US 4,561,476 AGrant
Toroidal Pressure Vessel
Issue Date:1985-12-31
•21 Claims
•2 Drawing Sheets
Abstract
A toroidal pressure vessel comprises two annular, complementarily formed axial sections which are intersecured along a duality of annular joint lines that circumscribe and are mutually offset along the axis of the toroid. The axial sections are formed by machining a pair of end portions removed from a length of thick-walled metal tubing.
Metadata
Assignee
- The Garrett Corporation
Inventor
- Bela Bunkoczy
Application Information
Application Number:US 6596061
Filing Date:1984-10-11
Priority Date:1984-10-11
Art Unit:241
Classifications
IPC:
B65D 822
Field of Search:
220137141292281 B;3;5 A;71;75;76;89 A68 R311 R416;463184
Patent Drawings (2 sheets)
Description
Background of the Invention
The present invention relates generally to pressure vessels, and more particularly provides a uniquely constructed two-piece, axially sectioned toroidal pressure vessel used to store and supply high pressure air utilized in various pneumatic control systems.
Conventional pneumatic control systems employ as their motive force a supply of high pressure air contained in a storage vessel which is operatively connected to the various air-driven components of the system through a pressure reduction system that functions to flow a regulated quantity of substantially lower pressure air to the driven components. Depending upon the space and weight limitations of the system, a wide variety of pressure vessel configurations may be used.
Particularly in space-limited applications, the toroidal shape has proven to be a very desirable storage vessel configuration because it permits various system structure, such as wiring and mechanical linkage, to be routed through the toroid's central opening. Thus, for example, in applications where the system must fit within a cylindrical housing of a predetermined inner diameter, a toroidal storage vessel of essentially the same overall diameter may be coaxially disposed within the housing at any point along its length and still permit the unimpeded interconnection of components positioned at opposite ends of the vessel.
Despite the desirability of its shape in many applications, however, the toroidal pressure vessel has heretofore presented several very difficult manufacturing problems which have significantly limited its use in high pressure air supply applications. It is to these problems that the present invention is directed.
The conventional method of fabricating a toroidal pressure vessel is to provide a section of metal tubing of an appropriate length and wall thickness, bend the tube section around a mandrel and butt weld the opposite ends together. Unfortunately, this seemingly simple and straightforward manufacturing technique is replete with inherent disadvantages and intricacies.
For example, it is well known that the area of maximum wall stress in an internally pressurized toroidal body occurs around the annulus of its radially innermost wall section. Thus, to equalize the pressure-induced stress around its cross-sectional area the radially inner wall of the vessel must be significantly thicker than its radially outer wall, with an appropriate degree of thickness tapering between these two extremes. Such equalization of wall stress is desirable, of course, because for a given internal design pressure and storage volume it minimizes the weight and external volume of the vessel. In the tube-bending method of forming the toroid, however, this desirable minimization is, as a practical matter, nearly impossible. Although, as the tube is bent there is a natural thickening of the resulting radially inner wall section, and a thinning of the radially outer wall section, the resulting thickness ratio (which, among other things, is dependent upon the tube section length) is nearly always far from optimal.
This unavoidable deficiency may be partially overcome by the relatively expensive and time-consuming expedient of custom manufacturing a tubing section having an eccentric bore. This is typically accomplished by drilling an axially offset bore in a section of solid cylindrical metal bar stock. The thicker wall portion of the eccentric tubing is then positioned against the mandrel prior to the bending of the tube into the requisite circular shape. As might be imagined, both the drilling and bending steps must be carried out with extreme care and precision to achieve an acceptable approximation of the optimum vessel cross-section. Not only must these steps be carefully performed, but precise design allowances must be made for the unavoidable wall thickness changes which occur during the bending process. In short, what would initially appear to be a straightforward design procedure in many instances turns out to be a time-consuming trial and errror process with a concomitantly high scrap rate.
