Background of the Invention
At present isophorone diisocyanate, IPDI, is the commonly used isocyanate curative for hydroxyterminated polymers used in the rocket propellant industry. An alternate curing agent that has the desirable properties of IPDI has been sought because IPDI is foreign made. IPDI cannot at this time be produced in this country because of international patent rights and environmental constraints; therefore; in case of national crisis, it might become unavailable.
As noted hereinabove, isophorone diisocyanate, IPDI, has environmental constraints against being produced in this country since it is made by a phosgenation process. Although the current supply at the price from the foreign source, (e.g., of about $3.00 per pound), is a preferred price to that which could be met, if it could be produced in this country, with all things considered, it is prudent in case of national crisis to not be restricted to a foreign source which might become unavailable.
An alternate curing agent meta-tetramethylxylene diisocyanate (m-TMXDI) would offer advantages which the presently used IPDI could not meet in this country. The domestically produced m-TMXDI is made by a non-phosgenation process developed by American Cyanamid Company's research laboratories. The applications of m-TMXDI and p-TMXDI in reaction injection molding (RIM) permits the manufacture of urethane parts which require no post-painting. The isomers of either TMXDI which are naturally white (or can be pigmented any desired color) are light stable; and if scratched or damaged in use, they retain their integral color. The introduction of a new family of aliphatic diisocyanates to the polyurethane industry provides the products which motivates further research in another industry, i.e., the propulsion industry, to meet a current need.
Composite rocket propellants that are cured and crosslinked with a domestically produced acceptable substitute for IPDI is presently needed. An acceptable substitute for crosslinking hydroxyterminated polymers of polybutadiene binders employed in composite rocket propellants would be highly desirable if, additionally, improved propellant properties are derived from its use.
Summary of the Invention
Meta-tetramethylxylene diisocyanate, (m-TMXDI), is employed as a curing agent (crosslinker) for hydroxyterminated polymers used in the production of composite rocket propellants. The curing agent, m-TMXDI, is employed in an amount from about 0.5 to about 2.0 weight percent of a composite propellant composition which comprises in weight percents of other ingredients of a high solids loading of aluminum metal fuel (0-20%) and ammonium perchlorate oxidizer (65-88%), hydroxy-terminated polymer binder (7-15%) with antioxidant (0.15 to 1.0% of polymer), plasticizer (0-4%), burn rate catalyst (.0.05-6.0%), and quick cure catalyst system of about 0.02% maleic acid (MA) or maleic anhydride (MAN) or oxalic acid and 0.02% triphenyl bismuthine (TPB). The evaluation of m-TMXDI in a propellant composition included comparing its effectiveness with the proven diisocyanate curing agent, isophorone diisocyanate (IPDI) which is foreign produced using a phosgenation process that has environmental constraints in this country. TMXDI, which is made by a non-phosgenation process in this country, shows lower propellant viscosities during processing, longer pot life, and less sensitivity to temperature change than the IPDI cured propellant.
Brief Description of the Drawing
FIG. 1 compares pot life hours at 56.degree. C. and effect of increased temperatures on pot life for TMXDI cured propellant and IPDI (prior art) cured propellant.
FIGS. 2 and 3 depict cure profiles for (prior art) IPDI propellants with TPB and TPB plus MA respectively.
FIG. 4 depicts cure profile for TMXDI propellant with TPB.
FIG. 5 depicts cure profile for TMXDI propellant with TPB plus MAN.
FIG. 6 depicts cure profile for TMXDI propellant with TPB plus MA.
