Background of the Invention
1. Field of the Invention
This invention relates to the field of balancing of vehicle wheels and, more particularly, to an electronic apparatus and a method suitable for achieving a dynamic balance of said vehicle wheels while using balance weights of a single, pre-selected mass.
2. Description of the Prior Art
As explained in U.S. Pat. No. 3,550,455 to Green et al., it is possible to balance vehicle wheels, for example, conventional automobile wheels, by using balance weights all of which are of a single, pre-selected mass. The mass of said balance weights may be statistically optimized, according to the teachings of the Green, et al. patent, so that one size weight can be used for counter-balancing a wide variety of wheel out-of-balance conditions. The method disclosed in that patent, however, is limited to the use of a conventional light spot or bubble-type wheel balancing apparatus for achieving a static balance condition. That earlier method for using balance weights of a single, pre-selected mass for wheel counter-balancing is further limited in that it requires a user or operator to manually move the balance weights along the wheel rim, in successive trial and error attempts, to approach a position at which a balance is achieved.
While the previously discussed patented method for using balance weights of a pre-selected mass for wheel balancing resulted in a substantial reduction in the cost of inventory and labor required for static wheel balancing operations as compared with prior techniques, our present apparatus and method is superior still, as it results in a dynamic wheel balance with less operator activity being required. Also, that patented method, while having achieved very wide commercial success, is subject to the introduction of operator-caused error relating to both the trial-and-error nature of the method and imperfect practice of the method by operators. The apparatus and method here described provide for highly accurate, automatic determination of the positions where balance weights should be placed, limiting operator involvement to merely setting parameters and attaching the weights. Thus, our present invention provides for both a quicker, more accurate determination of the positions at which balance weights should be placed and a superior dynamic, rather than static-only, balance.
Summary of the Invention
The invention which we describe herein is usable for the purpose of dynamically balancing vehicle wheels with a plurality of balance weights of a single, pre-selected mass.
Accordingly, it is a principal object of this invention to provide an apparatus and a method usable for the purpose of dynamically counter-balancing vehicle wheels, while employing balance weights of only a single, pre-selected mass.
An additional object of this invention is to provide an apparatus and method for counter-balancing vehicle wheels both dynamically and statically in a single operation.
It is another object of this invention that such apparatus provide a visual indication of the positions at which balance weights of a single, pre-selected mass may be placed on the rim flanges of a conventional vehicle wheel in order to achieve a dynamically counter-balanced condition for said vehicle wheel.
Our invention comprises an apparatus and method capable of achieving these objectives. Briefly, we have provided means for rotating the wheel to be balanced, electro-mechanical means for sensing, for each rim flange plane, the magnitude and the location on the rim flange at which a weight of the sensed magnitude could be placed to provide the counter-balancing moment required to correct the out-of-balance condition in each of said rim flange planes and for producing electrical representations of said magnitude and location, means for producing an electrical representation of the mass of said balance weights of the pre-selected mass, a divider circuit for producing a quotient signal representing the magnitude of the weight sensed to be required in the rim flange plane divided by twice the magnitude of a balance weight of the pre-selected mass, said quotient signal representing the cosine of the angular displacements at which said balance weights should be placed relative to the location in each plane at which said sensed weight would provide a balanced condition, means for obtaining the angles of which said cosines are representative, and a visual display means for displaying the positions at which said balance weights should be placed. Dynamic balancing is provided by applying the aforesaid balancing system to both the inside and outside rim flanges, independently of each other.
Alternative embodiments of our invention relate to the situation where two balance weights of the pre-selected size are insufficient to establish a balanced condition in either plane. These alternatives make provision for the placement of a third one of said balance weights at the location on the pertinent rim flange at which it is indicated that a weight of the determined magnitude should be placed.
Description of the Figures
FIG. 1 is a combination diagrammatic, block-function diagram of our basic electronic wheel balancer.
FIG. 2 is a top view of a wheel rim showing the proper placement of balance weights on one flange of the rim, according to our invention.
FIG. 3 is a combination diagrammatic, block-function diagram of a first alternative embodiment of our electronic wheel balancer.
