US 4,889,600 AGrant
Fractionating Column Control Apparatus and Methods
Issue Date:1989-12-26
•5 Claims
•2 Drawing Sheets
Abstract
Apparatus and methods for determining the Reid Vapor Pressure of a bottoms product stream of a fractionating column used for fractionating a multi-component hydrocarbon feed stream into an overhead product stream and a bottoms product stream are provided. The Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product stream is determined in response to the temperature of the bottoms product stream, the vapor pressure of the bottoms product stream, the rate of flow of the bottoms product stream and the rate of flow of the overhead product stream, without an analysis of the particular product stream. The Reid Vapor Pressure indication is used to maintain the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product system substantially equal to the desired Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product stream and to thereby control the quality of the bottoms and other product streams.
Metadata
Assignee
- Conoco Inc.
Inventors
- Patricia A. Meier
- W. Jeff Meier
- Brent J. Woodland
Application Information
Application Number:US 1557874
Filing Date:1988-02-16
Priority Date:1988-02-16
Art Unit:133
Classifications
IPC:
B01D 314B01D 342
Field of Search:
203202731962083642;3;DIG. 18160;20664.2132;141DIG. 1501
Patent Drawings (2 sheets)
Description
Background of the Invention
1. Field of the Invention
The present invention relates generally to hydrocarbon fractionation apparatus and methods. In one aspect, the invention relates to apparatus and methods for determining the Reid Vapor Pressure of one or more product streams of a fractionating column. In another aspect, the present invention relates to apparatus and methods for controlling the Reid Vapor Pressure and quality of one or more product streams of a fractionating column.
2. Description of the Prior Art
Fractionation processes wherein a multi-component hydrocarbon stream is heated and fractionated into a bottoms product stream and one or more sidedraw or overhead product streams are commonly employed in refining and other similar applications. In carrying out such processes, it is important to maintain product quality while operating as efficiently as possible.
The Reid Vapor Pressure of a particular product stream is the equilibrium vapor pressure of the stream at 100.degree. F. (37.8.degree. C.). The Reid Vapor Pressure of a product stream is directly related to the composition of the stream. For example, the Reid Vapor Pressure of a bottoms product stream is a function of the concentration of the components therein. As a result, the Reid Vapor Pressure of a particular product stream can serve as an indication of the product quality of the stream.
Changes in certain process variables associated with a fractionating column such as the fee stream flow rate, the feed stream composition, and the amount of heat provided to the column directly affect the quality and Reid Vapor Pressure of the product streams. The quality of a product stream can be controlled by detecting changes in the Reid Vapor Pressure of the stream and manipulating one or more process variables in response to the changes detected to maintain the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of the stream substantially equal to the Reid Vapor Pressure of the stream that corresponds to the quality of the stream desired.
In the past, an accurate determination of the Reid Vapor Pressure of a particular product stream typically required a complex analysis such as a chromatographic analysis of the stream. In a continuous fractionation process, it is difficult to perform such an analysis on a continuous or frequent basis. Even where it is possible to place a chromatographic or other type of analyzer on-stream, the cost and maintenance difficulties associated therewith often make it undesirable to do so.
In order to alleviate the problem, apparatus and methods have been developed for determining the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of a product stream in the absence of a chromatographic or other type of complex analysis thereof. In U.S. Pat. Nos. 4,578,151 and 4,667,508, apparatus and methods for determining the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of a mixture of hydrocarbons in response to the actual temperature and vapor pressure of the mixture are disclosed. Vapor pressure charts are used with the temperature and vapor pressure readings to make the determination.
Although apparatus and methods for determining the Reid Vapor Pressure of a product stream in response to the temperature and vapor pressure of the stream are a solution to the problem, they do not provide an accurate Reid Vapor Pressure indication in all applications. Such apparatus and methods do not provide an accurate indication of the Reid Vapor Pressure of a product stream when the Reid Vapor Pressure of the stream varies over a wide range as the fractionation process is carried out.
Thus, there is a need for improved apparatus and methods for determining the Reid Vapor Pressure of a product stream in the absence of a chromatographic or other complex analysis thereof. There is a need for such apparatus and methods that can provide an accurate indication of the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of a product stream even when the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of the stream varies over a wide range as the fractionation process is carried out.