Description of the Preferred Embodiment
Composite rocket propellant compositions containing hydroxy-terminated polymers are cured with m-tetramethylxylene diisocyanate (m-TMXDI). These propellant compositions contain about 88 weight percent solids composed of ammonium perchlorate and aluminum; thus, processing conditions, mechanical properties, and pot life are elements of high consideration and importance in the solid propellant industry. The curing agent, m-TMXDI, in a range from about 0.5 to 2.0 weight percent, is employed in a composite propellant composition comprising a high solids loading of aluminum metal fuel (0-20%) and ammonium perchlorate oxidizer (65-88%), hydroxyterminated polymer binder (7-15%) with antioxidant (0.15 to 1.0% of polymer), plasticizer (0-4%), burn rate catalyst (0.05-6.0%), and quick cure catalyst system of about 0.02% maleic acid (MA) or maleic anhydride (MAN) or oxalic acid and 0.02% triphenyl bismuthine (TPB).
Prior to teaching the use of m-TMXDI and disclosing the data obtained from its use as a curing agent for high solids loaded composite propellants, the physical properties and structural formula is of interest. The paper titled: "m- and p-TMXDI: Two New Isocyanates For the Polyurethane Industry" by Volker D. Arendt, Raymond E. Logan, and Robert Saxon, which was presented at the Society of the Plastics Industry, Inc. (SPI) Fall Conference, Oct. 20-22, 1982, discloses the physical properties and identities for m-TMXDI and p-TMXDI as follows:
The structural formula of m- and p-TMXDI (meta and para Tetramethyl Xylene Diisocyanate) are disclosed as follows: ##STR1##
Since IPDI is the commonly used isocyanate curative for hydroxy-terminated polymers used in the rocket propellant industry, compositions for control purposes employed IPDI, and the experimental composition in a like formulation except m-TMXDI is employed as the curative. A first requirement for a solid propellant composition is the processing parameters relating to viscosity and fluidity. The meta compound and the para compounds of TMXDI are structural isomers having the same molecular weights and same isocyanate (NCO) contents; however, the meta compound is liquid at room temperature while the para compound is a solid, melting at 72.degree. C. Thus, the m-TMXDI is the preferred isomer where a lower processing viscosity is required. Table I below compares end of mix viscosity data for composite propellant mixes, Control and Experimental, identified therein.
Table II set forth the mechanical properties of an IPDI AND a m-TMXDI cured propellant composition at -40.degree. C., 25.degree. C., and 60.degree. C. Each propellant used 0.02% TPB alone as a cure catalyst.
Table III sets forth the mechanical properties of an IPDI and a m-TMXDI cured propellant composition at -40.degree. C., 25.degree. C., 60.degree. C. which also contains 0.02% each TPB and MA.
Table IV Sets forth the mechanical properties of a IPDI and a m-TMXDI cured propellant composition at 25.degree. C. which also contains 0.02% each TPB and MAN.
Table V sets forth the mechanical properties of various size batches of IPDI and m-TMXDI cured propellant compositions measured at -40.degree. C., 25.degree. C., and 60.degree. C. wherein amounts of IPDI and m-TMXDI are 0.67%, 0.77% and 0.78%, respectively.
Table VI sets forth pot life of IPDI and a m-TMXDI cured propellant compositions which contained TPB, MA and MAN as a catalyst for quick curing formulation containing about 0.77 weight percent m-TMXDI.
Table VII sets forth pot life comparison between a IPDI and a m-TMXDI cured propellant composition with burning rate catalysts of Fe.sub.2 O.sub.3 and Catocene (2,2-bis(ethylferrocenyl)propane).
In further reference to the Figures of the drawing, FIG. 1 depicts Curves A, B, and C to show the effect of temperature increases on decreasing pot life for m-TMXDI cured propellant with 0.02 maleic acid, m-TMXDI cured propellant without maleic acid, and IPDI cured (prior art) propellant with 0.02% maleic acid respectively.
FIG. 2 depicts a cue profile for IPDI cured (prior art) control propellant containing TPB wherein Curve A is stress and Curve B is modulus.
FIG. 3 depicts a cure profile for IPDI cured (prior art) control propellant containing TPB and MAN wherein Curve C is stress and Curve D is modulus.
FIG. 4 depicts a cure profile for m-TMXDI cured (experimental) propellant containing TPB wherein Curve E is stress and Curve F is modulus.
