Referring to FIG. 2B, a control rod including only 12 side-by-side tube T is illustrated for placement in a reactor at a location having lesser neutron fluence. As is apparent, the number of tubes utilized in the control rod can vary as individual control rod parameters likewise vary.
Referring to FIG. 3, the completed rod is illustrated at R. It is shown in the interstices between four adjacent fuel channels 14. The completely assembled control rod is shown in a position to control nuclear reaction, the position here illustrated being close to full insertion.
Having illustrated the rod in its controlling environment in FIG. 3, attention can now be directed to the details of fabrication of the control rod. First the overall control rod configuration will be set forth with respect to FIG. 4. Thereafter, the various control rod sections will be discussed with respect to FIGS. 5, 6 and 7. Plugging of the ends of the control rod will be discussed with respect to FIG. 9. Finally, the addition of hafnium tips to the end of the control rod will be set forth with respect to FIG. 8.
Referring to FIG. 4, a completed control rod is illustrated. The control rod includes a velocity limiter V at the bottom, a handle H at the top and four respective planar sides S1, S2, S3 and S4 therebetween.
Unlike the prior art, the disclosed control rod includes cruciformed shaped tie segments 50 placed at respective intervals to brace the respective planar sides S1-S4 one with respect to another. Segments 50 are not continuous the longitudinal length of the disclosed control rod. Instead they are intermittent.
The limiting factor in the number of such segments is a combination of both flexibility and imparted columnar strength to the control rod during anticipated seismic events. Spacers 50 are provided at intervals so that the control rod may be flexible to enter the interstices between dynamically bowed fuel cells during seismic events. At the same time, the spacers 50 are placed to ensure to the control rod the desired degree of columnar strength to prevent columnar buckling during seismic event insertion.
This design gives the rod three respective profiles.
Referring to FIG. 5, the profile of the rod at a cruciformed shaped segment 50 is illustrated. Specifically, planar sides S1-S4 are all joined to the cruciformed shaped segment 50.
Referring to FIG. 6, the cross section of the control rod is illustrated at an interstitial location between segments 50. At this location, it is seen that the respective planar surfaces S1-S4 are not joined. Thus, the prior art continuous tie rod is completely omitted.
It has been emphasized that the tube segments T participate as structural members of the disclosed control rod configuration. This participation enables elimination of a continuous tie rod and allows intermittent segments 50.
It should be understood that the cruciform segments 50 here illustrated are not absolutely required. For example, intermittent plates can be used as well. Such plates would preferably alternately brac opposite surfaces S1 and S4 and thereafter surfaces S2 and S3.
Referring to FIG. 4 at section 7--7 and FIG. 7 it can be seen that the velocity limiter end of the rod has a cruciform configuration similar to both the handle and the planar rod members S1-S4. Referring to FIG. 7, respective planar sections V1-V4 are illustrated.
Referring to FIG. 9, a typical tube T is illustrated. Tube T is shown with a plug P inserted within cylindrical volume 40 of the tube. Plug P is placed at both ends of the tube so as to confine neutron absorbing materials interior of the rods.
It will be appreciated that the neutron absorbing material placed within cylindrical volume 40 is typically confined to boron carbide (B.sub.4 C) It will be appreciated that the control rod may be filled with any of the known vocabulary of neutron absorbing materials. Hafnium rods, for example, can be partially or wholly placed within such tubes T. Combinations of hafnium rods with boron carbide can be used. Likewise, other known neutron absorbers such as europium or dysprosium can as well be used.
Once plug P is placed in the end of rod T to plug cylindrical volume 40, the plug P is typically welded at the interstices between the outer diameter of the plug P and the cylinder 40. Placement of the plug P typically occurs after the individual rods T have been placed in side-by-side relation.
Once the plugs P are welded and in place, the respective ends of the rod T and the plugs P are typically machined, as by milling, to a finished surface 60 shown in broken lines on FIG. 9. Thus, it will be appreciated that the respective sides S1-S4 are ready for their respective attachments to the velocity limiter V and the handle H.
Regarding such attachment, it will now be understood that the attachment causes a secondary seal to occur at the respective ends of the individual square sectioned rods T.
Referring to FIG. 4, velocity limiter V at surface V1 abuts the end of the planar control rod surface S1. Welding conventionally occurs at and around the interface between planar surface S1 and velocity limiter surface V1. This weld effects the mechanical attachment of the velocity limiter at plate V1 to the control rod planar surface S1. However, this same weld has a secondary effect. Specifically, the weld forms a secondary or tertiary seal about the plugs P at the lower end of the joined control rods T. Thus the design here shown provides enhanced sealing.
Referring to FIG. 8, construction of the handle H can now be set forth. The upper end of handle H at 71 is conventional and typically comprises a continuous plate of stainless steel having a conventionally mounted control rod guide 72 for rolling over the surfaces of the respective fuel channels 14.