Summary of the Invention
The present invention provides apparatus and methods for determining the Reid Vapor Pressure of a first product stream of a fractionating column used for fractionating a multi-component hydrocarbon feed stream into an overhead product stream and a bottoms product stream. The apparatus comprises means for establishing a first signal representative of the actual temperature of the first product stream, means for establishing a second signal representative of the actual vapor pressure of the first product stream, means for establishing a third signal representative of the actual rate of flow of the bottoms product stream, means for establishing a fourth signal representative of the actual rate of flow of the overhead product stream, and means for determining the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of the first product stream in response to the first, second, third and fourth signals.
Also provided are apparatus and methods for controlling the Reid Vapor Pressure and quality of a first product stream of a fractionating column used for fractionating a multi-component hydrocarbon feed stream into an overhead product stream and a bottoms product stream. The apparatus comprises means for establishing a first signal representative of the actual temperature of the first product stream, means for establishing a second signal representative of the actual vapor pressure of the first product stream, means for establishing a third signal representative of the actual rate of flow of the bottoms product stream, means for establishing a fourth signal representative of the actual rate of flow of the overhead product stream, means for establishing a fifth signal representative of the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of the first product stream in response to the first, second, third and fourth signals, means for establishing a sixth signal representative of the desired Reid Vapor Pressure of the first product stream, means for comparing the fifth signal and the sixth signal and for establishing a seventh signal responsive to the difference between the fifth signal and the sixth signal, and means responsive to the seventh signal for varying the rate at which heat is provided to the fractionating column to maintain the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of the first product stream substantially equal to the desired Reid Vapor Pressure of the first product stream.
In a preferred embodiment, the seventh signal is scaled so as to be representative of the temperature of the first product stream required to maintain the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of the first product stream substantially equal to the desired Reid Vapor Pressure thereof. In this embodiment, the means for varying the rate at which heat is provided to the fractionating column to maintain the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of the first product stream substantially equal to the desired Reid Vapor Pressure thereof comprises means for comparing the seventh signal and the first signal and for establishing an eighth signal responsive to the difference between the seventh signal and the first signal and means responsive to the eighth signal for varying the rate at which heat is provided to the fractionating column.
Preferably, the first product stream is the bottoms product stream. The actual Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product stream is determined and the fifth signal representative of the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product stream is established in response to the first, second, third and fourth signals based on the following relationship:
wherein:
X equals the temperature of the bottoms product stream as represented by the first signal;
Y equals the vapor pressure of the bottoms product stream as represented by the second signal;
Z equals the rate of flow of the overhead product stream as represented by the fourth signal divided by the rate of flow of the bottoms product stream as represented by the third signal; and
A, B, C, D, and E equal fitted constants.
From the foregoing description of the present invention, it will be apparent that an important object of the invention is to provide hydrocarbon fractionation apparatus and methods whereby improved control of the Reid Vapor Pressure and quality of one or more product streams is achieved.
A further object of the present invention is to provide improved methods and apparatus for determining the Reid Vapor Pressure of a product stream of a fractionating column in the absence of a chromatographic or other complex analysis thereof.
A further object is to provide improved methods and apparatus for controlling the Reid Vapor Pressure and quality of a product stream whereby an accurate indication of the Reid Vapor Pressure of the stream is provided even when the Reid Vapor Pressure of the stream varies substantially as the process is carried out.
Numerous other objects, features and advantages of the present invention will be readily apparent to those skilled in the art upon a reading of the following disclosure when taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.
Brief Description of the Drawings
FIG. 1 is a schematic diagram of a fractional distillation process including the fractionating column control apparatus of the present invention.
FIG. 2 is a graph showing the results of a test of the fractionating column control apparatus and methods of the present invention.
FIG. 3 is a graph showing the results shown in FIG. 2 in a different way.
Detailed Description of the Preferred Embodiments
The present invention provides apparatus and methods for determining the Reid Vapor Pressure of a first product stream of a fractionating column used for fractionating a multi-component hydrocarbon feed stream into an overhead product stream and a bottoms product stream. First, second, third and fourth signals representative of the actual temperature of the first product stream, the actual vapor pressure of the first product stream, the actual rate of flow of the bottoms product stream, and the actual rate of flow of the overhead product stream, respectively, are established, and the Reid Vapor Pressure of the first product stream is determined in response thereto. The Reid Vapor Pressure indication can then be used to control one or more aspects of the fractionation process.