Another problem associated with the conventional tube-bending method is that it is simply not feasable in the case of small-diameter, high pressure toroidal storage vessels. As a specific example, for an internal design pressure of 10,000 psi the lower internal diameter limit for the toroid is approximately four inches. At and below this diameter limit, metals strong enough to withstand the design pressure are not malleable enough to withstand the bending. Additionally, at these small toroidal diameters it is extremely difficult to properly butt weld the facing tube ends properly because of the very limited work space within the torroid's central opening.
Finally, because of the unavoidable imprecision as to resulting wall thicknesses in the finished pressure vessel an unnecessarily high saftey factor must be utilized to assure that the design pressure limitation may be safely maintained. This necessity, of course, adds weight, external volume and expense to the finished vessel. Additionally, it is often a design requirement that the vessel have a predetermined burst location. Because of the wall thickness imprecision in the tube-bending method, however, this design requirement has also been difficult to meet.
Accordingly, it is an object of the present invention to provide a torroidal pressure vessel, and associated manufacturing methods therefor, which eliminates or minimizes above-mentioned and other problems and disadvantages associated with conventional storage vessels of toroidal configuration.
Summary of the Invention
Utilizing principles of the present invention, in accordance with a preferred embodiment thereof, a two-piece, axially sectioned toroidal pressure vessel is provided, the two axial sections being intersecured and sealed along a duality of annular joint lines which encircle and are mutually offset along the axis of the toroid.
According to a feature of the invention, the annular axial sections of the vessel are formed by machining a pair of blanks resulting from the removal of two end portions of a length of thick-walled metal tubing. During the machining process each of the annular sections is given a nonuniform cross-sectional wall thickness in a manner such that the assembled toroidal vessel will have an essentially equal internal pressure-induced wall stress level around the entire periphery of its cross-section. Additionally, each of the annular sections is configured to have axially offset radially inner and outer annular edge portions. In these assembled pressure vessel the inner and outer edge portions of the annular sections are in an axially overlapped, abutting relationship and define the axially offset joint lines of the vessel. The complementary annular sections are welded along these joint lines.
According to another feature of the invention, the toroidal pressure vessel is provided with an outlet fitting which is welded to one of the annular vessel sections, along the inner surface thereof, prior to the intersecuring of the two sections.
In an alternative embodiment of the invention a depression is formed in the inner surface of one of the annular sections, prior to assembly of the vessel, to provide the assembled vessel with a precisely located, predetermined burst area.
Brief Description of the Drawings
FIG. 1 is a perspective view of a two piece, axially sectioned toroidal pressure vessel which incorporates principles of the present invention and is utilized to furnish high pressure supply air to a pneumatically operated control system schematically illustrated in FIG. 1;
FIG. 2 is a sectioned, exploded perspective view of the pressure vessel of FIG. 1;
FIG. 3 is an enlarged scale fragmentary cross-sectional view, taken along line 3--3 of FIG. 2, through the upper annular pressure vessel section, and illustrates the interior weld joint used to affix an outlet fitting thereto;
FIG. 4 is an enlarged cross-sectional view taken through the pressure vessel along line 4--4 of FIG. 1;
FIG. 5 is a sectioned perspective view through the pressure vessel of FIG. 1 with portions of the upper and lower annular weld joints being broken away for purposes of illustration;
FIG. 6 is an enlarged scale top view of the pressure vessel of FIG. 1 with an upper portion of the outlet fitting bearing cut away;
FIG. 7 is an enlarged scale bottom view of the pressure vessel of FIG. 1;
FIG. 8 is a reduced scale perspective view of a length of thick-walled metal tubing from which a pair of annular end portions have been removed for use as blanks machinable to form the upper and lower axial sections of the pressure vessel;
FIGS. 9A and 10A are enlarged scale cross-sectional views taken through the tubing end portions of FIG. 8 along lines 9A--9A and 10A--10A, respectively;
FIGS. 9B and 10B, respectively, are cross-sectional views through the tubing end portions of FIGS. 9A and 10A subsequent to machining thereof to form the upper and lower pressure vessel sections;
FIG. 11 is a fragmentary cross-sectional view through an alternate embodiment of the pressure vessel which has an interior recess formed therein to provide a predetermined, precisely located burst area in the vessel; and
FIG. 12 is a fragmentary cross-sectional view through an alternate embodiment of the pressure vessel in which the axial dimension of its circumferential cross-section is elongated.
