The present invention relates to a machine for testing pavements such as paved surfaces and in particular, roads, highways, aircraft runways and the like for the purpose of evaluating the performance and the durability of paved surfaces and substrates and surfacings under controlled conditions.
An object of he present invention is the provision of a pavement testing machine which can replicate actual road traffic conditions, e.g. by simulating speed, accelerating and braking, wheel or axle loadings and which can replicate actual road conditions on a test road pavement, e.g. by distributing traffic to a realistic pattern or simulating road gradients. Thus the data gathered by testing road formations and surfacings with this machine may be applied directly to the design of highways, aircraft runways and other traffic bearing surfaces.
Another object of the present invention is the provision of a method of testing and evaluating the durability of road surfaces, substrates and formations efficiently and safely.
A further object of the present invention is the provision of a pavement testing machine which efficiently and safely evaluates and tests the durability of road formations, surfaces and substrates in a manner that reduces the energy or power requirements of the pavement testing machine.
In one aspect the invention comprises apparatus for testing pavements including means adapted to rotate about a central pivot and having at least one arm extending radially from said central pivot, the outer end of said arm carrying a driven road wheel to contact the paved surface; said machine including means to provide a force to rotate or resist the rotation of the radial arm about the central pivot, means being also provided to vary the vertical forces between the road wheel and the paved surface and the configuration of road wheels.
The present invention may also be said to comprise a machine for testing pavements, said machine including: a fixed centre post assembly engaging a rotatable centre pin, a bolster attached to said rotatable centre pin and housing a slide frame which has radial movement in relation to the bolster; a radial arm connected by one end in a substantially horizontal plane to one end of the said slide frame; a road wheel bogey connected to the second end of said radial arm; a first driving means mounted on said bolster for rotating the radial arm about the bolster; a subsidiary driving means connected to the road wheel and to the first driving means to produce acceleration, braking and constant speed; a retarding means to simulate the effect of road gradients connected with the first driving means to provide resistive force to the rotation of the said radial arm about the bolster; means to recover and reuse a portion of the energy consumed; and means to apply differing wheel loads to said road wheel bogey and to connect bogies with differing wheel arrangements.
Preferably, the first driving means is a variable volume hydraulic pump directly coupled to an electric motor. Preferably a second driving means is a small volume regulated pump directly coupled to an electric motor. Also, the subsidiary driving means are preferably hydraulic motors functioning in the fixed displacement mode, and the retarding means is a second variable displacement hydraulic pump mounted on the bolster section and driven from a gear wheel mounted on the fixed centre post assembly.
Preferably two radial arms are attached to the slide frame and are disposed diametrically opposite each other about the centre post assembly. Each road wheel bogey preferably is capable of containing one axle carrying a single or a dual tired truck wheel assembly, or may contain two axles and dual tired wheels. One or more supplementary wheels which typically equate to light vehicle wheels may be attached through brackets to the bogies.
The present invention further provides a method of testing and evaluating the performance and durability of road formations, substrates and surfacings, said method comprising: arranging a predetermined number of wheels and axles in the bogies of said pavement testing machine; arranging a predetermined loading on said bogey wheels; distributing wheel traffic over the test pavements to a predetermined pattern; providing safety devices and cutout mechanisms for monitoring the safe operation of the said pavement testing machine, providing a control system for operating said machine including means to cause the pavement testing machine to perform a predetermined regime of functions and a means to operate the safety devices and cut out mechanisms; and providing a monitoring system for monitoring and recording the performance of said pavement testing machine, the road surface conditions and the safety devices. The predetermined regime of functions includes simulation of acceleration, braking, running at a steady speed, climbing and descending a gradient, varying the distribution of wheel traffic over the breadth of a test pavement, or any combination thereof, stopping, starting at predetermined times and running the pavement testing machine for a predetermined time or predetermined distance, or any combination thereof. The duration of such testing regimes may extend over periods of days or weeks during which the machine operates without human attendance, records its operating and testing data and may be monitored or interrogated by a conventional telephone link from points which are remote from the test site.
The present invention further provides an energy recuperation system which may be applied to a machine which utilizes hydraulic driving means, said system comprising: the extraction of energy from said machine when said machine is in a braking mode which is concurrent with a driving mode in the same or in a separate hydraulic loop; and the re-introduction of said energy into the hydraulic power system to augment the external driving power.