The present invention also provides apparatus and methods for controlling the Reid Vapor Pressure and quality of a first product stream of a fractionating column used for fractionating a multi-component hydrocarbon feed stream into an overhead product stream and a bottoms product stream. First, second, third and fourth signals representative of the actual temperature of the first product stream, the actual vapor pressure of the first product stream, the actual rate of flow of the bottoms product stream and the actual rate of flow of the overhead product stream, respectively, are established. A fifth signal representative of the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of the first product stream is established in response to the first, second, third and fourth signals. A sixth signal representative of the desired Reid Vapor Pressure of the first product stream is established, the fifth signal and the sixth signal are compared and a seventh signal responsive to the difference between the fifth signal and the sixth signal is established. The rate at which heat is provided to the fractionating column is varied in response to the seventh signal to maintain the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of the first product stream substantially equal to the desired Reid Vapor Pressure of the first product stream.
Preferably, the seventh signal is scaled so as to be representative of the temperature of the first product stream required to maintain the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of the first product stream substantially equal to the desired Reid Vapor Pressure thereof. The rate at which heat is provided to the fractionating column in response to the seventh signal to maintain the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of the first product stream substantially equal to the desired Reid Vapor Pressure thereof is varied by comparing the scaled seventh signal and the first signal, by establishing an eighth signal responsive to the difference between the scaled seventh signal and the first signal and by varying the rate at which heat is provided to the fractionating column in response to the eighth signal.
The Reid Vapor Pressure of the first product stream is determined and the fifth signal representative thereof is established in response to the first, second, third and fourth signals without an analysis of the stream. Thus, a chromatographic or other complex analysis of the stream is not required. As used herein and in the appended claims, an analysis of a stream means a chromatographic analysis of the stream or other analysis of the stream to determine the nature of the component(s) forming the stream and/or one or more properties such as the molecular weight or specific gravity thereof. An analysis of a stream does not mean a measurement of a condition of the stream such as a measurement of the temperature, pressure and/or rate of flow of the stream.
The first product stream can be any product stream of the fractionating column, including the bottoms product stream, the overhead product stream or a sidedraw product stream. Preferably, the first product stream is the bottoms product stream. Accurate control of most fractionation processes is best achieved by controlling the Reid Vapor Pressure and quality of the bottoms product stream.
Preferably, the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product stream is determined and the fifth signal representative of the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product stream is established in response to the first, second, third and fourth signals based on the relationship shown by Equation One below:
wherein:
X equals the temperature of the bottoms product stream as represented by the first signal;
Y equals the vapor pressure of the bottoms product stream as represented by the second signal;
Z equals the rate of flow of the overhead product stream as represented by the fourth signal divided by the rate of flow of the bottoms product stream as represented by the third signal; and
A, B, C, D, and E equal fitted constants. The constants A, B, C, D and E usually vary depending upon the composition of the hydrocarbon feed stream and the nature of the fractionation process. They can be derived by empirical methods. For example, the constants can be derived by a multiple regression analysis of data collected on the temperature, vapor pressure and rate of flow of the bottoms product stream and the rate of flow of the overhead product stream as the fractionation process is carried out and data collected on the corresponding Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product stream as determined by analysis in the laboratory. The constants can also be derived by a multiple regression analysis of data collected from a thermodynamic model of the fractionating column.
The relationship shown by Equation One above can be modified to account for other process variables. For example, if sidedraw product streams are withdrawn from the fractionating column, it may be desirable to add variables for the rates of flow of such streams and additional fitted constants to the equation.
The signals referred to herein and in the claims appendant hereto as representative of measured process parameters, desired process parameters or determined values bear a direct relationship to the measured parameters, desired parameters or determined values they represent. The specific measured or desired parameters or determined values can be readily retrieved from the signals representative thereof regardless of the exact relationship therebetween.