Detailed Description
As illustrated in FIG. 1, the present invention provides a toroidal pressure vessel 10 which is utilized to store a supply of high pressure air (or other gas) used to operate the various components, such as valves, motors and the like, of a pneumatic control system 12. The high pressure supply air is flowed to the system 12 via a conduit 14 which is connected to an outlet fitting 16 mounted on the vessel 10. A conventional pressure reduction system 18, interposed in the conduit 14 between the control system 12 and the fitting 16, functions to provide a regulated flow of motive air to the control system at a predetermined pressure substantially less than the air pressure within the vessel 10.
In a variety of pneumatic control system applications the toroidal configuration of the vessel 10 is particularly convenient and advantageous because it permits various structure 20, such as pneumatic piping, electrical wiring and the like, to be passed through the central opening 22 of the toroid in a direction generally parallel to its axis 24.
As will be seen, the pressure vessel 10 is of a unique construction which affords it several very desirable advantages over conventional toroidal pressure vessels which are formed by bending a length of tubing around a circular mandrel and then butt welding the opposite ends of the bent tube.
Structure and Assembly of the Pressure Vessel 10
Referring now to FIG. 2, the pressure vessel 10 is of a two-piece, axially sectioned metal construction comprising an upper annular member or section 26, to which the outlet fitting 16 is secured, and a lower annular member or section 28. As can be seen in FIG. 5, the axial sections 26, 28 are complementarily shaped to define the hollow, generally circularly cross-sectioned toroidal configuration of the vessel 10 when the sections are intersecured (in a manner subsequently described).
The upper section 26 (FIG. 2) has an arcuate cross-section which defines a concave, annular inner surface 30 and terminates in an annular, radially outer edge portion 32, and an annular, radially inner edge portion 34 which is axially offset in an upward direction from edge portion 32. Edge portion 32 has an annular, axially downwardly facing end surface 36, while the edge portion 34 has an annular, radially inwardly facing end surface 38. Annular champfers 40, 42 are respectively formed on the section 26 at the junctures of surfaces 30, 36 and 30, 38.
Like its complementarily formed upper section 26, the lower section 28 has an arcuate cross-section which defines a concave, annular inner surface 44 and terminates in an annular, radially outer edge portion 46, and an annular, radially inner edge portion 48 which is axially offset in an upward direction from edge portion 46. Edge portion 46 has an annular, radially outwardly facing end surface 50, while the edge portion 48 has an annular, axially upwardly facing end surface 52. Annular champfers 54, 56 are respectively formed on the section 28 at the junctures of surfaces 44, 50 and 44, 52.
In assembling the pressure vessel 10, the outlet fitting 16 is first secured to the upper vessel section 26. Fitting 16 (FIG. 3) has a hollow cylindrical base or neck portion 58 which is inserted axially into a circular opening 60 formed through the wall of section 26. With the fitting neck 58 thus inserted, it is secured to section 26 by an annular weld bead 62 formed along the interior surface 30 around the juncture of the neck 58 and the opening 60.
The ability to make this interior weld arises from the axially split construction of the vessel 10 and presents a distinct advantage over conventional bent tube toroidal vessels. Specifically, in such conventional vessels the outlet fitting can be welded to the vessel body only around its outer surface due to the impracticability (and, in the case of small diameter tubing, the impossibility) of inserting welding apparatus into the tubing. Particularly in the case of relatively thick-walled tubing, it is often very difficult to form an exteriorly-applied weld joint which extends clear to the inner surface of the tubing to thereby form a weld joint whose strength is maximized.