By way of example only, a preferred embodiment of the present invention will be described with reference to and as shown in the accompanying drawings in which:
FIG. 1 is a side view of the machine showing only one radial arm also showing a typical test pavement
FIG. 2 is a plan view of the machine as shown in FIG. 1 and part of the surface of a test track.
FIG. 3 is a side view of machine of the present invention showing a partial view of radial arm and its associated componentry.
FIG. 4 is a plan view of the machine as shown in FIG. 3.
FIG. 5 is a sectional view of part of the fixed centre post and bolster assembly.
FIG. 6 is a partially cut away side view of one of the road wheel bogies.
FIG. 7 is a section view along line A.A of FIG. 6.
FIG. 8 is a partly cut away section view of the bolster, slide frame and slide frame actuating rams.
FIG. 9 is a schematic representation of the various driving means of the hydraulic system of the present invention;
Referring to the drawings and particularly to FIGS. 1 and 2, the machine has a fixed centre post assembly 3, to which is rotationally attached a rigid bolster 4 which houses a double ended slide frame 5, (see more particularly FIG. 3). Two opposed articulated radial arms 6 are connected at their inner ends by horizontal hinges 40 one to each end of the slide frame 5, and a road wheel bogey 7 is connected by a system of struts 27 to the outer end of each arm 6. A first variable volume hydraulic pump 8 is attached to the bolster 4 above the slide frame 5 and is connected to an electric motor 9 which is also mounted on the bolster 4 above the slide frame 5. A hydraulic motor 10, which functions in the fixed displacement mode, is mounted in the axle housing 11 of each road wheel bogey 7. A second variable displacement hydraulic pump 12 is rigidly mounted on the bolster 4 above the slide frame 5.
As shown in FIG. 5 the fixed centre post assembly 3 is bolted to a central foundation 13 and contains two bearings 14 one situated in the base and the other on the top of the assembly 3. A central shaft 15 is hollow and carries electrical and control cables. The assembly 3 also contains electrical slip rings (not shown) for the transmission of power and control data to and from the pavement testing machine 2.
A main gear ring 17 is rigidly attached in a substantially horizontal position to the centre post assembly 3 and positioned below the bolster 4. A pinion 18, attached to the input shaft of the second hydraulic pump 12 engages the main gear ring 17, thus providing a driving means for said pump 12. A gear box 41, attached to the bolster 4 is coupled to the main gear ring 17, and engages the second hydraulic pump 12 via a second gear box 42, thus providing driving means for said pump 12.
The bolster 4 includes a rigid top frame 43 and a rigid bottom frame 44, both lying in a substantially horizontal plane and being preferably rectangular in plan and in cross-section. The top and bottom frames 43, 44 are rigidly connected together at the four corners of the bolster 4. The slide frame 5 within the bolster 4 is powered by two hydraulic rams 19 (see FIG. 8) which are positioned in a substantially horizontal plane one on each side of the centre post assembly 3 between the ends of the slide frame 5. The hydraulic rams 19 impose radial movement about the centre post assembly 3 of the slide frame 5 in a substantially horizontal plane within the bolster 4. The hydraulic rams 19 may be driven by a volume controlled pump 20 attached to the bolster 4 and coupled to the electric motor 9.
The slide frame 5 includes stiffened and reinforced corner members 21. The braking or acceleration of the pavement testing machine 2 imposes torsion on the slide frame 5 and this torsion, plus gradient forces and any other forces on the slide frame 5 resulting from the rotation of the pavement testing machine 2 are borne by four nests of rollers 22 one about each corner of the slide frame 5. The rollers 22 are positioned between the slide frame corner members 21 and the bolster 4, and on the top and directly underneath the slide frame corners 21, between the slide frame ends 23 and the bolster frame 43/44.
The two opposed articulated radial arms 6 are each constructed of four main chords 24 and braces 25 of a rigid material. A lockable double hinge 26 is set in approximately the middle of each arm 6 in order to enable movement of the road wheel bogey 7 to and from the pavement 100 being tested or being relayed.