FIG. 4 is a top view of a wheel rim showing two closely spaced balance weights on the top rim flange.
FIG. 5 is a combination diagrammatic, block-function diagram of a second alternative embodiment of our electronic wheel balancer.
FIG. 6 is a front elevation of an arrangement for an operator's panel for our electronic wheel balancer.
Description of a Preferred Embodiment
FIG. 1 illustrates a preferred embodiment of our wheel balancing system. Sensor unit 1 comprises an electro-mechanical apparatus upon which the wheel to be balanced may be mounted and rotated, generally about a horizontal axis. A suitable apparatus for this element would be one such as shown in U.S. Pat. No. 3,732,737, issued May 15, 1973 to Brian Michael Forster. Sensor unit 1 provides four electrical output signals. The first of these signals, WT, represents the magnitude of a weight which, if placed at the proper angular location along the first or inner wheel rim flange defining a plane A, will develop a counter-balancing moment needed to dynamically balance the wheel in said plane; the second, POS, the angular location on said wheel rim flange at which said weight should be located to deveoop a counter-balancing moment in the direction required in order to produce a condition of dynamic balance in plane A. The third and fourth output signals of sensor unit 1 provide the same data relative to a second plane B defined by the other or outer wheel rim flange. All of the electrical signals herein may be either analog or digital, as desired. However, for reasons of economy, reliability, and simplicity of design, we have found digital techniques to be preferable both serial and parallel processing being suitable.
In the case of conventional vehicle wheels, the balancing operation is performed upon the combination of a tire 2 and a rim 3, the combination comprising a wheel assembly 4. In accordance with standard practices established in the prior art, sensor unit 1 is provided with a spindle 5, rotatable about a generally horizontal axis, and wheel 4 is manually placed by the operator on said spindle prior to the electronic wheel balancer being activated.
A gauge member or scale 6 is provided, the gauge member having graduated markings fixed in angular orientation relative to spindle 5. By generating signal POS synchronously relative to spindle 5, a one-to-one correspondence may be obtained between values of POS and angular positions on wheel rim 3 as indicated on gauge member 6. While the graduated markings on gauge member 6 can be as closely spaced as desired, it has been found that resolution to 5.degree. of arc is sufficient for obtaining a satisfactory balance with conventional vehicle wheels, in view of the physical dimensions of available weights. A gauge member provided with 72 evenly spaced radial positions will provide this resolution. Thus, two digits will suffice for displaying the weight positions. Of course, the actual choice of resolution is up to the user, and is not intended herein as a limiting feature.
The mass of the balance weights may either be preset or initially set by the operator. Means such as a thumbwheel switch 7, assuming a digital system, or a potentiometer, assuming an analog system, may be used to allow the operator to set balance weight mass. Thumbwheel switches 7 provide an electrical signal, SSW, representative of the mass of the weights to be employed. Notwithstanding the flexibility provided by a thumbwheel switch, it may be desirable, in order to eliminate one source of operator error, that means 7 be capable of being preset, whereby the operator cannot freely change the value of signal SSW. Alternatively some flexiblity may be added to the system without giving rise to a significant source of operator error by allowing the operator to select from among a multiplicity of pre-selected balance weight masses, as for example, by incorporating in means 7 a multiple position switch.
Divider 9 receives signal WT as a first input 9a and signal SSW, as a second input 9b, divides the former by the latter, and provides an output signal 9c representing the quotient WT/SSW. The latter signal is halved in value by halving circuit 10, which in turn produces an output signal 10a representing the quantity COS .theta. = WT/2.times.SWW.