In contrast, the present invention affords the opportunity for the fitting's weld joint to emanate from the pressure vessel's interior surface. In the case of relatively thick-walled vessel construction this interior fitting weld may be supplemented by an exterior surface weld (not shown in the drawings), to thereby assure the desired complete exterior-to-interior surface weld penetration which is often unachievable in conventional compact vessel construction.
Referring now to FIGS. 4 and 5, after the outlet fitting has been welded to the upper section 26, the two sections 26, 28 are positioned against one another so that the annular champfer pairs 42, 56 and 40, 54 are brought into abutment around their facing peripheries. This contiguous positioning of the champfers precisely aligns the ends of the inner section surfaces 30, 44, and creates in the vessel 10 axially offset joint lines 64 (at the juncture of champfers 42, 56) and 66 (at the juncture of champfers 40, 54), joint line 64 being positioned radially inwardly of joint line 66. As may best be seen in FIG. 5, the abutment of these facing champfer pairs also respectively brings into precise alignment the annular inner ends of the end surfaces 38, 52 and 36, 50. The aligned end surface pairs 38, 52 and 36,50 respectively define an annular, right-angled weld channel 68 which circumscribes the axis 24 near the upper end of the vessel 10, and an annular, right-angled weld channel 70 which circumscribes the axis 24 near the lower end of the vessel 10.
With the two axial sections aligned in this manner the construction of the toroidal pressure vessel is completed by forming conventional weld beads 72, 74 (FIGS. 5, 6 and 7) along the axially offset joint lines 64, 66 within the weld channels 68, 70. Because of the unique cooperation between the champfered areas 40, 54 and 42, 56 the welding of the vessel is significantly easier than that required in conventional tube-formed toroidal vessels. Specifically, as may best be seen in FIG. 4, upon the interengagement of the champfers, the upper and lower vessel sections 26, 28 are caused to axially overlap one another around an annular upper area "x", and an annular lower area "y". These axially offset overlapped areas conveniently prevent side-by-side relative shifting of the interengaged sections, thereby holding them in precise alignment during the welding process.
In addition to this self-alignment feature, the relative positioning and configuration of the axially offset upper and lower annular weld joints permits the vessel 10 to be fabricated in even very small-diameter sizes (i.e., less than 6" outer toroid diameter). This distinct advantage arises from the fact that in welding the sections 26, 28 the welding tool is simply passed around the periphery of the torid adjacent its opposite ends--the tool need not be inserted any appreciable distance into the torroid's central opening.
In the case of conventional bent-tube vessels, on the other hand, such small diameter vessels are impractical (if not impossible) to make due to the necessity of clamping the ends of bent tube together (to keep them from springing apart from one another) and then passing the welding tool completely through and transversely around the very small central toroid opening.
Moreover, the offset weld joints 72, 74 are desirably shifted axially away from the plane "S"--"S" (FIG. 4) of maximum vessel wall stress, the maximum wall stress occurring along the intersection of such plane with the radially innermost vessel wall portion. This, of course, reduces the internal pressure-induced stress on the weld joints. It is important to note that this advantageous feature is impossible to achieve in a bent-tube toroidal vessel since its single butt-weld joint must, of necessity, pass through this plane of maximum wall stress.
Although the illustrated weld beads 72, 74 may be conveniently applied using a conventional arc welding technique, other welding methods may also be employed. For example, an electron beam welding process may be used. Additionally, the axially sectioned construction of the vessel 10 lends itself particularly well to the "inertial welding" method in which the aligned sections are axially pressed together with great force while at the same time being relatively rotated about the axis 24. This causes uniform metal-to-metal fusion around the annular joint lines 64, 66.
Fabrication of the Axial Sections 26, 28
As can be seen in the drawings, each of the axial sections 26, 28, as well as the assembled vessel 10, has a nonuniform cross-sectional wall thickness. More specifically, both the sections and the completed vessel have a cross-sectional wall thickness which is greatest at the radially inner periphery, at a minimum at the radially outer periphery, and has an appropriate degree of circumferential tapering between these two thickness extremes.