A sensitive strain gauge (not shown) of known type is attached preferably to one of the braces 25 on each radial arm 6. This gauge is set to gauge the stress on the arm 6 when compared with a pre-set maximum stress limit. If this pre-set limit is approached by a predetermined amount, power to the electric motor 9 is cut-off.
Each road wheel bogey 7 (see particularly FIG. 4) is connected to each radial arm 6 by a system of struts 27 and an axle arrangement 32 connects at a pivot point 28. The pivot point 28 contains a spherical bearing 29 and a worm wheel and screw 30 (see FIG. 6) to allow the wheels 31 to move in a vertical plane and for angular adjustment of the wheels 31 and axle 33 in the horizontal plane. This latter adjustment allows a limited variation in the slip angle of the wheels 31 relative to the pavement 100. The distance between centre line 33 and said pivot point 28 preferably corresponds with a typical track width of a motor vehicle. The axle 32 is constrained to move in a vertical path by a Watts linkage 34 which gives controlled rotational movement of the wheel 31 and axle housing 11 in a vertical plane to reproduce the effect of one wheel of full truck axle assembly passing over a road surface irregularity. The unsprung weight on the wheel 31 and the road springs 38 are preferably arranged so as to be typical for a standard motor truck to enable the combination to produce test pavement reactions which typify actual highway reactions caused in this example, by loaded truck traffic.
Each bogey 7 may have one axle 32 carrying two wheels 31, and preferably the inner of which is fixed to the driving axle with the outer wheel being free to rotate separately. The above described axle configuration and wheel attachment provides a means for preventing horizontal shear forces in the pavement 100 which would result from rigidly connected dual wheels 31 which are constrained to move in a circular path. Optionally the dual wheels 31 can be rigidly connected together for the purpose of evaluating the effect of such shear forces on bends in a highway. Optionally also, a differential system may be contrived to fit between pairs of dual wheels such that the tractive effort is divided evenly to each wheel while still enabling each of the two wheels to rotate at slightly differing speeds, one to the other.
Each road wheel bogey 7 includes a sole bar 36 to which weights 37 (see FIG. 7) may be attached to adjust the axle load. A standard truck spring set 38 is positioned on each axle 32 but is not rigidly attached to the sole bar 36 or axle 32. A spring adjuster 39 bears down on each end of each spring set 38 and is used to compensate for vertical depression of the spring set 38 when weights 37 are added to the sole bar 36, thus maintaining mean horizontal alignment of pavement surface and axle for differing axle loads.
The placement of weights 37 in respect of the fixed mass of the radial arms 6, bogey frame 7 and axle assembly 10,11,31,35, is such that the dynamic forces developed by these several masses when rotating, will remain balanced about the plane of restraint and thus prevent variation with road speed of the vertical force to be supported by the pavement.
In order to keep each spring set 38 in position on each axle 32 and preserve a mean horizontal axle alignment and an even distribution of load between the tires 31, two spring slipper arrangements 45 within the sole bar 36 each contain one end of each spring set 38. Each spring adjuster 39 bears directly on one spring slipper arrangement 45. The spring slipper arrangements 45 permit limited movement of the end of each spring set 38 in a substantially horizontal plane whilst at the same time keeping each spring set 38 in the correct position on each axle 32.
Axle displacement transducers (not shown) attach to the sole bars 36 and connect to the axle housings 11 to monitor and transmit vertical axle movements relative to bogie frames. This transmission is interpreted to present a readout of road profile and to sense a road surface break up which will stop the machine if preset displacements are exceeded.
The sole bar 36 also includes a track obstruction sensor (not shown) and a tire failure sensor (not shown). If these are triggered they are arranged to interrupt power to the electric motor 9.
To allow for differing heights of the pavement 100 to be tested, the centre post assembly 3 may be raised or lowered from its normal horizontal level by a series of packers 50 (see FIG. 5) positioned adjacent the anchoring points 51 for rigidly attaching the centre post assembly 3 to the centre foundation 13. Variations in height of the centre post assembly 3 thus may be achieved by suitable jacking means. Concentricity of the centre assembly during jacking operations is maintained by the centre guide 49.