Although the present invention applies to all types of hydrocarbon fractionation processes, it is particularly applicable to fractional distillation processes. It is not limited to any specific means for using the temperature and pressure of a first product stream and the flow rates of the overhead and bottoms product streams to determine the Reid Vapor Pressure of the first product stream or to any specific means for using the determined Reid Vapor Pressure of the first product stream to control the Reid Vapor Pressure and quality of the first product stream. A fractional distillation process and means for using process parameters to determine the Reid Vapor Pressure of a product stream and for using the Reid Vapor Pressure indication to control the Reid Vapor Pressure of the distillation product are generally described in U.S. Pat. Nos. 4,578,151 and 4,667,508, which are incorporated by reference herein.
Referring now to FIG. 1 of the drawings, preferred apparatus and methods for determining the Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product streams of a fractionating column and for controlling the Reid Vapor Pressure and quality of the bottoms product streams of a fractionating column will be described.
A fractional distillation column 12 is used to fractionate a multi-component hydrocarbon stream into an overhead product stream and a bottoms product stream. The multi-component hydrocarbon stream is formed from a mixture of hydrocarbons and fed into the fractional distillation column 12 through conduit means 14. Any means for forming the mixture of hydrocarbons into the multi-component hydrocarbon stream and supplying the stream to the conduit means 14 can be used.
The overhead product stream is withdrawn from the fractional distillation column 12 through conduit means 16 and is conducted to a heat exchanger 18. Heat is exchanged between the overhead product stream and a cooling medium provided to the heat exchanger 18 through conduit means 20. The condensed overhead product stream is then conducted to an accumulator 22 through conduit means 24 and conduit means 26. If desired, vapor can be drawn off through conduit means 28. Liquid in the accumulator 22 is withdrawn from the accumulator and provided as a reflux to the fractional distillation column 12 through conduit means 30 and conduit means 32. The overhead product stream is conducted through conduit means 30 and conduit means 34.
The bottoms product stream is withdrawn from the fractional distillation column 12 through conduit means 38 and conduit means 39. Although any means for providing heat to the fractional distillation column 12 can be used, heat is preferably provided to the column by indirect heat exchange therewith. A portion of the bottoms product stream is preferably conducted through conduit means 40 to a heat exchanger 42 and then back to the column 12 through conduit means 48. A hot fluid such as hot oil or steam is provided to the heat exchanger 42 through conduit means 44 and withdrawn from the heat exchanger through conduit means 46. In the heat exchanger 42, heat is exchanged between the hot fluid and the portion of the bottoms product stream circulated therethrough. The rate of flow of hot fluid circulated through the heat exchanger 42 and hence the amount of heat provided to the fractional distillation column 12 are controlled by control means in the form of a control valve 52.
Any means for establishing the first, second, third and fourth signals representative of the temperature and vapor pressure of the bottoms product stream and the flow rates of the overhead and bottoms product streams can be utilized. Sensing and transducing means for measuring process parameters and generating various signals representative thereof exist in a variety of forms and formats. As will be understood by those skilled in the art, the particular means used can vary depending upon the particular fractionating process including the equipment and control instrumentation used therewith, safety factors and the like.
Preferably, a first signal 56 representative of the actual temperature of the bottoms product stream is established by a sensing device 57 located in the fractional distillation column and a temperature transducer 58. As long as the first signal 56 is representative of the actual temperature of the bottoms product stream, the exact locations of the sensing device and temperature transducer 58 are not critical. The equilibrium temperature in the fractional distillation column is usually essentially equal to the temperature of the bottoms product stream. If necessary or desired, the actual temperature of the bottoms product stream can be sensed.
A second signal 60 representative of the actual vapor pressure of the bottoms product stream is established by a sensing device 61 located in the fractional distillation column and a pressure transducer 62. As long as the second signal 60 is representative of the actual vapor pressure of the bottoms product stream, the exact locations of the sensing device and the pressure transducer 62 are not critical. In most fractionation processes, the vapor pressure of the fluid in the fractional distillation column, or even that of the overhead product stream, is essentially equal to the vapor pressure of the bottoms product stream. If necessary or desired, the vapor pressure measurement made can be adjusted or the actual vapor pressure of the bottoms product stream can be sensed.