If this nonuniform thickness configuration is precisely designed into and achieved in the finished toroidal vessel, the result is that the internal pressure-induced wall stress at all points around the cross-sectional periphery of the vessel is essentially equal. For a given size of the vessel such equalized wall stress minimizes the weight and external volume of the toroid, while maximizing its storage volume.
Unfortunately, the attainment of these optimizations is, as a practical matter, nearly impossible in conventional toroidal pressure vessels fabricated from bent tubing. Although as the tubing is bent there is a natural tendency for its radially inner wall section to thicken, and its radially outer wall section to be diminished in thickness, only in isolated instances does the resulting toroidal cross-section approach providing the desired equal internal pressure-induced wall stress in the finished vessel. Even when the tubing is custom formed with an offset bore, such cross-sectional optimization can usually only be approximated.
But in the present invention such optimization is readily, precisely and inexpensively achieved by a unique fabrication method which represents an important aspect of the invention. More specifically, with reference to FIGS. 8, 9A, 9B, 10A and 10B, the axial sections 26, 28 are respectively formed from a duality of annular end portions or blanks 76, 78 which have been transversely cut away from a length of thick-walled tubing 80. Each of the rectangularly cross-sectioned blanks 76, 78 (FIGS. 9A and 10A) is then precisely machined, using a numerically controlled lathe, to respectively form the nonuniformly cross-sectioned axial sections 26, 28 depicted in FIGS. 9B and 10B.
Since neither of the sections 26, 28, nor the finished vessel 10, is the end product of any element which must be bent, there is no wall thickness distortion in the vessel. The equal stress, nonuniform wall thickness designed and precisely machined into the sections 26, 28 is maintained in the completed vessel. Additionally, there is no residual bending stress to be compensated for by unnecessarily increased wall thickness in the vessel.
While the previously discussed method of transversely cutting a duality of end portions from a length of thick walled tubing and then precision machining the removed portions to provide the two axial vessel sections is currently preferred, alternate methods could be used to provide the annular blanks from which the finished sections are fabricated. For example, near net-shape annular blanks could be formed by conventional casting, or by a vacuum forging process, and then finish machined using a numerically controlled lathe or other precision machining apparatus.
Another problem which is easily and inexpensively solved by the present invention is that of precisely locating the vessel burst area. It is often a design requirement that should a toroidal pressure vessel burst, the burst area must be in a predetermined location along the vessel walls. Because of the vagaries in wall thickness resulting from the conventional tube bending process, predicting or actually positioning the exact burst area is a difficult task--often accomplished only by trial and error as to a particular vessel size.
However, in the present invention this problem is solved by forming a small depression 82 (FIG. 11) in the interior surface 44 of section 28 (or surface 30 of section 26, if appropriate) at the desired burst location prior to the welding of the two sections. Since without such depression the pressurized vessel wall stresses are substantially identical around the toroid's cross-sectional circumference, the vessel burst location is precisely positioned at the location of the internal depression 82.
It should be noted that while the illustrated vessel 10 is of a circular cross-section, the vessel's cross-section could alternatively be elongated either axially (as in the alternatively configured vessel 10a in FIG. 12) or radially if desired. The axial sections, such as 26a and 28a in FIG. 12, of vessel 10a can, of course, be fabricated by the same method previously described for sections 26, 28.
In summary, it can be seen that the present invention provides a toroidal pressure vessel, and associated fabrication methods therefor, which lessens or eliminates each of the previously discussed major problems typically associated with toroidal vessels fabricated by the tube-bending process.
The foregoing detailed description is to be clearly understood as given by way of illustration and example only, the spirit and scope of this invention being limited solely by the appended claims.
Claims
What is claimed is:
1. A toroidal pressure vessel having an axis and comprising first and second annular section that collectively define a hollow toroidal body and are intersecured along a duality of annular joint lines which circumscribe and are spaced apart along said axis, said vessel having, around its cross-sectional circumference, a nonuniform wall thickness configured to provide said vessel with essentially equal internal pressure-induced wall stress around its cross-sectional circumference.