The wheel arrangement of the road wheel bogey 7 may be altered to correspond to any one of the following in symmetrical or differing combinations:
a single driven tired van wheel;
a single driven tired van wheel combined with a single steering tired van wheel;
a dual tired truck wheel with either one or both tires driven;
a tandem axled, dual tired truck wheel combination with either one or both tires on either or both axles driven; and
attachment of supplementary motor car wheels bracketed from the bogies.
By varying the weights 37, actual wheel loads or any combination of the above described wheel arrangements may thus be reproduced.
The fixed displacement motors 10 may be variable displacement motors and set automatically to produce any desired torque/speed characteristic within their range of competence.
Means are provided to monitor the radial position of the arms 6 relative to the centre post assembly 3. Said means may be a helical bar engaging a nut which is fixed to an element of the slide frame which causes the helical bar to rotate as the slide frame moves radially and by its rotation, to drive a rotary encoder.
Road speed and distance travelled by the machine are monitored by proximity sensors which actuate a PID control loop and counters respectively. A bellows cover arrangement (not shown) may be used to protect the slide frame 5 from weather and contamination.
The above described pavement testing machine 2 operates in the following manner: the first hydraulic pump 8 is connected hydraulically to each hydraulic motor 10 mounted in the axle housing 11. When power is supplied by the electric motor 9 and the output from the first pump 8 is supplied evenly to the hydraulic motors 10, (if more than one bogey is utilised), rotational movement about the centre post assembly 3 is given to the pavement testing machine 2. The hydraulic fluid after passing through the hydraulic motors 10 returns to a reservoir 52. Rotational speed of the pavement testing machine 2 is then regulated by varying the hydraulic output from the first hydraulic pump 8.
The second variable displacement hydraulic pump 12 is driven from the main gear ring 17 by rotation of the pavement testing machine 2. For flat running modes, the control of the second variable pump 12 remains in neutral. To impose a simulated gradient onto the pavement 100, the control of the second variable pump 12 is proportionately advanced, causing hydraulic fluid drawn from the reservoir 52 to be delivered into the same pipe system as is fed by the first variable volume pump 8. The control of said first volume pump 8 is pre-set such that the output of said pump 8 is adjusted to compensate for hydraulic fluid delivered by said second pump 12.
With said second pump 12 set in neutral there is negligible resistance to the rotation of the pavement testing machine 2. As the second variable pump 12 is activated, it imposes a resisting torque on the rotation of the radial arms 6, resisting the driving force from the wheel motors 10. This produces a combination of vertical and horizontal reactions on the pavement which equates to those produced on the road surface by a vehicle climbing or descending an incline.
At a steady speed of the pavement testing machine 2 and ignoring volumetric efficiency losses, the hydraulic fluid flow rate will remain constant. However the system pressure will rise in direct proportion to the tangent of the gradient angle. It follows that for any given combination of pavement formation, wheel loading and speed, a calculated increment in system pressure serves both as a means of imposing a simulated gradient and of monitoring that gradient.
Control System
Under flat running conditions, the first pump 8 can be programmed to give any desired combination of speed, acceleration or braking in combination of up to four modes per revolution of the pavement testing machine 2, or multiples thereof. This can be imposed by means of the speed control loop which is referenced to the rotational speed of the pavement testing machine 2 and is unaffected by variations in volumetric and mechanical efficiency of the pavement testing machine 2 over the range of operating conditions.
Simulated gradients are imposed by a separate control loop referenced to increments in system pressure, above and below those which would pertain if under the particular combination of test track formation, speed and wheel loading, the pavement testing machine 2 was in the flat running mode. The basic system pressure relationship to any one combination of test track formation, wheel loading and speed is first established by trial and recorded as permanent data within the control system. Thereafter, it can be retrieved as a reference curve for controlling simulation of gradients.
Considering the above two control loops together, it will be seen that the first control loop will respond independently to any speed command which it receives; whether on flat running or on a simulated gradient. Its function is to maintain a fluid flow rate through the hydraulic motors 10 which is appropriate to the speed command it has received. The gradient control loop then imposes an increment of pressure over the flat running pressure, which is appropriate to the gradient command it receives. A simulated gradient of desired inclination can therefore be achieved.
Thus it will be seen that the machine is capable of maintaining a commanded road speed independent of all other factors and the energy expended in simulating a road gradient is recovered, less only efficiency losses and the nett energy is returned to the driving circuit. Typically in the gradient mode this allows application to the pavement of 1.6 KW for every 1 KW absorbed into the main pump 8 from the driving motor 9.