A third signal 64 representative of the actual rate of flow of, the bottoms product stream is established by a flow sensor 41 located in conduit means 39 and a flow transducer 66. The exact locations of the flow sensor and flow transducer 66 are not critical as long as the third signal 64 is representative of the actual rate of flow of the bottoms product stream. If desired, the flow sensor can be located in other conduit means such as conduit means 38, conduit means 40 or conduit means 48 and the sensed value an be adjusted to be representative of the actual rate of flow of the bottoms product stream.
A fourth signal 68 representative of the actual rate of flow of the overhead product stream is established by a flow sensor 33 located in conduit means 34 and a flow transducer 70. The exact locations of the flow sensor and the flow transducer 70 are not critical as long as the fourth output signal 68 is representative of the actual rate of flow of the overhead product stream. If desired, the flow sensor used to establish the fourth output signal 68 can be located in other conduit means such as conduit means 32, conduit means 30, conduit means 26, conduit means 24 or conduit means 16 and the sensed value can be adjusted to be representative of the actual rate of flow of the overhead product stream.
The output signals 56, 60, 64 and 68 are used to determine the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product stream. Preferably, the signals 56, 60, 64 and 68 are transmitted to and provided as input signals to a computer 110 where the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product stream is determined. The Reid Vapor Pressure is calculated in the "Determine Reid Vapor Pressure block" 112 of the computer 110 based on the relationship described by Equation One above.
The Reid Vapor Pressure indication can be used to control one or more aspects of the fractionation process including the quality of one or more product streams. Various processes can be implemented to achieve whatever control is desired.
Preferably, the Reid Vapor Pressure determined is used to control the quality of one or more product streams by controlling the Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product stream. A fifth output signal 114 representative of the actual Reid Vapor Pressure determined is established by the "Determine Reid Vapor Pressure block" 112 of the computer 110. The fifth signal is provided as a process variable input to a controller block 116. Also provided to the controller block 116 is a sixth signal 118 representative of the desired Reid Vapor Pressure for the bottoms product stream, i.e., the Reid Vapor Pressure corresponding to the quality of the bottoms product stream desired. The sixth signal 118 serves as a set point signal. Although it can be established by any means, it is preferably entered by the operator of the fractionation process.
The controller block 116 compares the fifth signal 114 and the sixth signal 118 and establishes a seventh signal 120 which is responsive to the difference between the fifth signal 114 and the sixth signal 118. The seventh signal is then used to vary the rate at which heat is provided to the fractional distillation column to maintain the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product stream substantially equal to the desired Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product stream.
Any means responsive to the seventh signal 120 for varying the rate at which heat is provided to the fractional distillation column 12 to maintain the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product stream substantially equal to the desired Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product stream can be utilized.
Preferably, the seventh signal 120 is scaled so as to be representative of the temperature of the bottoms product stream required to maintain the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product stream substantially equal to the desired Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product stream. The seventh signal 120 can be scaled by any means. Inasmuch as the scaling of an output signal is well known in the art, a detailed description of the process is not provided herein.
The scaled seventh signal 120 is provided from the controller block 116 as a set point signal to a controller block 130. Also provided to the controller block 130 is the first signal 56, which is representative of the actual temperature of the bottoms product stream. The controller block 130 compares the scaled seventh signal 120 and the first signal 56 and establishes an eighth signal 132 responsive to the difference therebetween. The rate at which heat is provided to the fractional distillation column 12 is varied in response to the eighth signal.
Any means for varying the rate at which heat is provided to the fractional distillation column 12 in response to the eighth signal can be utilized. Preferably, the control valve 52 controlling the rate of flow of heating fluid circulated through the heat exchanger 42 is manipulated in response to the eighth signal 132.
Thus, by the present invention, the Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product stream, the overhead product stream or any other product stream of a fractionating column can be accurately determined based on a single measurement of the temperature and vapor pressure of such stream and the rates of flow of the overhead and bottoms product streams. By continuously sensing the parameters, a continuous indication of the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of the stream is provided. Based on the continuous Reid Vapor Pressure indication, the Reid Vapor Pressure of the stream, and hence the quality of one or more products streams, can be continuously controlled. The amount of heat provided to the fractional distillation column can be automatically adjusted in response to changes in the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of the stream to continuously maintain the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of the stream substantially equal to the desired Reid Vapor Pressure of the stream. The potential of this closed loop, on-stream advanced control is unlimited.