2. The pressure vessel of claim 1 wherein said first and second annular sections are axially overlapped along first and second annular areas which define said duality of annular joint lines.
3. The pressure vessel of claim 1 wherein one of said duality of annular joint lines is positioned radially inwardly of the other of said duality of annular joint lines.
4. The pressure vessel of claim 1 wherein each of said first and second annular sections has a duality of axially offset, annular champfered areas, said champfered areas of said first annular section being in abutment with said champfered areas of said second annular section and defining therewith said duality of annular joint lines.
5. The pressure vessel of claim 4 wherein said vessel is of a metallic construction; each of said first and second annular sections has an annular end surface extending outwardly from each of its champfered areas; said end surfaces define a duality of annular exterior weld channels on said vessel; and said first and second annular sections are intersecured by weld joints formed within said weld channels.
6. The pressure vessel of claim 1 wherein said vessel has an essentially circular cross-section around its periphery.
7. The pressure vessel of claim 1 wherein said vessel has an axially cross-sectional dimension and a radially extending cross-sectional dimension, and wherein one of said dimensions is elongated relative to the other of said dimensions.
8. The pressure vessel of claim 1 wherein said vessel is of a metallic construction, and wherein one of said first and second annular sections has an outlet fitting welded thereto along an interior surface thereof.
9. The pressure vessel of claim 1 wherein one of said first and second annular sections has a depression formed along an interior surface thereof to thereby provide said vessel with a predetermined, precisely positioned burst location.
10. The toroidal pressure vessel of claim 1 wherein said vessel has a radially inner periphery and a radially outer periphery, and wherein said wall thickness is greatest adjacent said radially inner periphery and at a minimum adjacent said radially outer periphery.
11. A toroidal pressure vessel having an axis and comprising a duality of annular axial sections which abut and are intersecured along two annular joint lines each encircling said axis, each section having a radially inner periphery, a radially outer periphery, and a nonuniform cross-sectional thickness configured to provide said pressure vessel with essentially constant internal pressure-induced wall stress around its cross-sectional circumference, each of said annular axial sections being thickest at said radially inner periphery thereof and thinnest at said radially outer periphery thereof.
12. The pressure vessel of claim 11 wherein said pressure vessel is of a metallic construction; said joint lines are axially offset from one another; said annular axial sections are welded together along said joint lines; and said pressure vessel has operatively connected thereto an outlet fitting which extends inwardly through one of said annular axial sections.
13. The pressure vessel of claim 12 wherein said one of said annular axial sections has an inner surface, and said outlet fitting is secured to said inner surface by an interiorly formed weld bead extending therealong.
14. The pressure vessel of claim 11 wherein one of said annular axial sections has a depression formed therein in a manner providing said pressure vessel with a predetermined burst area coinciding with the location of said depression.
15. The pressure vessel of claim 14 wherein said one of said annular axial sections has an inner surface, and said depression is formed in said inner surface.
16. The pressure vessel of claim 11 wherein said annular joint lines are axially offset from one another.
17. Pneumatic control apparatus comprising: (a) a pneumatically operable device; (b) a metal toroidal pressure vessel adapted to store high pressure gas usable to operate said device, said pressure vessel having an axis, a radially inner periphery, a radially outer periphery, and a nonuniform wall thickness around its cross-sectional circumference, said nonuniform wall thickness being thickest adjacent said radially inner periphery and thinnest adjacent said radially outer periphery, said pressure vessel including: (1) a first annular member defining an axial portion of a hollow toroidal body, said first annular member having axially offset radially inner and outer annular edge portions, (2) a second annular member defining the balance of said hollow toroidal body, said second annular member having axially offset radially inner and outer annular edge portions, said radially inner edge portions, and said radially outer edge portions, being in an abutting relationship around their peripheries, and (3) a duality of annular weld joints extending around the abutting peripheries of said radially inner and outer annular edge portions and interconnecting said first and second annular members; (d) supply conduit means, operatively interconnected between said pressure vessel and said device, for flowing a supply of motive gas to said device; and (d) pressure reduction means, operably interposed in said conduit means between said pressure vessel and said device, for providing a regulated flow of motive gas to said device at a predetermined pressure less than the pressure within said vessel.
