Background of the Invention
In my U.S. Pat. No. 3,485,521 there is illustrated a seal of the padlock type, in which the body is formed of a synthetic organic plastic with a pair of apertures opening to one end of the body, and the shackle is formed of a U-shaped piece of wire having reverse bent end portions, which end portions, when inserted into the body openings, are locked therein by the end portion being maintained in a flexed condition so that the end of the reverse bent portion digs into the wall of the housing aperture.
Although the seal as illustrated in the above-identified patent has achieved considerable commercial success, it has been found that in some instances it has been possible to work an end of the shackle out of its aperture to enable the seal to be removed and re-assembled without leaving evidence of tampering.
It has been proposed that if the end portions of the shackle were bent outwardly, rather than inwardly, as illustrated in said patent, such attempts to remove a shackle end would cause the extreme end to pierce the outside wall of the housing. However, in such case, the protruding reversely bent end can be cut off, and the remainder of the leg pulled out of the housing. When, after the protected closure has been opened, the seal can be re-assembled by forming a new reverse-bent end portion on the end of the leg that has been cut off.
Such seals must often be removed by authorized service personnel, which can be done only by cutting the spring steel shackle with a special type of wire cutter. Such tools are expensive and often lost by the service personnel.
Summary of the Invention
A seal of the padlock type is provided with a plastic body having a pair of spaced apertures to receive shackle ends, the body having a weakened portion formed between the apertures. In one embodiment the weakened portion may be formed by a narrow slot formed in one or both faces of the body, forming body portions connected by a thin web. The shackle also is provided with a centrally located weakened portion.
Attempts to remove a shackle leg by an unauthorized person which requires that the body be manually held with considerable strength, will break the web, which breakage may be facilitated by the fact that sufficient pulling force on the leg will cause the end thereof to pierce the wall of the body and start a fracture in the web. Further flexing of the web resulting from squeezing of the body will allow the body portions to separate, giving conclusive evidence of tampering.
However, the seal may be easily removed without the use of special tools by intentionally breaking the body so that the two portions separate, and thereafter bending or twisting the shackle so that it breaks at the centrally located weakened portion.
Since in most installations, the seal is used in outdoor locations, in a preferred embodiment of the invention, the slot is deeper than it is wide, to minimize the effect of sunlight on the thin web at the bottom of the slot.
Brief Description of the Drawings
FIG. 1 is a plan view of a seal embodying the features of the invention with the shackle in the open position.
FIG. 2 is a plan view of the seal of FIG. 1 assembled with a closure fastener of a device to be protected.
FIG. 3 is a view of the seal of FIG. 2 as seen from the left side.
FIG. 4 is a view of the seal of FIG. 2 as seen from the bottom.
FIG. 5 is a plan view of the seal assembly of FIG. 2 in which the seal has been broken by attempts to remove the wire shackle ends from the plastic body.
FIG. 6 is a perspective view of the seal assembly of FIG. 2 in which the seal has been intentionally broken, illustrating the method of breaking the shackle to enable the seal to be removed from the closure fastener.
Description of the Illustrated Embodiment
Referring to the drawing, there is illustrated a seal 10, which comprises a housing or body 12 formed of synthetic organic plastic such as polypropylene, and a shackle 14 formed of spring wire.
The illustrated embodiment of the housing 12 comprises a pair of spaced body portions 16 and 18 joined by a thin web 20 forming a slot 21 in both faces of the body. The portions 16 and 18 have apertures 22 and 24 respectively formed therein and opening only to the top 26 of the housing.
The shackle 14 is generally U-shaped to provide a pair of legs 28 and 30, the ends of which have reversely bent end portions 32 and 34. As described in the above-identified patent, the length and angle of the end portions 32 and 34 is such in relation to the size of the apertures that when a shackle end is inserted into a body aperture, the bent end is maintained in a flexed condition in the aperture so that the extreme end (36 or 38) of the end portion digs into the aperture wall to prevent removal of the shackle without leaving visible evidence of tampering. Notches 40 may be provided in the aperture wall to assist in allowing the ends 36 and 38 to dig into engagement with the wall.
The medial portion of the shackle 14 is provided with a weakened portion 42, for a purpose to appear hereinafter.
The seal 10 is normally supplied to the user with the longer leg 28 retained in one body aperture and the reverse bend of the shorter leg 30 projecting into the other aperture, but with the extreme end 38 thereof not entered into the aperture, so that said leg 30 may be readily released from the aperture for assembly with a closure fastener on an electric meter or the like.
Such assembly is accomplished by inserting the free leg 30 of the shackle through the closure fastener opening, and then inserting the leg 30 into said other body aperture, and forcing the shackle legs down into the apertures, to the position shown in FIG. 2.
In the illustrated embodiment the web 20 connecting the two body portions is positioned mid-way between the two side faces of the portions for reasons now to be described.
Since the seal is often used on outdoor electric meter installations, it is desirable to minimize the effect of solar ultra-violet radiation on the thin web 20. For this reason it is desirable that the slot have a greater depth than width, so that if the seal is hanging so that a side of the body is facing south, the web will receive direct solar radiation for only a short time.
Although the web could be positioned on one face of the body, so that the slot would open only to the other face, the seal could then be inadvertently installed so that the side of the seal having the web would be exposed, so that the web would receive continuous radiation. Although such a structure would be suitable for interior installations, the illustrated structure is preferred for exterior installations.
In either structure, it is preferred that the apertures 22 and 24 be so positioned in relation to the web that the extreme ends of the shackle are positioned in alignment with the web, for the following reason.
The usual method used by an unauthorized person to remove a shackle leg from the housing of a seal of the type shown in the above-identified patent is by grasping the housing with one hand and, with a pair of thin-nosed pliers grasping the leg at the top surface of the housing. With manipulation of the pliers, it has been possible to sometimes work the shackle end out of the housing, or to cause the shackle end to pierce the housing so it can be cut off.
However, when the illustrated seal is manually grasped firmly enough to resist the necessary pulling force on a shackle leg, the seal body flexes at the connecting web 20. As the wire is flexed back and forth by the grasping instrument, flexing of the web also occurs. It has been found that the pressure that must be applied to the body by one hand to resist the pulling force that is applied to the shackle almost inevitably causes the body to break in half at the web 20. In some cases the pulling force on the shackle causes an end of a shackle leg to pierce the body wall and the adjacent portion of the web, facilitating the breaking of the web.
After the body is broken, the seal may or may not then be removed by the person attempting to open the device protected by the seal, but in either case the broken or missing seal gives clear evidence of tampering.
The seal may be easily removed by authorized personnel by breaking the seal body and then separating the two body portions with a twisting motion (see FIG. 6) so that the shackle breaks at the weakened portion 42. The two portions may then be removed from the closure fastener and discarded. After the adjustment or repair to the device is completed, a new seal is applied.
Although in the illustrated embodiment of the invention, the shackle is formed of spring steel, it will be understood that in some applications a plastic shackle may be used. In such case the shackle may have locking ridges and each aperture locking fingers as shown in my U.S. Pat. No. 3,467,427 issued Sept. 16, 1969, and the body apertures may be closed at the bottom, as illustrated, or may be open, as illustrated in said U.S. Pat. No. 3,467,427, so that the shackle ends may be pulled through the body for tightening.
Since certain other changes apparent to one skilled in the art may be made in the illustrated and described embodiments of the invention without departing from the scope thereof, it is intended that all matter contained herein be interpreted in an illustrative and not a limiting sense.