With reference to FIG. 2, it will be observed that if weights are to be placed on the wheel rim symmetrically about the postion 11 represented by signal POS, the quotient signal COS .theta. represents the cosine of the angular displacement R on either side of the position corresponding to POS at which one each of the balance weights should be affixed to the wheel rim flange to obtain a balanced condition. Thus, in order to achieve a visual indication of the positions 12 and 13 at which the operator should place said balance weights, the signal COS .theta. is first provided to arcosine generator 14. Arcosine generator 14, may, for example, be a read-only-memory (ROM) in which an arcosine table is stored, together with control logic for providing access to the ROM and obtaining as output therefrom an electrical signal .theta.. Adder 15 and subtractor 16 respectively add and subtract the .theta. signal from the POS signal, to generate corresponding signals POS1 and POS2. Signals POS1 and POS2 represent the positions in plane A at which a balance weight of the pre-selected mass should be attached to the wheel rim flange. These may be displayed by any display means 17 as would be considered convenient. For a digital system, display means 17 might be a direct numerical display; while for an analog system, a meter might be used. Other displays are, of course, possible, such as a series of lights incrementally spaced circumferentially around the wheel, so that when the wheel is stopped those lights corresponding to the positions POS1 and POS2 could be illuminated to show the location for placement of the balance weights.
Since there can be situations in which one balance weight at each of positions 12 and 13 will not be adequate to balance the subject wheel, WT may, at times, exceed twice the mass of a balance weight. This will, of course, cause COS .theta. to exceed unity. Arcosine generator 14 is capable of detecting this event and providing an output signal .theta. which will indicate to the operator that the signals displayed at POS1 and POS2 may not be relied upon. With the addition of a third balance weight, however, said third weight being placed at the position corresponding to position signal POS, it has been found that there are very few out of balance conditions which cannot be properly compensated. Accordingly, we have invented two alternative embodiments of our basic invention in which provision is made for using up to three weights of the pre-selected mass in each plane.
With reference to FIG. 3, a first alternative embodiment is shown. In this alternative, means are provided for determining whether two balance weights will be sufficient to achieve a balanced condition. In the event that two balance weights will not be adequate, a visual indication is given to the operator that a third balance weight should be placed at the position represented by POS, and the apparatus then calculates the positions at which the two other balance weights should be placed, assuming the third weight will be placed. The positions for the two balance weights which are to be placed on either side of the central position represented by POS are located by first subtracting the mass of a balance weight from the magnitude of the weight sensed to be required to develop the appropriate counter-balancing moment, to provide an adjusted moment requirement, WT-SSW, and processing the adjusted moment requirement as above.
The limiting factor controlling whether two essentially identical weights of the same known mass can adequately counter-balance a wheel is the physical size of the weights--specifically, the arc length such weights require on the subject rim flange. In moving the two balance weights 21 and 22 closer together, there will be a point at which these weights will be in end-to-end contact, as illustrated in FIG. 4. At such point, the centers of the weights are separated by an arc length S, which is related to the angle .alpha. subtended by the radii to the centers of the weights according to the formula .alpha. = S/R, where R is the radius to the rim flange. For the small values of arc length typical of commercially available wheel balancing weights, the length L of each weight is approximately equal to S. If the position 23 at which the two weights 21 and 22 touch is the flange position corresponding to POS, then the mid points of weights 21 and 22 cannot be placed any closer to that position than about L/2Rradiants.
Means 24 are provided, therefore, for either pre-setting or permitting the operator to initially set the length L of the balance weights to be used. Such means may, in the case of a digital system, be thumbwheel switches. A signal representing radius R may be made available from sensor unit 1, since that is an operator-set parameter and is internally present in sensor unit 1. Divider 25 receives both the L and R signals and provide a signal representing quotient L/R as its output; this quotient signal is fed to halving circuit 26, which produces at its output a signal representing L/2R. The output of halving circuit 26 is connected to the first input 27a of comparator 27, while the output of arcosine generator 14 is connected to the second input 27b of comparator 27. The output signal 27c of comparator 27 is connected to the control signal input 28c of condition responsive controlled switch 28. Condition responsive controlled switch 28 has two signal inputs 28a and 28b, the first receiving the signal WT and the second, the signal WT-SSW, which signal is provided by subtractor 29. The switch 28 is a two-state switch responsive to the control signal 27c provided on control line 31. When the output of comparator 27 indicates that .theta. is less than or equal to L/2R, it provides a control signal 27c which causes controlled switch 28, in response, to connect its second input directly to its output. Switch 28 is latched in this position until being reset prior to the next balancing operation. Resetting switch 28 results in the first input of said switch being connected to its output. When the output of comparator 27 indicates that .theta. is greater than L/2R, it causes controlled switch 28, in response, to connect its first input directly to its output. The output 32 of controlled switch 28 is connected to input 9a of divider 9, the operation of the remainder of the system being as described above.