Between the respective ends of the control rod S1 and plate 71 on handle H, a rectangular sectioned tube 80 is placed. This tube defines in the interior a rectangular volume having a complementary rectangular hafnium plate 82.
Plate 82 can be made of any longitudinal length desired. For example, in control cell locations plate 82 is usually relatively long in the range of six inches.
In conventional control rod locations, plate 82 and tube 80 are relatively short in the range of three inches; the plate is given a length only sufficient to withstand the higher neutron fluence at the reactor exposed end of the normally withdrawn control rod.
It will be appreciated that the rectangular sectioned tube 80 is continuously welded around planner control rod surface S1. Likewise, the upper end of the rectangular tube 80 is continuously welded to handle plate 71. These respective continuous welds provide not only containment to the hafnium plate 82 but additionally serve as a secondary seal to the respective ends of the tubes T forming the planar control rod member S.
It has been found that higher volumes of neutron absorbing material can be placed within the disclosed apparatus. Control rods of an increased worth in the range exceeding 10% can be produced.
Further, the disclosed control rods because of their defined central cylindrical volume and the fact that they are tubular extruded provide ideal resistance to known control rod failure phenomenon.
It will be appreciated that the standard tube making techniques can be used for fabricating the disclosed tubes. Consequently, the defined cylindrical volume 40 need not be fabricated by drilling or other factors.
Further, automated welding can include laser welding, electron beam welding, and plazma arc welding technologies ideally suited for joining the disclosed tube sections.
It will be understood that the increased volume of neutron absorbing material provides improved self shielding. Simply stated, neutron absorbing materials, such as boron carbide, tend to absorb neutrons on their outermost cylindrical areas. Depletion of the neutron absorbing characteristics occurs with successive cylindrical layers absorbing and thereafter being expended in the absorption process. By providing a cylinder of larger diameter, control rod worth is maintained for a longer in service time. Specifically, the surface area present for neutron absorption decreases more slowly with the higher cylindrical volumes of poison or neutron absorbing material.
It will, therefore, be understood that the square tube of this invention contains a unique serendipity which cooperates in the control rod environment. This serendipity includes the composite tubular make up and the ability to construct and fasten the square cross section tubes in side-by-side relation.
Claims
What is claimed is:
1. A process for forming an elongate flat planar member comprising a portion of a nuclear reactor control rod for insertion within the core of a nuclear reactor for control of the reaction, said process comprising the steps of: providing a plurality of tubes defining cylindrical volumes and having square cross section, each said tube defining a cylinder of constant side wall thickness sufficient for defining therewithin the cylindrical volume for the containment of neutron absorbing poisons; providing on each said tube of said plurality of tubes four discrete right angle corner sections integrally formed to said constant side wall thickness cylinder having a placement on the outside of said cylinder at 90.degree. intervals to the side walls of said constant side wall thickness tube, said four corner sections defining four volumes of increased thickness in said tube wall with four areas of constant thickness of said tube wall defined therebetween; fastening said tubes in juxtaposed side-by-side relation with the two discrete right angle corner sections of one tube adjoining two discrete right angle corner sections of an adjacent tube; joining said tubes at said corner sections in side-by-side juxtaposed relation to form said elongate planar member of said control rod; placing neutron absorbing poisons confined within each said tube for absorption of neutrons for control of said nuclear reaction; and plugging said tubes at the respective ends of said tubes to confine said neutron absorbing materials within said tubes.
2. A process for forming an elongate flat planar member as recited in claim 1, wherein said placing and plugging steps are performed after said fastening step.
3. The process of claim 1 and including the additional steps of: joining said plugged tubes to respective end members of said control rod around the periphery of said plugged tubes whereby said joinder forms a secondary seal to said control rods.
4. The process of claim 1 and wherein said fastening step includes fastening by welding.
5. The process of claim 3 and wherein said joining step at one end of said plugged tubes constitutes providing a rectangular sectioned tube complementary in section to the section of said plugged tubes at said one end; placing neutron absorbing material in said rectangular sectioned tube; fastening one end of said rectangular sectioned tube to said plugged tubes; and, fastening the other end of said rectangular sectioned tube to a control rod handle to capture said neutron absorbing material in said tube whereby said fastening steps provide a secondary seal to said plugs in said square sectioned tubular members.
Patent Citations (5)
| Patent | Date | Inventor | Cited By |
|---|---|---|---|
| US2998640 | 1961-09-01 | Huet | |
| US3407117 | 1968-10-01 | Lichtenberger | |
| US3485717 | 1969-12-01 | Eich | |
| US3585709 | 1971-06-01 | Muller et al. | |
| US3712852 | 1973-01-01 | Fisher |
Non-Patent Literature (2)
- FIGS. 2-6a. Control Rod Assembly 2-73/2-74/1 pg.
- Applications of Hafnium/ASEA-ATOM/2 pgs., Jan. 1987.