Inasmuch as accurate Reid Vapor Pressure readings are provided without a chromatographic or other complex analysis, the number of product samples sent to the lab is reduced and the efficiency of the process is improved. Maintenance problems associated with on-stream analyzers are eliminated.
By incorporating the relative product ratio into the calculation, the Reid Vapor Pressure determination is corrected for changes in separation taking place in the fractionating column. This allows accurate Reid Vapor Pressure determinations of a product stream to be made even when the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of the stream changes substantially as the fractionation process is carried out.
Apparatus and methods for determining the Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product stream based on the temperature and vapor pressure of the bottoms product stream without taking the rates of flow of the overhead and bottoms product stream into account only provide accurate Reid Vapor Pressure determinations in a confined Reid Vapor Pressure range. By the apparatus and methods of the present invention, the Reid Vapor Pressure can change by as much as 8 pounds per square inch and the Reid Vapor Pressure values provided will still be accurate.
As mentioned above, it is generally desirable in most applications to determine the Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product stream. Nevertheless, the present invention can be utilized to determine the Reid Vapor Pressure of other product streams as well. The present invention is applicable to all separation apparatus and methods whereby a stream of hydrocarbons is separated into a bottoms product stream and one or more sidedraw or overhead product streams.
Any means for sensing the temperature and vapor pressure of the product stream and the rates of flow of the bottoms product stream and overhead product stream can be used. Similarly, any means for using the sensed parameters to determine the Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms or other product stream in the absence of a chromatographic or further analysis thereof may be used. A variety of suitable components can be substituted for the specific components illustrated herein. It may be desirable to perform quality checks on the calculation input variables and controller programming logic to prevent faulty control excursions due to bad input data.
The present invention is useful for all types of separation processes. For the sake of simplicity, the many details surrounding a fractional distillation process have not been described.
In order to illustrate and facilitate a clear understanding of the invention, the following example is given:
Example I
The fractionating column control apparatus and methods of the present invention are tested for accuracy.
The fractional distillation column 12 schematically illustrated in FIG. 1 of the drawings was used to fractionate a multi-component hydrocarbon feed stream into an overhead product stream and a bottoms product stream. The multi-component hydrocarbon feed stream consisted essentially of aliphatic and aromatic hydrocarbons.
Heat was provided to the distillation column 12 by exchanging heat between heavy cycle oil flowing through the heat exchanger 42 and the portion of the bottoms product stream flowing through the heat exchanger and recirculated to the column. The overhead product stream withdrawn from the column 12 consisted essentially of propanes, propenes, butanes, and butenes. The bottoms product stream withdrawn from the column 12 consisted essentially of butanes, butenes, pentanes, isopentene, hexanes, and slightly heavier hydrocarbons of similar nature. As the process was carried out, the Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product stream was continuously determined by the computer 110 based on the following relationship:
wherein:
X equals the temperature of the bottoms product stream;
Y equals the vapor pressure of the bottoms product stream;
Z equals the rate of flow of the overhead products stream divided by the rate of flow of the bottoms product stream; and
A, B, C, D, and E equal fitted constants.
Before full operation of the process began, the constants were empirically fit for the process. First the constants were determined by a multiple regression analysis of data collected from a thermodynamic model of the fractionating column. The constants were then recalculated by a multiple regression analysis of data collected on the temperature, vapor pressure, and rate of flow of the bottoms product stream and the rate of flow of the overhead product stream as the fractionation process was carried out and data collected on the corresponding Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product stream as determined by analysis in the laboratory. The constants were determined to be as follows:
Once the constants were fit for the process, full operation of the process began. A set point corresponding to the desired Reid Vapor Pressure was entered into the computer 110 by the process operator. The computer 110 continuously determined the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product stream as the process was carried out. The actual Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product stream was recorded by the computer 110 every 60 seconds.
The computer 110 continuously compared the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product stream to the operator entered set point corresponding to the desired Reid Vapor Pressure thereof and continuously provided a signal which was used to vary the rate of flow of heavy cycle oil through the heat exchanger 42 to maintain the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product stream substantially equal to the desired Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product stream. In this way, the Reid Vapor Pressure and hence the quality of the bottoms product stream was controlled.