18. The apparatus of claim 17 wherein said pressure vessel has an outlet fitting to which said conduit means are operably connected, said outlet fitting being secured to said pressure vessel by an interior weld therein.
19. The apparatus of claim 17 wherein said pressure vessel has an interior depression formed therein to provide said pressure vessel with a precisely positioned, predetermined burst area located at said depression.
20. A toroidal pressure vessel manufactured by a method comprising the steps of: (a) providing a first annular member configured to define an axial portion of a hollow toroidal body having a radially inner periphery, a radially outer periphery, and a nonuniform wall thickness being at a maximum thickness adjacent said radially inner periphery and at a minimum thickness adjacent said radially outer periphery, said first annular member having axially offset radially inner and outer annular edge portions; (b) providing a second annular member configured to define the balance of said hollow toroidal body and having axially offset radially inner and outer annular edge portions; and (c) forming said hollow toroidal body by respectively intersecuring said radially inner edge portions and said radially outer edge portions of said first and second annular members.
21. A toroidal pressure vessel manufactured by a method comprising the steps of: (a) providing a length of thick-walled metal tubing; (b) removing a first axial portion of said tubing; (c) removing a second axial portion of said tubing; (d) configuring the removed first and second axial portions of said tubing to define complementary sections of a hollow toroid having a nonuniform, radially tapered wall thickness which is greatest around a radially central portion of said toroid; and (e) intersecuring said complementary sections to form said toroidal pressure vessel.
Patent Citations (33)
| Patent | Date | Inventor | Cited By |
|---|---|---|---|
| US1552224 | 1925-09-01 | Murray | |
| US1630037 | 1927-05-01 | Stresau | |
| US1655931 | 1928-01-01 | Langstroth | |
| US1678744 | 1928-07-01 | Olsen | |
| US1816298 | 1931-07-01 | Reifurth | |
| US1847310 | 1932-03-01 | Schmitz | |
| US1917175 | 1933-07-01 | Wills et al. | |
| US1928640 | 1933-10-01 | Boardman | |
| US1934065 | 1933-11-01 | Hermanson | |
| US1991556 | 1935-02-01 | Hopkins | |
| US2028968 | 1936-01-01 | Carlstrom | |
| US2335887 | 1943-12-01 | Smith | |
| US2351387 | 1943-06-01 | Anderson | |
| US2445730 | 1948-07-01 | Kuhn | |
| US2668634 | 1954-02-01 | Arne | |
| US2893589 | 1959-07-01 | Braun | |
| US3108838 | 1963-10-01 | McCleary | |
| US3235956 | 1966-02-01 | Heathcote et al. | |
| US3246394 | 1966-04-01 | Meyer | |
| US3304724 | 1967-02-01 | Blumrich et al. | |
| US3353372 | 1967-11-01 | Rapaport | |
| US3522647 | 1970-08-01 | Holcomb et al. | |
| US3772750 | 1973-11-01 | Hauser | |
| US3943867 | 1976-03-01 | Erfurt et al. | |
| US3951362 | 1976-04-01 | Robinson et al. | |
| US3979005 | 1976-09-01 | Robinson et al. | |
| US4219126 | 1980-08-01 | Oana | |
| US4294662 | 1981-10-01 | Guignard et al. | |
| US4318491 | 1982-03-01 | Nelson et al. | |
| US4372459 | 1983-02-01 | Newman | |
| DE2322223 | 1920-06-01 | ||
| JPX32115 | 1977-03-01 | ||
| JPX2238 | 1979-01-01 |