FIG. 5 depicts a cure profile for m-TMXDI cured (experimental) propellant containing TPB and MAN wherein Curve G is stress and Curve H is modulus.
FIG. 6 depicts a cure profile for m-TMXDI Cured (experimental) propellant containing TPB and MA wherein Curve I is stress and Curve J is modulus.
In conclusion, it is noted that in all cases mechanical properties are comparable for IPDI and m-TMXDI cured propellant. For examples, Table II shows mechanical data of IPDI AND m-TMXDI wherein 0.02% TPB is used as cure catalyst. Tables III and IV compare mechanical properties of IPDI and m-TMXDI propellants using 0.02% each TPB and MA, and 0.02% each TPB and MAN as cure catalyst, respectively. Table V shows mechanical properties of propellant from both gallon and pint mixes containing 0.025% each TPB and MAN. Thus, m-TMXDI meets the comparability tests for acceptability with IPDI since the stress, strain, and modulus are within desirable ranges for a composite solid propellant composition at the specified temperatures of measurement.
In the other areas of comparabilities for m-TMXDI with IPDI, m-TMXDI prevails in pot life, cure time equal or shorter, and pot life of high rate propellants containing cure catalyzing ingredients can be significantly extended by using m-TMXDI as the curing agent.
The above statement of conclusion for pot life has substantiating data in Table VI for increases in pot life with m-TMXDI ranging from 28% to 60% as compared with IPDI using same cure catalyst.
Pot life of m-TMXDI cured propellant is less sensitive to temperature change than IPDI cured propellant. See FIG. 1 for graphic illustration for m-TMXDI with and without 0.02% MA.
Table VII shows that substantially longer pot life can be obtained with m-TMXDI when cured catalyzing burning rate catalysts (e.g. Fe.sub.2 O.sub.3 or Catocene) are present in the propellant.
In FIGS. 2 and 3, curing profiles are presented for IPDI with TPB and TPB and MAN respectively which represent control propellant or prior art. The improvements which are evident by uniform cure profiles for m-TMXDI with TPB alone, with m-TMXDI with TPB and MAN, and with m-TMXDI with TPB and MA are depicted in FIGS. 3, 4, and 5 respectively.
Cost comparisons based on total cost of propellant per pound using foreign country produced IPDI versus the cost of propellant per pound using domestically produced m-TMXDI indicate a price increase of only 0.3.cent. (i.e, $0.003) per pound for the m-TMXDI cured propellant. Thus a propellant grain weighing a hundred pounds would cost only $0.30 more for the m-TMXDI cured propellant composition. The advantages of being able to use a domestically and commercially produced stock item (i.e., one which is used in quantity in polyurethane and reaction injection molding art) but has a specialized use as a curative for a propellant binder is readily recognized by an artisan in the propulsion industry and a procurement and a cost analyst as well.
The antioxidant class of compounds are added to rubber materials such as hydroxyterminated polymers to retard oxidation. Typical rubber antioxidants are commonly of an aromatic amine type, such as di-beta-naphthyl-para-phenylenediamine and phenyl-beta-naphthylamine. Other antioxidants are substituted phenolic compounds such as butylated hydroxyanisole, di-ter-butyl-para-cresol, and propyl gallate.
Burn rate catalysts can be selected from carboranes, ferrocenses, iron oxide, or combinations which contains the catalyst ingredient as part of the polymeric material, thereby preventing catalyst migration.
The adjustments of propellant ingredients by percent of the propellant formulation are made to obtain the desired properties of the finished propellant grain. For example, if the burn rate catalyst also functions as a binder the amount of the binder can be reduced. The use of plasticizers may also be considered for certain formulations of high solids content. Decreased pot life due to ionic metal catalysis such as induced by iron oxide or chelated metal compounds, can be offset by use of m-TMXDI as described hereinabove. In any event, the total propellant ingredients are adjusted to total 100 percent as determined by the above criteria and to meet the desired propellant mechanical properties, end of mix viscosities, and burning rates or chemical properties desired.