In order to determine the accuracy of the process, the Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product stream as determined by the computer 110 was compared from time to time to the Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product stream as determined by a laboratory analysis. Samples of the bottoms product stream were taken and analyzed in the lab approximately four times a day throughout a forty-three day test period. In the lab, the Reid Vapor Pressure of the samples was determined by an automatic Reid Vapor Pressure analyzer. The Reid Vapor Pressure values recorded by the computer 110 at times corresponding to the times the samples were taken were collected. The Reid Vapor Pressure of each sample was then compared to the Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product stream determined by the computer 110 at the time the sample was taken.
The results of the comparison are plotted in the graphs shown in FIGS. 2 and 3 of the drawings. In the graph shown in FIG. 2, the Reid Vapor Pressure of each sample as determined in the lab is directly compared to the Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product stream as determined by the computer 110 at the time the sample was taken. In the graph shown in FIG. 3, the Reid Vapor Pressure of each sample as determined in the lab is plotted against the Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product stream as determined by the computer 110 at the time the sample was taken.
As shown by the results, the Reid Vapor Pressures calculated by the computer 110 trended very well with the Reid Vapor Pressures determined in the lab. The Reid Vapor Pressure indications provided by the computer remained accurate even though the Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product stream fluctuated between around 6 psi and around 14 psi. The calculated data yielded a standard deviation of .+-.0.34 psi from the lab data over the full Reid Vapor Pressure range.
Thus, the fractionating column control apparatus and methods of the present invention provide a very accurate continuous indication of the Reid Vapor Pressure of the bottoms product stream of a fractional distillation column, even when the Reid Vapor Pressure varies over a wide range.
From the above, it can be seen that the fractionating control apparatus and methods of the present invention can be utilized to control the quality of one or more product streams of a fractionating column. The apparatus and methods of the present invention readily achieve the ends and advantages mentioned as well as those inherent therein. While certain preferred embodiments of the apparatus and methods have been illustrated and described for the purposes of the present disclosure, numerous changes in the arrangement of parts and exact manner of performance of the various steps may be made by those skilled in the art, which changes are encompassed within the scope and spirit of the invention as defined by the appendant claims.
Claims
The embodiments of the invention to which an exclusive property or privilege is claimed are as follows:
1. Apparatus for separating a mixture of hydrocarbons into discrete products, comprising: a fractionating column; means for providing heat to said fractionating column; means for feeding a stream of said mixture of hydrocarbons to said fractionating column whereby said stream is fractionated into an overhead product stream and a bottoms product stream; and means for controlling the Reid vapor pressure of said bottoms product stream, including: means for establishing a first signal representative of the actual temperature of said bottoms product stream; means for establishing a second signal representative of the actual vapor pressure of said bottoms product stream; means for establishing a third signal representative of the actual rate of flow of said bottoms product stream; means for establishing a fourth signal representative of the actual rate of flow of said overhead product stream; means for establishing a fifth signal representative of the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of said bottoms product stream in response to said first, second, third and fourth signals without an analysis of said bottoms product stream; means for establishing a sixth signal representative of the desired Reid Vapor Pressure of said bottoms product stream; means for comparing said fifth signal and said sixth signal and for establishing a seventh signal responsive to the difference between said fifth signal and said sixth signal; and means responsive to said seventh signal for varying the rate at which heat is provided to said fractionating column to maintain said actual Reid Vapor Pressure of said bottoms product stream.
2. The apparatus of claim 1 wherein said seventh signal is scaled so as to be representative of the temperature of said bottoms product stream required to maintain said actual Reid Vapor Pressure of said bottoms product stream substantially equal to said desired Reid Vapor Pressure thereof and said means responsive to said seventh signal for varying the rate at which heat is provided to said fractionating column to maintain said actual Reid Vapor Pressure of said bottoms product stream substantially equal to said desired Reid Vapor Pressure thereof comprises: means for comparing said seventh signal and said first signal and for establishing an eighth signal responsive to the difference between said seventh signal and said first signal; and means responsive to said eighth signal for varying the rate at which heat is provided to said fractionating column.