Accelerating and braking rates are controlled by varying the ramp angle of the actuator on the first main pump 8. These are hydraulic system responses. Also, an emergency drum brake 48 operated by a suitable fail safe system may be provided. Limitations imposed on the system are the maximum input power from the electric motor 9, the maximum speed at which the pavement testing machine 2 can rotate and the maximum pressure which can be sustained by the hydraulic system.
The control system may be capable of manual operation by manually keying in simple command codes to the on shore computer or of automatic operation by programming a testing regime into the on shore computer. Also, for effecting slow, precise movements of the machine, a portable control pendant equipped with `forward` and `reverse` switches may be plugged into a bogey mounted electrical socket. When fitted said pendant automatically suspends all other means of control and will cause the machine to move slowly in the forward or reverse direction when one or the other switch is actuated.
Method
The present invention further provides a method of testing and evaluating the durability of paved surfaces, substrates and formations by providing a circular test-track of paved surface 100, on which is operated the above described pavement testing machine 2. This will enable a predetermined wheel arrangement and weight loading to replicate the desired actual wheel arrangement and wheel loading on the traffic bearing surface, and to provide a predetermined pattern of wheel traffic across the test pavement and of presetting the geometry of the axles 32 so that the dynamic responses of the wheels 31 replicate those of actual running conditions; and providing a control and a monitoring system. Said control system may be programmed to run the pavement testing machine 2 for an indefinite period. During this period the control system can be used to operate the pavement testing machine 2 to perform and record a predetermined regime of diverse functions. These functions include:
(a) Accelerating, braking or running at steady speed, each in elements of one quarter cycle or multiples thereof;
(b) Climbing and descending a simulated gradient, in combination with (a);
(c) Varying the distribution of wheel traffic over the breadth of the test pavement 100 in combination with (a) and (b);
(d) Any combination of the above; and
(e) Stopping and starting at predetermined times, running for predetermined times or distances and resting for a predetermined time in combination with (a) to (c) above.
Said monitoring system may be programmed to:
(a) Monitor and record data which relates to the loading conditions applied to the pavement 100 and the pavement response;
(b) Record the rate and extent of road surface failure;
(c) Automatically transmit an alarm if the limits of safe working parameters are approached;
(d) Stop the pavement testing machine 2 in the event of severe road breakup, tire failure, track obstruction, out of limit loading, over-temperature or exceeding the limits of safe working parameters or upon unauthorised entry to the testing enclosure;
(e) Maintain a constant transmission to a shore based computer reporting operating modes and status of all systems, the status of all dynamic functions, road surface condition and the status of all safety devices;
(f) Maintain in a computer, a permanent log of all the above functions together with a record of aggregated time and distance run.
(g) Permit monitoring or interrogation of the control system via a conventional telephone connection from a point which is remote from the test site.
Energy System
The present invention further provides an energy recuperation system. As above described, for flat running modes the control of the second variable hydraulic pump 12 remains in neutral; thus it has no fluid output and imposes very limited resistance to the rotation of the pavement testing machine 2. To impose a simulated gradient onto the pavement 100, the control of the second pump 12 is proportionately advanced, causing fluid drawn from the reservoir 52 to be delivered into the same pipe system as is fed by the first pump 8.
If under this condition the output of the pump 8 is not reduced, then the added flow of fluid to the motors 10 would cause the pavement testing machine 2 to speed up and ultimately, lock up. Accordingly, the controls are so contrived as to back off the output of the pump 8 to compensate for the fluid delivered from the pump 12 and if constant speed is required, then the reduction in output from the pump 8 will exactly equate to the full output of the pump 12 less volumetric efficiency losses.
By this means an average of 80% of the climb energy can be returned to the system. For instance it has been determined that up to 80 KW of power can be applied to the pavement 100 with a system input from an electric motor 9 of 50 KW. The energy absorbed in wind and road resistance and into efficiency losses will always be lost to the system.
Some particular aspects of the invention have been described by way of example and with reference to the accompanying drawings, but it will be appreciated that other variations of and modifications to the invention may take place without it departing therefrom.