A second alternative embodiment is shown in FIG. 5. In this alternative, the output 27c of comparator 27 is connected to display 17 for signalling the operator when .theta. is less than or equal to L/2R. Upon the occurrence of such signal, the operation can stop the apparatus, install a balance weight at the position indicated by the display showing the POS signal and then restart the apparatus. Our balancer will then proceed as above described to display the POS1 and POS2 signals defining the positions on the rim flange where additional balance weights should be placed.
Some modifications of these alternative embodiments may be made without materially changing the functioning of our apparatus or method. For example, it is obvious that the inputs to comparator 27 could be signals representing the cosines (or other functions) of the angles .theta. and L/2R, rather than the angles themselves. Were that change made, it would, of course, be necessary to correspondingly change the operation of controlled switch 28; controlled switch 28 should still respond to the relative magnitudes of the quantities .theta. and L/2R as described above. As a further modification, it is also apparent that the quantity L/2Rneed not be separately calculated for each operation of the apparatus if some sacrifice in the efficient use of weights is acceptable. The apparatus described in the alternative embodiments will function properly so long as the smaller value of .theta. for which two weights are used is no smaller than L/2R. Therefore, a fixed value may be ascribed to the quantity L/2R, and if such fixed value is chosen to be just large enough to account for the largest weight which might be used (on the smallest rim expected), only a little efficiency is lost.
FIG. 6 shows an arrangement for an operator's panel for our electronic wheel balancer. Controls 33 and 34 are set by the operator to provide the balancer with rim diameter and width data, respectively. These controls are adjusted prior to the start of a balancing procedure. The wheel is then rotated by the spindle 5 and indicators 17a, 17b, 17c, 17a', 17b', 17c' will display the positions on the wheel rim flanges at which one each of the balance weights should be placed. With 72 evenly-spaced positions on guage member 6, the placement of balance weights as indicated on display indicators 17a', 17b', and 17c' in FIG. 6 is shown in FIG. 2. It should be appreciated that the displays may differ slightly depending on the particular embodiment being used.
It should be further appreciated that there are other ways than those already discussed for determining when two balance weights will be insufficient to properly counter-balance a particular wheel, necessitating the use of a third balance weight at the position corresponding to signal POS. For example, knowing the total moment required to achieve a balance condition, the moment available from two of said balance weights placed at the POS position may be compared thereto. If the two balance weights when placed in such location cannot provide at least the required moment, a third balance weight will be required. In order to make a more practical calculation which includes a factor accounting for the physical dimensions of the balance weights and recognizing that two weights should not be required to overlap, the required moment could be compared to the moment which would be developed by 1.8 or 1.9 times the mass of a balance weight. It is believed that apparatus for making such determinations would be readily apparent to one familiar with the design of electronic systems.
The processing and apparatus are exactly the same with respect to balancing the wheel in the second plane B as they were for balancing in plane A. Accordingly, in order to avoid undue repetition, no further explanation of balancing in plane B is necessary and no more will be given.
While we have described our wheel balancing apparatus and method with respect to only one plane, and have provided figures illustrating an application to balancing in two planes, it should be appreciated that the dimensions and structure of the wheel to be balanced will determine in how many planes balance weights should be attached to the wheel. Thus, for some wheels, balancing in a single plane may be all that is required. In other circumstances, balancing in more than two planes may be required. For conventional vehicle wheels, it has been the general practice in the prior art to balance the wheel in two planes.
It should also be appreciated that our invention is applicable to the balancing of wheels of all types and is not limited to vehicle wheels or to wheel assemblies made up of a separate tire and wheel rim. The system and method we describe would, for example, be suitable for balancing flywheels, rotating machine parts, high-speed gears, shafts, and so forth.
Although some particular embodiments of the invention have been described and illustrated herein, it is recognized that modifications, variations, and alternate embodiments may readily occur to those skilled in the art without departing from the spirit of the invention. Thus, it is intended that all such modifications and equivalents to the preferred embodiment are covered by the appended claims.