3. A method for determining the Reid Vapor Pressure of a bottoms product stream of a fractionating column used for fractionating a multi-component hydrocarbon feed stream into an overhead product stream and a bottoms product stream, comprising: establishing a first signal representative of the temperature of said bottoms product stream; establishing a second signal representative of the vapor pressure of said bottoms product stream; establishing a third signal representative of the rate of flow of said bottoms product stream; establishing a fourth signal representative of the rate of flow of said overhead product stream; determining said Reid Vapor Pressure of said bottoms product stream in response to said first, second, third and fourth signals without an analysis of said bottoms product stream; wherein said step of determining said Reid Vapor Pressure of said bottoms product stream in response to said first, second, third and fourth signals without an analysis of said bottoms product stream comprises the step of determining said Reid Vapor Pressure of said bottoms product stream in response to said first, second, third and fourth signals without an analysis of said bottom product stream based on the following relationship; wherein: X equals the temperature of said bottoms product stream as represented by said first signal; Y equals the vapor pressure of said bottoms product stream as represented by said second signal; Z equals the rate of flow of said overhead product stream as represented by said fourth signal divided by the rate of flow of said bottoms product stream as represented by said third signal; and A, B, C, D, and E equal fitted constants.
4. A method of controlling the Reid Vapor Pressure of a bottoms product stream of a fractionating column used for fractionating a multi-component hydrocarbon feed stream into an overhead product stream and a bottoms product stream wherein heat is provided to said column, said method comprising: establishing a second signal representative of the vapor pressure of said bottoms product stream; establishing a third signal representative of the rate of flow of said bottoms product stream; establishing a fourth signal representative of the rate of flow of said overhead product stream; establishing a fifth signal representative of the actual Reid vapor Pressure of said bottoms product stream in response to said first, second, third and fourth signals without an analysis of said bottoms product stream; establishing a sixth signal representative of the desired Reid vapor Pressure of said bottoms product stream; comparing said fifth signal and said sixth signal and establishing a seventh signal responsive to the difference between said fifth signal and said sixth signal; varying the rate at which heat is provided to said fractionating column in response to said seventh signal to maintain the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of said bottoms product stream substantially equal to the desired Reid Vapor Pressure of said bottoms product stream: wherein said fifth signal representative of the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of said bottoms product stream is established in response to said first, second, third, and fourth signals without an analysis of said bottoms product stream based on the following relationship: wherein: X equals the temperature of said bottoms product stream as represented by said first signal; Y equals the vapor pressure of said bottoms product stream as represented by said second signal; Z equals the rate of flow of said overhead product stream as represented by said fourth signal divided by said rate of flow of said bottoms product stream as represented by said third signal; and A, B, C, D, and E equal fitted constants.
5. The method of claim 4 wherein said seventh signal is scaled so as to be representative of the temperature of said bottoms product stream required to maintain said actual Reid Vapor Pressure of said bottoms product stream substantially equal to said desired Reid Vapor Pressure thereof and said step of varying the rate at which heat is provided to said fractionating column is response to said seventh signal to maintain the actual Reid Vapor Pressure of said bottoms product stream substantially equal to the desired Reid Vapor Pressure thereof comprises the steps of comparing said seventh signal and said first signal, establishing an eighth signal responsive to the difference between said seventh signal and said first signal and varying the rate at which heat is provided to said fractionating column in response to said eighth signal.
Patent Citations (12)
| Patent | Date | Inventor | Cited By |
|---|---|---|---|
| US3901062 | 1975-08-01 | Lynch et al. | |
| US3964975 | 1976-06-01 | Harrison et al. | |
| US3976179 | 1976-08-01 | Harrison et al. | |
| US3981793 | 1976-09-01 | Christie et al. | |
| US3981942 | 1976-09-01 | Zabransky | |
| US3999959 | 1976-12-01 | Bajek | |
| US4262791 | 1981-04-01 | Lynch et al. | |
| US4578151 | 1986-03-01 | Soderstrom, III et al. | |
| US4667508 | 1987-05-01 | Soderstrom, III et al. | |
| CAX661578 | 1963-04-01 | ||
| CAX730129 | 1966-03-01 | ||
| GBX1031685 | 1966-06-01 |